self-ownership
The principle that each person owns themselves—their body and labor—and so has rights to dispose of them as they choose, often modeled on property ownership.
As defined in Amia Srinivasan
Where it comes up · 4
- Michael Heller and James Salzman on Mine!3 claims
- David Schmidtz on Rawls, Nozick, and Justice2 claims
- Amia Srinivasan1 claim
- Ross Douthat1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “self-ownership” →
- On Nozick's implicit view, one can exploit one's own talents without making anyone else worse off, but no one else can commandeer or enslave another's talents without mixing their labor with something the person reliably regards as theirs—so talents belong to the individual, not to society.David Schmidtz on Rawls, Nozick, and Justice
- A genuinely liberal society—one that treats individuals as real agents who own themselves—must answer affirmatively the fundamental question of whether a person has the right to say no, to refuse the deal, and to leave with his talents; if society denies that right by claiming ownership of his labor, kidney, or blood, it has ceased to be liberal.David Schmidtz on Rawls, Nozick, and Justice
- While there is something worth respecting in the sovereignty of the body and rights to dispose of one's body and labor, the language of self-ownership is undesirable because it imports a property model that does not correctly capture our relationship to the self; the underlying intuition can instead be grounded in inviolable Kantian autonomy rather than Lockean ownership.Amia Srinivasan
- What we treat as inviolate about ownership of one's body is often technology-contingent: surrogacy raises different ownership questions today when conception occurs in a Petri dish and an embryo is implanted than when the surrogate was literally the biological mother, so technology reshapes the contours of what we permit people to own of their bodies.Michael Heller and James Salzman on Mine!
- Every claim of ownership over any resource in the world reduces to one of just six simple stories—attachment, first-in-time, possession, labor, self-ownership, and family—and all ownership disputes are clashes among these stories, which different cultures emphasize differently but never expand beyond.Michael Heller and James Salzman on Mine!
- Indentured servitude—selling yourself into a form of temporary servitude—used to be common and viewed as normal and beneficial because capital markets worked poorly and it was a way for people without capital to access resources, yet it is now considered disgusting and is banned, illustrating how permissible body/self ownership shifts over time.Michael Heller and James Salzman on Mine!
- The legalization of euthanasia reflects a liberal view of rights that has escaped its Christian origins far enough to become a vision of self-ownership that is false to human existence; the case against suicide is quite similar to the case against murder, and the drift away from recognizing this is a case study in liberal ideas getting far enough from the truth as to become false.Ross Douthat