What this covers
Ross Douthat sits down with Tyler Cowen in this conversation ranging across theology, politics, technology, and culture. Douthat, a Catholic intellectual and New York Times columnist, defends a vision of faith grounded in paradox: that Christian truth emerges not from choosing between competing claims but from holding them in creative tension. He illustrates this method through heresies, which he characterizes as errors of subtraction—taking one legitimate pole of a paradox and severing it from its opposite. The conversation moves fluidly between his philosophical commitments and their practical implications, with Douthat discussing everything from the structure of the church to the role of screens in children's lives.
The substantive range is considerable. On ecclesiology, Douthat argues that Christianity as Counterculture depends on the church sustaining radical practices—celibacy, the Eucharist, uncompromising marriage teaching—rather than surrendering them to cultural accommodation. He contends that the collapse of Thomistic education in post-1960s Catholicism created a crisis of comprehensibility among theologians who were critiquing a tradition their readers no longer possessed. On governance, he argues for recovering female religious orders and nuns in positions of power while maintaining male ordination. Beyond the church, Douthat forecasts that technology—especially artificial intelligence, genetic engineering, and digital devices—poses the signature political challenge of coming centuries, yet American culture resists the regulatory control such power demands. He also examines how cable television and social media differently shape polarization, sketches an optimistic (if unlikely) future of Euro-African Catholic renewal, and defends the educational common sense of a Butlerian Jihad against childhood screen exposure.
Douthat argues that the truth about human existence (and the heart of Catholicism) lies in holding seemingly paradoxical elements in synthesis rather than resolving them by cutting one away, and that this 'both-and' instinct shapes his views on heresy, narrative, politics, and the church's countercultural radicalism.
- Heresies err by taking one element meant to be held in tension and running with it to the exclusion of others
- God reveals himself primarily through narrative, so approaching faith through stories and aesthetics is legitimate
- The church's value lies in sustaining radical, countercultural cores (Eucharist, celibacy, marriage teaching) rather than surrendering them to the dominant culture
Liberal rights theory, divorced from Christian origins, produces false anthropology about self-ownership and individual autonomy.
- The legalization of euthanasia reflects a liberal view of rights that has escaped its Christian origins far enough to become a vision of self-ownership that is false to human existence; the case against suicide is quite similar to the case against murder, and the drift away from recognizing this is a case study in liberal ideas getting far enough from the truth as to become false.
“this sort of liberal view of rights has so far escaped its Christian origins as to become a vision of self-ownership that I think is not actually true to human existence”
- Particular Christian ideas about the individual, the individual's relationship to God, and 'render unto Caesar' eventually develop into the constituent forms of modern liberal democracy — though one can read liberal democracy either as a happy development out of Christianity or as a rebellious stepchild that banished its parent.
“these sort of embedded ideas eventually develop into the constituent forms of modern liberal democracy”
- Conservatism is particularist by definition and varies with cultural context, so 'conservative Christian' makes sense only provisionally — when a universal faith has taken over a particular piece of the world and one is trying to preserve its influence there — but that is always contingent and temporary, since Christianity is at root a more radical religion.
“I think conservatism is particularist, sort of by the definition, yes. And I think that every form of conservatism is going to be different depending on the cultural context”
The Church's crisis stems from collapse of religious life and abandonment of radical countercultural witness in favor of lay accommodation.
- Much of the crisis in Catholicism over the last 60-70 years can be distilled to a collapse in the sense of the importance of consecrated religious life; while Opus Dei's lay apostolate is admirable and well-tailored to secular society, the ultimate revival of the church requires a more radical model of priests, nuns, and religious orders — and the 'Age of the Laity' has been a disaster for the church.
“a big part of the crisis in Catholicism in the last 60 or 70 years can simply be distilled to a collapse in the sense of the importance of religious life, of consecrated life, of the priesthood, religious orders, sisters and brothers”
- Although there is no dogmatic prohibition on ordaining married men, large-scale married priests would be seen as the church giving up on the elevation of celibacy — one of its most valuable countercultural teachings, that a life can be lived well without sex — trading the promise of renewal for effective cultural surrender; structural impediments (a bureaucracy not set up to support priests' families) also matter greatly.
“for the church to give up on the elevation of celibacy, in a way that large-scale married priests inevitably would be seen as doing, would not be a likely source of revitalization and revival in the long run”
- The priesthood should remain male because the priest stands in the person of Jesus Christ in enacting the mass, but the church can and should integrate women more fully into its governance — preferably through a revival of female religious orders and nuns in positions of power in Rome rather than through laywomen or by changing the understanding of the priesthood as the Episcopalians have attempted.
“the enactment of the sacrifice of the mass depends on priests who can stand in the person of Jesus Christ and that it makes sense for them to be men”
Catholic truth is found in liturgy and narrative encounter with Scripture, not abstract theology or modern adaptation.
- Because God has revealed himself primarily through narrative — the Old and New Testaments are above all stories, and God even enters the story as a character — it is not just acceptable but plausible to approach him through narrative, poetry, and art; this explains why Western intellectual Christians have been so heavily shaped by storytellers like Lewis, Tolkien, and Chesterton.
“the fact that God is a storyteller, tells us something reasonable about how best to approach him and that it is not just OK, but completely plausible to approach him through narrative, through poetry, through art, through stories”
- The heart of Catholicism lies not in abstract theology but in the link between the New Testament and the ordinary liturgical life of the church — the aha moment comes from connecting the Eucharist and the everyday life of Catholic churches to the startling things Jesus says about his body and blood, rather than from theological commentary.
“the heart of the connection between Catholicism as a religion and the startling, striking world of the New Testament lies more in liturgical life, the lives of the saints, the sort of everyday stuff of the Catholic Church rather than the abstract arguments”
- Douthat's objection to a therapeutic shift on Catholic divorce teaching is primarily that the church would risk betraying its connection to Jesus, not merely the sociological argument that stricter churches weather modernity better; the New Testament presents marriage teaching as a radicalization of Jewish law, and the church has maintained that radical fidelity, which Douthat would rather not see softly surrendered.
“the reason the issue is particularly important to me, and the reason I've written about it so much, is that I think the church is risking betraying its connection to Jesus. And that's . . . The sociological stuff is important, but it's secondary.”
- Post-1960s Catholic theologians wrote as critics of a stale Thomistic foundation while assuming their readers possessed an 1880s or 1940s Catholic education; because they themselves hastened the collapse of that Thomistic consensus, their works no longer make sense to readers who lack the missing foundation they were critiquing.
“the collapse which they hastened in certain ways of that Thomistic consensus means that in certain ways their works don't make that much sense”
Western Europe has become post-Catholic, and demographic change coupled with elite misjudgment creates space for extremism.
- As a political analyst, Douthat opposed Merkel's refugee decision on the principle that stability is better than chaos and that a flawed liberal order should be preserved rather than disrupted by large dramatic moves; the decision pushed him toward thinking Europe's elites underestimate how fast demographic transformations can divide societies and create space for extremisms.
“stability is better than chaos. As flawed as the liberal order is in various ways, I want it to hold up. Therefore I don't want leaders to make these big, dramatic moves that I think could have an obviously destabilizing impact”
- Western Europe, historically the ancestral homeland where 'the faith is Europe and Europe is the faith,' has become a museum of Catholicism — a post-Catholic, residually Catholic culture increasingly hostile to traditional religious faith.
“Europe is sort of a museum of Catholicism in this weird way. With some exceptions, but particularly in Western Europe, it's a museum”
- An optimistic future is a Euro-African Catholicism in which African migration, ideas, and leaders help renew and return European Catholics to their faith, exemplified by Cardinal Robert Sarah praising the Vendée Catholics' resistance to the French revolutionary regime — though the likelier outcome is more chaotic, and Douthat's first loyalty is to the church over European culture.
“there is a Euro-African future for the church where African forces, African migration, African ideas, African leaders help renew and enrich and return European Catholics to their faith”
- From a Catholic perspective, given a forced choice between an atheistic, effectively anti-Catholic Europe for the next thousand years and a Muslim Europe, a sincere Islamic faith is preferable to a truly post-Catholic landscape — though the actual choice on offer is not so stark.
“if you're asking me would I rather Europe be atheistic and sort of effectively anti-Catholic for the next 1,000 years, or rather have it be Muslim — perhaps I'd rather have it be Muslim, right?”
Screens and digital technology derange human development, imagination, relationships, and the capacity for formation before adulthood.
- The costs of children spending hours behind screens are likely felt not as crime waves or political tumult but as a numbing effect — bad for imagination, normal relationships, and appreciation of reality — showing up at the margins as increased mental disturbance, difficulty forming marriages and families, and more cultural despair.
“the reason we may not see costs is that it has a numbing effect in certain ways on human behavior”
- Much of the polarization in American life is driven by an older technology — cable television — whose effect on older Americans probably explains more of current polarization than social media does; nevertheless social media has a deranging effect, creating a sense of permanent crisis and reinforcing groupthink, including among journalists.
“it's being driven by an older technology: cable television. And that the effect of cable news on older Americans probably goes a longer way to explaining some of our polarization right now than does social media”
- A short-term 'Butlerian Jihad' should limit or eliminate the use of computers and screens for children in schools up to a certain age, on the principle that young human beings should be given a sustained encounter with actual physical and social reality before being placed in front of a screen — something that should be educational common sense.
“young human beings should be given a sustained encounter with actual physical and social reality before being placed in front of a screen. And I think that that should be educational common sense.”
- The central challenge of the next 100 to 500 years is getting better at exerting political control over technologies (computers, the internet, virtual reality, genetic engineering) to prevent nightmare scenarios; there is a deep aversion, especially in the United States, to such control, leaving consequential decisions to a combination of experiment, market forces, and governments wanting to seem hip.
“the challenge of the next 100 to 500 years of human history is getting better at exerting political control over technologies and preventing actual nightmare scenarios”
Orthodoxy holds paradoxical truths in tension; heresies err by isolating one element and pursuing it to exclusion.
- The Hegelian dialectic can legitimately apply to the development of political and practical responses to social and technological change, but it cannot be applied to certain revealed truths; otherwise you impute dishonesty to God, as if his revelation in one era doesn't hold in another, whereas the orthodox believe revelation is final and God means it when he gives final answers.
“too much Hegelianism leads you to the point where you're saying, "Well, what God is saying in one era just doesn't hold true in another." And that gets you to a point where there's a kind of a dishonesty”
- The truth about human existence lies in seemingly paradoxical formulations held in synthesis; heresies (including Calvinism) err by taking one element meant to be in tension and running with it to the exclusion of others, whereas orthodoxy is the point at the intersection of different ideas that is as close to truth as limited minds can reach.
“tend to take one particular element of you that's supposed to be in synthesis and possibly in tension, and run with it. And therefore the truth about things lies in a place that may seem slightly contradictory”
- The Marcionite heresy is wrong because it solves the apparent tension between Old and New Testament portraits of God by cutting one away (declaring the God of the Old Testament a wicked demiurge), and this same cutting-away logic reappears in the Nazis' Aryan Christianity of the 1930s and 1940s.
“What is the Aryan Christianity of the Nazis, if not the Marcionite heresy given form in the 1930s and 1940s?”
Narrative and story better convey truth about existence and divine reality than doctrinal exposition or theoretical argument.
- Watership Down is the best modern novel about politics because it dramatizes a founding: rabbits encounter different models of political order (a warren surrendered to humanity as a breeding farm, a fascist dictatorship, and an in-between community), with reproductive competition and folktales, where the success of the new warren rests on subordinating the military (Bigwig) and the religious (Fiver's visions) to the politician (Hazel).
“essentially, it's about a founding... you have a group of rabbits who go forth and encounter different models of political order”
- Catholicism is well represented in literature; the decline of Catholicism's importance in literature since the Waugh-Greene golden age happened in parallel with the decline of literature's own cultural importance, and Catholicism hangs over the whole first half of the 20th century — even shaping non-practicing writers like Hemingway and Fitzgerald.
“the decline in Catholicism's importance in literature since that Waugh-Greene golden age has happened in parallel with the decline of literature's cultural importance”
- The narrative superiority of Dante's Inferno over the rest of the Divine Comedy reflects a sincere limit to human imagination in contemplating the beatific vision: we don't know how to tell stories about the story outside our own story, whereas the Inferno tells a story about the familiar world, which is easier.
“We don't know how to tell stories about the story outside our story in quite the same way. And the Inferno is telling a story about the world that we're all familiar with and that's easier.”
- The Sopranos is a better, deeper, more personal and psychological show than The Wire; people who should have known better talked themselves into preferring The Wire because it was sociological and political, but The Wire's characters are Dickensian types you know on meeting them, whereas The Sopranos has a depth unequaled by any show since.
“there's a depth to much of The Sopranos that I think is not equaled by The Wire and hasn't quite been equaled in any show since”
Political elites must address actual social suffering and systemic problems, not merely manage through institutional control and discourse.
- In a democratic society you cannot escape the demos, so attempts to maintain elite control over politics without addressing deep systemic social problems are doomed to eventually produce phenomena like Trump; the proper role of elites is both to block manifestly unfit candidates and, more fundamentally, to care about what is happening to the actual people in actual America.
“in a democratic society, you can't escape the demos. And so attempts to maintain elite control over politics that don't address deep, profound, systemic social problems are doomed to eventually produce... things like the Trump phenomenon”
- Even if a pro-natal policy like the child tax credit wouldn't move fertility much given dominant cultural forms, there is value in building the political-economy foundations for the cultural changes one wishes to see before those changes arrive, so the policy is 'there waiting' for a future cultural shift.
“I think there's value in building the foundations in political economy for the cultural changes that you wish to see even if those changes haven't arrived yet”
- The honest goal of the child tax credit is to help people have more babies — it is social engineering, just as the Wall Street Journal's preferred pro-entrepreneurship economic policies are; there is no pristine separation between an economic sphere that isn't social engineering and family policy that is, and a $2,000 credit is a minimal step toward a much larger $5,000-plus credit that might actually move fertility.
“the goal of the child tax credit is to help people have more babies. That should be the actual goal and when the Wall Street Journal accuses it of being social engineering — it is social engineering”
Some non-mainstream ideas dismissed by expert consensus contain truth, and human desire for absolute truth outweighs safety of consensus.
- Western civilization is decadent, and that decadence has virtues — chiefly the absence of massive bloody civil wars — but some strands of Islam come closer to asking the most important questions about existence, and it is better for human beings to retain that desire for the extreme, the absolute, and the truth than to lose it, even though that desire incites extremism.
“there are parts of Islam that are closer to asking the most important questions about existence than a lot of people are in the West”
- Growing up outside the mainstream amid religious healing services and health-food/New Age culture taught Douthat that there can be things true about the universe not available through expert consensus; while there was much nonsense outside the mainstream (e.g., the anti-vaccine cause is wrong and dangerous), there were also things he held onto as true, leaving him with a standing assumption that some weird ideas now dismissed are actually correct.
“it also gave me an appreciation for the fact that there can be things that are true about the universe that are not available through the experience of expert consensus”
- People with lived experience of totalitarianism tend to fear anything that smacks of totalitarian impulses, which is a normal reaction to being traumatized by authoritarianism — explaining why the three commentators worried about sex being pushed out of American life happened to be of Russian background.
“people who have lived experience of totalitarianism, which I do not, thankfully, tend to fear anything that smacks of totalitarian impulses”
- If humans could actually create a conscious AI it would reveal something about consciousness currently unknown and influence theological debates about the mind's place in the cosmos; Douthat is skeptical that consciousness will arise by accident through Moore's-law doublings, expecting instead that some remarkable, unknown breakthrough would be required, and notes that leading non-theistic critics of eliminative materialism (like Nagel) drift toward panpsychism.
“I'm very skeptical of the idea that we're just going to get through some Moore's law doubling . . . we're going to a recognizable consciousness by accident; Skynet is going to become self-aware or something”
Journalism is a tradecraft bound to deadlines and practical necessity rather than intellectual ambition or unfinished thought projects.
- Journalism is best understood as a trade rather than the work of a 'public intellectual' or 'thought leader': there is a physical slot in the printed paper that must be filled, so you write the column the way a plumber fixes a toilet — and being a tradesman bound to deadlines is more productive than sitting around with unfinished novels.
“there is a sense in which writing a column is — it's like you're a plumber. The toilet has to be fixed, so you fix the toilet. The column has to be written, so you write the column.”
- How people mispronounce 'Douthat' signals class background: the 'Do that' mispronunciation was common in his middle-school years, while the affected French 'Du tá' mispronunciation becomes more prevalent as one climbs the pretension ladder, so you can tell whether someone has gone to graduate school by whether they try to render it as a French surname.
“as you climb the pretension ladder in America, the "Du tá" mispronunciation becomes more prevalent”
- The Alt-Right is very real on the internet but barely real in reality — there is no mass movement, and there are more profiles of Alt-Right leaders in liberal publications than avowed Alt-Righters who will show up; the hard journalistic problem is distinguishing what is real from what is 'just Twitter,' and whether at some point social media itself becomes reality.
“The Alt-Right is very real on the internet. It doesn't seem to be particularly real in reality, but maybe social media is reality, or at some point it becomes reality”
- Male productivity is often closely linked to being bound to other people through having a family and kids; family obligations serve as a motivating force, which Douthat is certain is true in his own case, having married younger than many in his cohort.
“male productivity is often . . . It's often closely linked to being bound to and linked to other people, and having kids and a family and so on”
- Cats are apex predators that have taken over the world through their relationship to humans by hijacking the maternal instinct — their infant-like faces, wide eyes, and meows that approximate an infant's cry trigger displaced maternal feelings in humans.
“they meow in this way that approximates an infant's cry, and they essentially hijack the maternal instinct”
- If artificial wombs are developed, they would create a weird cultural crisis for current pro-lifers while also generating substantial political pressure favoring the pro-life cause; one would see deep religious and left-wing hippyish resistance to the technology even as it offered a technocratic solution to the abortion debate, with the invasiveness of the technology determining where liberalism ultimately goes.
“It would create a weird cultural crisis for the kind of people who currently are pro-life, while also creating substantial political pressure in favor of the pro-life cause”
- Mormonism is quintessentially American because, like an attempt to integrate Islam, Judaism, and Christianity into one story, it seeks to solve the problem of how to integrate the Americas into the Old World–dominated story of Judaism and Christianity; even its sexual ethics that bring it into tension with dominant American culture leave it as American as Woodstock.
“Mormonism is an attempt to do that, not with three religious traditions, but with the Americas. How do you integrate the Americas into what seems like the Old World–dominated story of Judaism and Christianity?”