social choice theory
The formal study of how individual preferences can be aggregated into collective decisions, including its impossibility results.
As defined in Diane Coyle on Cogs, Monsters, and Better Economics
Where it comes up · 5
- 354 | Christian List on Free Will and Levels of Reality3 claims
- Diane Coyle on Cogs, Monsters, and Better Economics2 claims
- Jonathan Rodden on the Geography of Voting1 claim
- Tyler Cowen on Stubborn Attachments, Prosperity, and the Good Society1 claim
- Dario Amodei1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “social choice theory” →
- Machine learning systems increasingly used in the private and public sectors to make consequential decisions about people's lives are literally utility maximizers—set up to maximize objective functions or minimize loss functions—chosen by computer scientists, despite all the unresolved social choice problems economists know.Diane Coyle on Cogs, Monsters, and Better Economics
- Systematically introducing the idea of sustainable economic growth into philosophy, welfare economics, and social choice theory resolves aggregation problems, because if one economy has a higher rate of compound growth than another, over some decades that situation will clearly be better for almost everyone.Tyler Cowen on Stubborn Attachments, Prosperity, and the Good Society
- The core question of what it means for a policy to make things 'better' lacks good tools in economics; welfare economics has not been seriously revisited since the 1970s texts of Little and Sen, and given dramatic structural changes it needs a reboot.Diane Coyle on Cogs, Monsters, and Better Economics
- Since Condorcet and Arrow, social choice theory shows it is nonsensical to claim a coherent 'will of the majority' exists: cycling majorities mean that whoever controls the agenda — the order in which options are paired — controls the outcome, so identical preferences can yield different collective decisions depending on institutional rules.Jonathan Rodden on the Geography of Voting
- For AI alignment, an empirical, practical approach is preferable to chasing utopian theoretical perfection (whose values, what alignment means), because perfect systems are often brittle; the goal should be to make models good enough and robust enough that nothing terrible happens and we can keep iterating — raising the floor matters more than reaching the ceiling.Dario Amodei
- Social choice theory provides an axiomatic toolkit for evaluating aggregation methods: one formulates desiderata that a good aggregation rule should satisfy and uses mathematical analysis to determine whether rules satisfying them simultaneously exist, yielding either impossibility results like Arrow's theorem or possibility results where compelling criteria uniquely pick out a particular rule, thereby giving strong reasons to adopt it.354 | Christian List on Free Will and Levels of Reality
- Organized collective entities such as firms, corporations, courts, universities, and states can truly be intentional agents in their own right — possessing functional states qualifying as beliefs, desires, and goals, and systematically interacting with their environment on the basis of those states — a realist position about group agency reflected both in common sense and in the social sciences such as economics' theory of the firm and international relations theory.354 | Christian List on Free Will and Levels of Reality
- Unlike physical coarse-graining where the system itself suggests the macrovariables, group-level attitudes are defined relative to a chosen voting method or aggregation rule, but they still supervene on individual judgments relative to the organizational structure that defines the entity — analogous to how a computer's high-level states supervene on low-level states relative to its operating system, with the organizational structure playing the role of a system-relative nomological constraint.354 | Christian List on Free Will and Levels of Reality