self-determination
The principle that a people may determine their own political status; invoked by Palestinians and contrasted by Kontorovich with the legal border-determination rules.
As defined in Is Israel Occupying the West Bank? (with Eugene Kontorovich)
Other definitions
The principle that peoples have the right to determine their own political status and pursue their own economic, social, and cultural development without external coercion
Armenia, Azerbaijan, and Geopolitics in the South Caucasus
Where it comes up · 7
- The Disastrous Relationship Between Israel, Palestinians and the U.N.4 claims
- What Palestinians Are Thinking (with Dahlia Scheindlin)2 claims
- Is Israel Occupying the West Bank? (with Eugene Kontorovich)2 claims
- Is Israel Committing Genocide in Gaza? | The Ezra Klein Show2 claims
- Shoshana Zuboff on Surveillance Capitalism1 claim
- Omar Suleiman1 claim
- Armenia, Azerbaijan, and Geopolitics in the South Caucasus1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 13Search all claims for “self-determination” →
- The conflict between territorial integrity and the right to self-determination is a structural problem around the periphery of the former Soviet Union because of embedded ethnic autonomies that was not resolved in the Nagorno-Karabakh case despite a long peace process.Armenia, Azerbaijan, and Geopolitics in the South Caucasus
- Scheindlin is not optimistic about the conflict because she believes Israel can never fulfill its promise to itself of being a democracy—certainly not a liberal democracy—as long as it is preventing the self-determination and freedom of another people.What Palestinians Are Thinking (with Dahlia Scheindlin)
- Because psychologists hold that awareness is essential for self-determination and autonomy, surveillance capital's intentional design of behavior modification to bypass awareness directly erodes human agency, and much of the apparent 'don't care' attitude is itself a product of operations engineered to keep people in ignorance.Shoshana Zuboff on Surveillance Capitalism
- There is a double standard whereby Arab areas (Gaza, Areas A and B) are expected to be free of Jews—no Jews can safely live there—while Jewish Israel contains two million Arab citizens and Area C contains Arabs; the expectation that a future Palestinian state begin free of Jews is, as Abbas has demanded, an unusual condition not imposed in comparable self-determination conflicts.Is Israel Occupying the West Bank? (with Eugene Kontorovich)
- The international community refuses to recognize Crimea as Russia's not because of self-determination (a majority were ethnically Russian) or colonial distance, but because Crimea was part of the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic after Khrushchev transferred it in the 1950s; it therefore became part of Ukraine on independence, and the ethnic argument Russia made (mirroring the Palestinian argument) was rejected.Is Israel Occupying the West Bank? (with Eugene Kontorovich)
- Palestinians have a reasonable understanding that the conflict with Israel has been a long process of their erasure and encroachment, not beginning with October 7th; to them, the October 7th violence was an eruption within a longer trajectory of occupation, settlement, and denial of self-determination.Is Israel Committing Genocide in Gaza? | The Ezra Klein Show
- In the two decades following Israel's admission, the UN presided over a much wider scale decolonization of territories that had been colonial possessions of Britain, France, and other European powers across the Middle East, Africa, and parts of Asia, bringing dozens of new countries into the UN who were highly committed to a model of decolonization.The Disastrous Relationship Between Israel, Palestinians and the U.N.
- Scheindlin holds that if Jews have a right to self-determination—which she affirms—then Palestinians, who have an indisputable claim to self-determination in the region, also have that right, and the question is how to reconcile two national claims to sovereignty in the same land.What Palestinians Are Thinking (with Dahlia Scheindlin)
- Following WWII, there were new international legal rules about the conduct of war and protection of refugees that did not exist when earlier settler-colonial states were founded, so Israel came into existence against a backdrop of evolved international law that afforded Palestinians protection as a recognized people with self-determination rights.The Disastrous Relationship Between Israel, Palestinians and the U.N.
- The International Court of Justice ruled a year ago not only that Palestinians have a right of self-determination but that this right implies the existence of a sovereign state.Is Israel Committing Genocide in Gaza? | The Ezra Klein Show