Michael Heller and James Salzman on Mine!
What this covers
Michael Heller and James Salzman speak with economist Russ Roberts about their book Mine!, exploring how ownership functions in practice rather than in the clean binaries of legal theory. The conversation moves across everyday disputes—from airplane seat reclines to parking spaces to condominium rules—and deeper into property systems governing water, oil, genetic data, and even body ownership. Throughout, Heller and Salzman argue that all ownership claims reduce to one of six recurring stories: attachment, first-in-time, possession, labor, self-ownership, and family. What makes the discussion practical is their central finding: roughly 99.99 percent of ownership conflicts never reach formal law. Instead, norms, etiquette, and informal bargaining resolve them. When disputes do escalate, the question of "who owns what" is always a choice, not a natural fact—and understanding which ownership story underpins each side's claim can unlock informal solutions.
The pair trace how ownership regimes shift when technology, scarcity, or population pressure changes. Barbed wire in the 1860s transformed American land law from a labor-and-possession regime to an attachment regime. Amazon and Apple exploit the gap between what consumers feel they own (a book on Kindle) and what they actually own, retaining deletion rights and capturing a premium on every download. Fugitive resources like oil and water generate Tragedy of the Commons dynamics under state law, while the condominium form, invented around 1960, enabled dense urban living by giving associations—not residents—control, though it simultaneously flattened diversity into identical pattern documents. The discussion circles back repeatedly to Ronald Coase's insight that harm in property conflicts is reciprocal and that assigning rights to whoever avoids harm most cheaply often beats a binary ruling. Heller and Salzman also examine how firms deliberately deploy Strategic Ambiguity and Ownership Engineering to extract value—airlines shrinking seat pitch while leaving the reclining wedge ambiguously owned, or HOV lanes rewarding different behaviors depending on the policy goal.
Heller and Salzman argue that ownership is not a binary on/off fact but a contested choice among just six recurring 'stories' (attachment, first-in-time, possession, labor, self-ownership, family), and that most ownership disputes are resolved through norms and engineered ambiguity rather than law.
- Every ownership claim reduces to one of six simple stories that conflict with one another
- Most ownership disputes are resolved outside formal law via norms, etiquette, and Coasean bargaining
- Owners and firms deliberately exploit ambiguity (airlines, Amazon) to extract value
Property rights regimes have massive material effects despite seeming like technical details.
- Because in the United States (under state law) landowners own the resources beneath their property, the country experienced a fracking revolution that did not occur in countries where the government owns subsurface rights, illustrating how a seemingly minor allocation of property rights produced an enormous real-world difference.
“the fracking revolution which took place in the United States, did not take place in many other countries, because the government owns the space below the ground. Whereas in America... you own the resources under your house.”
Ownership norms and informal dispute-resolution practices solve problems that law and contracts alone cannot.
- The Chesterton's Fence principle—don't remove a fence until you understand why it was built—applies to ownership norms: the informal norms we use to resolve disputes are often extremely important and solve many problems that would not be solved by legislation or contract, so they should not be casually dismissed.
“I also want to invoke the Chesterton Fence, which is this idea that when you see a fence there, it's like, 'Obviously, it doesn't have any purpose. Let's get rid of it. Let's tear it down.' A lot of times, the norms that we use to resolve disputes we might otherwise have are extremely important”
Reframing property conflicts as reciprocal harms rather than moral wrongs reveals creative solutions.
- Coase's deeper insight is that harm in property conflicts is reciprocal and free of inherent moral fault: in the redwoods-blocking-solar-panels case, the trees only harm the panels because the owner wants sun, and vice versa, so reframing the conflict as reciprocal—rather than oppressor-versus-victim—makes it legible and opens creative solutions, and where transaction costs are high you should assign the right to whoever uses the resource most valuably or avoids harm most cheaply.
“the deeper insight... is that that harm is reciprocal. It's easy to think, 'Oh, it's the fault of the tree grower'... But, it's also the fact that the solar panel person wants to get the sun, and the other person wants it. There's no moral issue here.”
What counts as permissible self-ownership shifts over time based on economic and social context.
- Indentured servitude—selling yourself into a form of temporary servitude—used to be common and viewed as normal and beneficial because capital markets worked poorly and it was a way for people without capital to access resources, yet it is now considered disgusting and is banned, illustrating how permissible body/self ownership shifts over time.
“indentured servitude, selling yourself into some form of slavery. Used to be a very common thing. Everybody thought it was normal and wonderful, actually, because capital markets didn't work so well, and it was a way to get access to resources for people who didn't have any capital.”