What this covers

Ezra Klein talks with Yale Law professor Aslı Ü. Bâli about what international law is for, taking the Gaza war as the central case and setting it beside Syria, Yemen, and Ethiopia. Bâli argues that international humanitarian law is meant mainly to be absorbed into military manuals and training before a war, not enforced in courts afterward. She also contends that weaker perpetrators escape accountability when they have great-power patrons, such as Russia shielding Syria at the UN Security Council and the United States backing Saudi Arabia in Yemen. The conversation also covers the United Nations' involvement in the conflict from partition onward.

The historical stretch runs from Israel's admission to the UN through the wave of decolonization that followed. It continues to the early 1990s, when both apartheid South Africa and Israel-Palestine seemed close to resolution, and Bâli frames Palestine as the one case left unfinished. Along the way she notes that the General Assembly, though it cannot make binding law, helped turn global opinion against apartheid, and that the US once treated an anti-apartheid Security Council resolution as non-binding. Klein cites the 143-9 General Assembly vote on Palestinian membership and the lopsided count of resolutions on Israel compared with other conflicts. Bâli counters with the failures of Yugoslavia and Rwanda in the 1990s.

The sharpest and most contested material concerns Gaza. Bâli calls blocking humanitarian aid the most clearly documented war crime. She also describes Israel's reading of military necessity as hollowing out proportionality and distinction, and she lays out alternatives Israel had after the Hamas attack of October 7. She warns that continued selective enforcement could push the world toward fragmented regional orders, and Klein points to the Biden administration's growing use of legal language as evidence that law still exerts pressure.

Sharpest takeaway

International law functions as a system that recognizes formal equality among states while preserving asymmetric power for nuclear-armed permanent members, prioritizing prevention of great power conflict over enforcement of justice, and this structural tension explains why powerful states can violate international law with impunity while weaker states face constraints.

  • The UN Security Council veto mechanism deliberately paralyzes enforcement when great powers perceive their interests threatened, to prevent nuclear escalation rather than achieve justice
  • International law is applied selectively based on power: Syria and Yemen violations go unpunished because Russia and the US shield their clients, while smaller states face accountability
  • Israel's creation occurred after rules changed (post-WWII), making it subject to international law constraints that didn't apply to earlier settler-colonial projects like the US, yet the system still privileges powerful actors over enforcement of decolonization

The claims · ranked40 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.75

In Syria and Yemen, weaker actors were able to evade accountability not because they themselves were powerful but because they cultivated great-power patrons: Russia shields Syria using its Security Council veto, and the United States backing Saudi Arabia has similarly enabled Saudi impunity in Yemen through back-room negotiations and threats.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Aziz Biali

“in the two specific examples you just gave that you began with in Syria and Yemen the reason for this is because smaller or less powerful actors can seek great power patrons in the International System and those very powerful states can disable mechanisms of enforcement and accountability so in the case of Syria it has cultivated a relationship with Russia and Russia has effectively used its veto power at the security Council to Shield Syria from various forms of accountability that were very much on the table with respect to Yemen the source of impunity has been the United States and Saudi Arabia has been able to wield its own influence backed by the United States at the UN through a variety of back room negotiations and open threats”

0.75

International humanitarian law is designed primarily for ex ante incorporation into military manuals and rules governing armed forces training, not primarily for ex post accountability in international criminal courts, so the rules work through internalization by military forces rather than punishment.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Aziz Biali

“let's just look at the laws of war for a moment and see what they're designed to do they're not designed primarily for expost accountability and you know to be used in an international criminal setting they're designed for ex an incorporation in the military manuals and books and rules that govern Armed Forces how they're trained and what they're told they can or can't do”

0.75

The General Assembly, though it cannot issue binding law, has enormous power to shape agendas and set the global understanding of an issue, and during South African apartheid, the General Assembly's overwhelming resolutions eventually shifted the global momentum against apartheid, constraining even the Security Council to eventually pass binding measures.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Aziz Biali

“while it doesn't have the power to issue resolutions that have binding law that are the force of binding law it has enormous power to shape agendas and it did do that even as the US and the UK and to some extent France continued to use their role in the security Council to Shield the South African government the general assembly ended up setting the global agenda for how one should understand South Africa and over time the security Council had no choice under enormous pressure to finally agree to some very very mild measures against South Africa”

0.74

There is a precedent for the United States treating a UN Security Council resolution as non-binding: during apartheid South Africa, the US presented a first security council resolution against apartheid as non-binding and had a debate about how to interpret Security Council resolutions, a pattern echoing the current moment with Israel.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Aziz Bali

“there's actually a precedent for the United States treating a un Security Council resolution and turning around and presenting it as non-binding and strikingly it was in the South African context you had a very similar situation during apartheid that we find ourselves in now in which the UN General Assembly the overwhelming majority of states in the International System passed resolution after resolution after resolution with enormous majorities in support of denunciations of the South African regime of apartheid calls for San arms embargos all kinds of things in the general assembly while it doesn't have the power to issue resolutions that have binding law that are the force of binding law it has enormous power to shape agendas and it did do that even as the US and the UK and to some extent France continued to use their role in the security Council to Shield the South African government the general assembly ended up setting the global agenda for how one should understand South Africa and over time the security Council had no choice under enormous pressure to finally agree to some very very mild measures against South Africa but the very first such resolution passed by the security Council involved exactly the same pattern and then the US delegate turning around and saying well this is non-binding”

0.69

At the beginning of the 1990s there was global expectation that both remaining examples of incomplete decolonization—apartheid South Africa and Israel-Palestine—were on the cusp of resolution, but the two-state solution in Israel-Palestine did not come to fruition while South Africa transitioned to a post-apartheid constitutional regime, leaving Palestine as the one instance since the UN's founding of ongoing incomplete decolonization.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Aziz Bali

“at the beginning of the 1990s there was an expectation globally that both of these remaining dossier of incomplete decolonization were on the cusp of being resolved one of them because of the transition within South Africa to a post- AAR constitutional regime and the other because of the Oslo Peace process and the imminent possibility of the emergence of a Palestinian state in the context of Israel Palestine the two-state solution did not come to fruition and as a consequence now Palestine Remains the one instance that goes right back to the founding of the United Nations of an example that a majority of States at the UN continue to interpret through the lens of incomplete decolonization”

0.68

The United States is the author of most international rules and a rule maker rather than a rule taker, largely because it is the most powerful state in the International System, and this American experience of international law as optional creates a skewed understanding when Americans think about how international law constrains other states.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Aziz Bali

“we are thinking about international law from the perspective of sitting in the United States a country that is the author of most of the rules a rule maker and not very often a rule taker in part because it's by far the most powerful state in the International System and we tend to project from that experience of understanding international law and let's say an allart manner to how all states in the International System might regard international law but that's wrong”

0.68

If the US and other actors continue to erode the international legal infrastructure through selective enforcement, we are moving in the direction of regional fragmented interpretations of international rules, with powerful actors commanding authority within their own regions and becoming stronger, creating precisely the kinds of dynamics that resulted in the world wars of the 20th century.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Aziz Bali

“there is that phenomenon for starters and that indicates a universe in which all actors not just the United States have to either be far more careful about the ways in which they continue to erode the existing International legal infrastructure or in which we are moving in the direction of regional fragmented interpretations of what the international rules are powerful actors commanding Authority within their own neuro broad becoming stronger and over time the production of precisely the kinds of dynamics that resulted in the world wars of the 20th centur”

0.68

In the two decades following Israel's admission, the UN presided over a much wider scale decolonization of territories that had been colonial possessions of Britain, France, and other European powers across the Middle East, Africa, and parts of Asia, bringing dozens of new countries into the UN who were highly committed to a model of decolonization.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Aziz Bali

“in the following two decades the UN presided over a much much wider scale decolonization of territories that had been Colonial possessions of Britain and France and other European powers across the Middle East Africa and parts of Asia and this enormous wave of decolonization brought dozens of new countries into the United Nations newly independent countries all of whom were highly committed to a model of decolonization that enabled populations under colonial rule to achieve self-determination”

0.66

Following WWII, there were new international legal rules about the conduct of war and protection of refugees that did not exist when earlier settler-colonial states were founded, so Israel came into existence against a backdrop of evolved international law that afforded Palestinians protection as a recognized people with self-determination rights.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Aziz Bali

“and secondly following the end of the second world war there were new rules about the conduct of War and the protection of refugees so it was against that backdrop that Israel came into existence”

0.66

On May 10th, the UN General Assembly voted 143-9 with 25 abstentions to grant Palestinians full member status at the United Nations, which was a historic moment because the General Assembly had never voted to grant Palestinians such status before.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Ezra Klein

“the UN General Assembly passed a resolution saying Palestinians qualify for full member status at the when in the end the vote was overwhelming in favor 143 against nine abstentions 25 this was new the general assembly had never voted for that before”

0.61

Approximately 50 countries in the world don't recognize Palestinian statehood, and there is an enormous overlap between those 50 countries and the former colonial powers in the International System, suggesting that support for Palestinian statehood aligns with former colonized nations' grievances about the role international law played in enabling their subordination.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Aziz Bali

“50 countries in the world don't recognize Palestinian statehood and there's an enormous overlap between those 50 countries and the former Colonial powers in the International System and so in that circumstance I think you can see why it is that what you're describing as dis at attention is actually attention to the one case that continues to reflect this long-standing grievance of the global south over the role that international law has played in enabling subordination”

0.61

If Israel wanted to rely on international law for both defense and justice following October 7, it could have engaged in several options: (1) a police action seeking to apprehend individuals responsible, (2) a narrow military engagement targeting facilities that enabled armed actors to cross the border, or (3) strengthening its own defenses, since the October 7 attack was enabled by failure to maintain border security rather than an unexpected capacity on the part of Hamas.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Aziz Bali

“if Israel wanted to rely on an international law here as both a matter of defense and a matter of Justice what would it have said or done so it had a number of potential options it could have engaged in a police action in Gaza seeking to apprehend individuals that they held responsible for the October 7th attacks it would probably have begun with investigation on Israeli territory of who actually was responsible for taking the individuals that had been captured alive on Israeli territory interrogating them and then seeking to gain access to or jurisdiction over those that were held responsible it could have engaged in a much narrower set of engagements attempting to Target facilities that made it possible for armed actors to cross the border in the way it had and primarily it could have shorted up its own defenses because the conditions that enabled the October 7th attack to occur was not some new unexpected capacity on the part of armed actors that represent an an ongoing existential threat to Israel but rather a failure to maintain basic defenses at the border with Gaza”

0.61

The worst conflicts and highest casualty counts since 2000—including Syria, Yemen, Ethiopia, and Eritrea—have involved perpetrators that are not particularly powerful international actors, yet international accountability mechanisms have failed to stop these atrocities, suggesting power matters even when the perpetrators are weak.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“one of the things I was looking at before we talked was is what since roughly 2000 have been the conflicts with the the most terrible casualty counts and when you look at that you actually do see a lot of countries that are not hugely powerful International actors I mean you see Syria on there you see uh Yemen you know and the the Civil War you see uh Ethiopia and arria and all of these and some of them in particular have had terrible atrocities associated with them but the fact fact that the the perpetrators weren't particularly powerful did not seem to create some opening by which the International Community could stop the blood leing”

0.61

During the 1990s, when the United States was the uncontested unipolar power, there were two major crises involving clear evidence of crimes against humanity and possibly genocide—Yugoslavia and Rwanda—yet the US still refused to trigger UN Security Council measures to stop the violence, partly because Somalia had taught Americans that Security Council involvement would create binding obligations to intervene in conflicts they didn't want to be part of.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Aziz Bali

“in the context of the 1990s when the United States was by far the most powerful state in the International System and uncontested sort of unipolar moment there were two major Cris that involved clear evidence of crimes against humanity possibly genocidal crimes and violence one was in Yugoslavia and the other one was in Rwanda and there was enormous International attention to these contexts and yet there was still a reluctance to do the first thing that international law might have required which is to trigger measures through the UN Security Council that would wield international power to get the violence to stop and there were constant calls for this but from the United States perspective an painful punishing experience in Somalia earlier in the 1990s had yielded the lesson that we will not be implicated in judgments by the security Council suggesting that such an obligation might exist for example by characterizing the conflict in Rwanda as a genocide we will not allow this because this will drag us into engagements that we do not wish to be part of”

0.56

From 2015 to 2022, the UN General Assembly adopted 140 resolutions on Israel while adopting only 68 resolutions on all other countries combined, suggesting disproportionate international attention to Israel-Palestine compared to other conflicts with higher casualty counts like Syria and Yemen.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ezra Klein

“from 2015 to 2022 the UN General Assembly adopted 140 resolutions on Israel over that same period it passed 68 resolutions on all other countries combined”

0.55

The clearest and most easily documented war crime in Israel's conduct of the Gaza war is the blocking of access to humanitarian aid and the resulting starvation of Gaza's population, as Israeli officials declared they would cut off all food, fuel, and water, and have maintained control of all entry and exit points, preventing humanitarian aid from reaching the territory.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Aziz Bali

“I think the one that is probably the easiest to document and substantiate is the blocking of access to humanitarian Aid and what is now amounting to the crime of starvation because Israeli officials declared in the immediate aftermath of October 7th that they were going to cut off all food all fuel all water and have proceeded to oversee a scheme in which they control today all points of entry and egress from Gaza and have precluded humanitarian Aid necessary for subsistence of the Gaza population to enter the territory and have also denied humanitarian actors the ability to supply that Aid so blocking humanitarian assistance including food medicine fuel water treatment hospitals that I think is the clearest and most easily established War crime”

0.55

Even the US invasion of Iraq, which had regime change as an objective, did not entail destroying every last fighting age man or disarming all Iraqis, but rather focused on decapitation of leadership and preserving infrastructure for governing the day after—objectives that are typically pursued in war but are not consistently distinguished in Israel's approach to Gaza.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Aziz Bali

“the United States clearly had in mind in its invasion of Iraq and subsequent occupation of Iraq destroying Saddam Hussein's capacity to wield his military it didn't entail destroying every last fighting man or fighting age man in Iraq and indeed it didn't involve even disarming all Iraqis these are not the kinds of objectives that we have typically it's a decapitation of the leadership and then a preservation to the extent possible of infrastructure that will make governing the day after possible it's not always clear in the case of the war against Hamas that Israel is making any of these distinctions”

0.55

The 34,000+ deaths in Gaza have not attracted the same level of international scrutiny as specific incidents like the World Central Kitchen strike, but statements by Israeli military authorities and IDF spokespeople combined with the empirical record of enormous destruction of civilian infrastructure in Gaza make it relatively straightforward to establish that indiscriminate bombardment of civilian areas has occurred.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Aziz Bali

“the deaths of 34,000 plus Gins has simply not attracted the same level of international Focus but there are statements that have been made on the record by Israeli military authorities and IDF spokespeople together with the empirical record of enormous destruction of all civilian infrastructure in Gaza that make it relatively more straightforward than in other context to establish that the war crime of indiscriminate bombardment of civilian areas has occurred”

0.55

The inconvenient reality on the ground is that there are two equal-sized populations of 7 million Palestinians and 7 million Jewish citizens of Israel on the same territory, and it has proven impossible for external pressure or military force to compel Palestinians to simply accept their subordination as a legal matter, resulting in an ongoing conflict.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Aziz Bali

“the inconvenient reality on the ground is that there are two populations of equal size on the territory 7 million Palestinians 7 million Jewish citizens of Israel and it has proven impossible to force through EXT interal pressure or by Dent of arms Palestinians to Simply accept their subordination as a legal matter and so you have an ongoing conflict”

0.55

Israel's interpretation of international humanitarian law prioritizes military necessity over the principles of proportionality and distinction, and describes military necessity with respect to overall strategic objectives rather than answering whether a specific objective in a concrete moment is contributing to a specific military advantage, thereby reinterpreting the rules in a way that undermines both the spirit and letter of humanitarian law and eviscerates the law's ability to protect civilians.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Aziz Bali

“the way that Israel is interpreting International humanitarian law here it's deliberate choice to prioritize military necessity over the principles of proportionality and distinction and also to describe military necessity with respect to its overall strategic objectives rather than answering the question whether this object in this concrete and direct way is contributing to a specific military advantage in that moment is reinterpreting the rules in a way that undermine both the spirit and the law of international humanitarian law because it eviscerates the Law's ability to protect civilians”

0.55

All rounds of external attempts to impose solutions to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict—whether by the UN, the British, or the Americans—have greatly favored the Israeli side, and each subsequent agreement has enabled Israel to retain larger swaths of territory acquired by use of force, which violates international law that prohibits acquisition of territory through force.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Aziz Bali

“all of those efforts that you described of external actors to impose Solutions of one kind or another whether they be unilateral Al the British or the Americans or the United Nations as an international organization one thing they run up against is that they're actually two communities on the ground whose preferences need to be taken into account one of them is asymmetrically more powerful than the other each of the rounds that you described or that we've discussed so far have greatly favored the Israeli side in one way or another the least example of that is the UN partition plan all subsequent plans have enabled Israel to retain far larger swats of territory territory acquired by use of force in a time when international law prohibits the acquisition of territory through the use of force so these agreements these externally backed agreements have systematically favored the more powerful side”

0.53

The institutional design of the United Nations security system deliberately prioritizes preventing great power wars (and the risk of nuclear escalation) over achieving justice, giving each nuclear power the ability to veto action when it perceives its core interests as threatened, accepting the moral cost of bloodletting in peripheral conflicts to avoid nuclear war.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Aziz Bali

“the architecture of the UN endows them with this asymmetric power as a mechanism to keep them inside of the institution negotiating the differences amongst them rather than resorting to extra diplomatic extra political means to resolve their conflicts now imagine a universe in which the great majority of countries agree that the circumstances in Israel Palestine represent a threat to International Peace and security and require imperatively International intervention the United States would interpret such an intervention has a direct threat to one of its most core interests of enormous consequence and so immediately you would be in a situation in which one nuclear power would be on one side of the equation and arguably one or more nuclear Powers would be on the other side of a conflict there is a real risk that any number of geopolitical zones of conflict including Israel Palestine including the Middle East could become the site of a metastasizing globalizing conflict in which one or more of these nuclear States has ranged against the other but the institutional design of the United Nations system is intended to prevent that by enabling each of these powers to paralyze any action when one of these great Powers understands its interests to be threatened”

0.51

The use of 2,000-pound bombs or heavy artillery shelling of civilian areas with civilian populations remaining present is quite distinctive in this context because of its frequency and the high ordinance level, setting it apart from essentially any other conflict the United States has been involved with or implicated in.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Aziz Balli

“The use of such heavy Weaponry as 2,000lb bombs or the shelling with very heavy artillery of Civilian areas where civilian populations remain present is quite distinctive in this context because it's happened so frequently and with such a high level of ordinance that sets it apart from essentially any other conflict to date at least that the United States has been involved with or implicated in”

0.49

The Biden Administration has been shifting its position over 2-3 months and increasingly using international law language as a tool to justify its positions, at times when it previously didn't want to invoke international law, suggesting international law functions as an agreed-upon moral language that can be used to create mounting pressure even when it cannot enforce immediate compliance.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Ezra Klein

“one thing that has been interesting to me is the Biden Administration has been shifting its position somewhat over the past you know I would call it two or three months is that as much as international law has not been able to constrain Israel on its own it is the tool the B Administration increasingly seems to be using as it looks for a way to reconcile its own positions it wasn't there when they didn't want it to be there but when they don't seem to want their position to Simply Be Joe Biden has had enough he thinks they've gone too far it does sort of op operate as this other language this sort of agreed upon language”

0.48

Israel argues it feels there is something unusual about the belief that Israel is unusual—that the US, which was also founded on settler colonialism with enormous violence including genocide of indigenous populations and slavery, has long been accepted as just a country, not an open case file, while Israel remains subject to the question of whether it should continue to exist.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“The View I often hear from Israelis about this is that they feel there is something unusual about the belief that Israel itself is unusual and it's an attack they often lob specifically at the United States which is itself a nation that was settled settled with enormous violence to it um there is a lot of blood in the founding and blood in the the early years of the country and that at some point that is no longer a question right there isn't an effort anywhere to sort of say should the US continue to exist and and to Israelis there are many countries that that look like that that their foundations have a war in them they foundations have an expulsion in them but that country is now kind of accepted as just a country not sort of an open case File whereas Israel they feel like there is somehow softer clay around them than other countries that don't look all that different in their Origins”

0.48

Russia's response to Ukraine involved claiming that the governing authority was illegitimate and needed to be wiped out, but Russia has not articulated expectations of exterminating all government employees (trash collectors, sanitation workers, teachers), and the distinction matters for international law analysis of total war versus limited war objectives.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“I want to go back to something you said a minute ago about Russia and Ukraine because I actually did understand something like the governing authority of this country is illegitimate and a danger to us and needs to be wiped out completely as Russia's at least stated objective of what they were trying to do in Ukraine and I think this gets to this question somewhat of of enforcement where I think Russia's you know General invasion was rejected within international law and yet there is this kind of shimmering crazy making sense around it where Russia did the thing that is most abhor under international law just launched an invasion of a neighboring country for functionally no reason whatsoever and yet Russia maintains its standing in the International System uh as it has you know always been it's sitting there on the UN Security Council”

0.47

There are two narrative tracks about the founding of Israel: (1) it was an act of the UN through the partition plan, and (2) it was a fact of war where the UN was a sideshow. The second track is problematic because it doesn't ask the predicate questions about how international law enabled the partition plan and the British mandate that made the state possible.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Aziz Bali

“I think that the second track that you describe which just views the creation of the state of Israel as a fact of war is problematic for a couple of reasons the first is that it doesn't ask a set of questions that are the predicate to that war being possible how was it that there was an idea that an Israeli state would emerge on a mandate from the Ottoman Empire that was called the Palestine mandate for the population that was on that territory at the time of the end of the first world war that too was an instrument of international law the mandates were created as a consequence of the Versa peace treaty and the British exercised its power as a matter of international law over Palestine”

0.47

For smaller or less powerful actors that are not major powers, international law functions relatively normally: they are deterred from violations by the prospect of sanctions, International Criminal Court prosecution, or other accountability mechanisms, suggesting that international law works as law works domestically for these states.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Aziz Bali

“If we take an average sized country with an average military capacity and an average economy it might be very much deterred just by the presence of the rules themselves from doing things that it could reasonably anticipate would be subject to punishment under the rules like sanctions or punishment like International adjudication”

0.46

The non-binding ceasefire resolution could shift focus from international humanitarian law and rules for conduct of hostilities to the broader question of belligerent occupation and the political and legal future of the territory under international law, asking what a future would look like for an authority that governs 14 million people where 7 million Jewish citizens are fully enfranchised and 7 million Palestinians have unresolved rights.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Aziz Bali

“so this non-binding resolution around the ceasefire could also be seen as the first in a series of steps that might occur in this relationship between International public opinion international law the en assembly International courts the UN Security Council that shift our attention away from the long-standing international humanitarian law framework that has dominated and that has forced us to look specifically at the rules for belligerent occupation and the rules of the conduct of hostilities when Israel engages in a variety of kinds of operations against Gaza or against the West Bank to shift our gaze from all of that and instead return our attention to the question of the entirety of the Mandate and ask a question about what the future would look like politically and legally under international law for an authority that governs 14 million people where 7 million people Jewish citizens are fully enfranchised citizens of a democracy and the other population of the territory the other 7 million people still have unresolved rights”

0.41

British support for Jewish immigration to Palestine was conceived as a solution to Europe's antisemitism and violence against Jews, which had long punctuated European history with pogroms and persecution and culminated horrifically in the Holocaust.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Aziz Bali

“the British authorities were extremely supportive of the goal of Jewish communities to establish a Jewish homeland in Palestine it was something that was conceived of as a solution to an ongoing problem of Europe which was the kind of raging anti-Semitism and the violence that came with it that culminated horrifically in the showa in the second world war but of course had punctuated European history for centuries before that with pograms and persecution across the continent”

0.41

In 1975, the UN voted to declare Zionism a form of racism, though this resolution was repealed in 1991, illustrating the historical oscillation between treating Israel as a colonial project versus a legitimate nation-state within the international legal order.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Ezra Klein

“Israelis have long felt the UN is biased against them in 1975 the UN voted to declare Zionism a form of racism though appealed that in 1991”

0.41

The Palestine mandate was bequeathed to Britain by the League of Nations, and over two decades Britain facilitated increasing Jewish immigration to Palestine as part of the Zionist goal of establishing a Jewish homeland, while the indigenous Arab population sought self-determination, creating an inevitable conflict between two communities seeking self-determination on one land.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Aziz Bali

“one of those was the Palestine mandate and it was bequeathed to Britain to oversee as a mandate That was supposed to enable the self-determination of the people on that territory there were a range of events for two decades as the British maintained this mandate Authority in which you had increasing immigration of Jews from Europe and elsewhere to Palestine as part of their goal to establish a state on the Palestinian territory that would realize the Ambitions of the Zionist movement which was born in Europe in the 19th century and the British authorities were extremely supportive of the goal of Jewish communities to establish a Jewish homeland in Palestine”

0.39

A state department official said they couldn't say a non-binding Security Council resolution calling for a ceasefire would have any impact on negotiations, raising the question of what the point of the UN Security Council is if it can pass a resolution and have it be declared non-binding.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“so you don't believe anything is going to happen as a result of the passage of this resolution so I think that separate and apart from this resolution we have active ongoing negotiations to try to achieve what this resolution calls for which is the um uh an immediate cease fire and the release of hostages I don't know I can't say that this impa this resolution is going to have any impact on those negotiations so I don't expect you to answer this now but to me just stick this in your pocket if that's the case what the hell is the point of the UN of the UN Security Council”

0.34

The UN's judgment in its partition plan was to divide Palestine with roughly 55% going to the Jewish Community and roughly 45% to the Arab Community, meaning Palestinians (who constituted a very large majority of the territory at the time) were accorded less than half of the territory they inhabited, and they objected to this division.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Aziz Bali

“the Judgment that the United Nations made was that the land would be partitioned between the Jewish Community which would get roughly 55% of the land and the Arab Community which would get roughly 45% of the land the Palestinians of the territory were accorded less than half half of the territory that had been part of the Mandate they objected to this they also constituted a very very large majority on that territory at the time but the Arab rejection led to a war”

0.34

The League of Nations oversaw territories of collapsed empires defeated in World War I (particularly the Ottoman Empire in the Middle East) by placing them under mandates—trusteeships in the hands of colonial powers—intended to enable self-determination but effectively facilitating continued European imperial control through a legalized mechanism.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Aziz Bali

“one of the things that the League of Nations did after World War I was oversee the territories of collapsed Empires that were defeated in the course of the first world war and whose territories were now no longer under Imperial Dominion on the land Empire of the Ottoman Empire in the Middle East the territories were not deemed capable of self-government and were placed instead under mandates a kind of trustee ship in the hands of colonial Powers”

0.34

Hamas clearly violated the laws of war on October 7th by deliberately targeting civilians, taking civilians hostage (which is impermissible), and conducting ongoing indiscriminate rocket fire, all of which constitute war crimes.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Aziz Bali

“they clearly violated the laws of war by first deliberately targeting civilians secondly taking civilians hostage which is also impermissible and then ongoing indiscriminate rocket fire is another source of violation so there's undoubtedly war crimes committed by you know armed Palestinian factions including Hamas on October 7th”

0.34

Israel was admitted to UN membership in 1949, and at that time the UN had through peaceful mediation resolved an international dispute that had been a threat to world peace, suggesting international law was functioning as an organizing force for the conflict.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Aziz Bali

“Israel was admitted to membership in the United United Nations and her flag was raised at Lake Success again the United Nations had through peaceful mediation resolved an international dispute which had been a threat to World Peace so that's as of 1949”

0.29

The US stated its position is that a Palestinian state should only emerge through negotiations between Palestinians and Israelis, and the US would veto any Security Council resolution granting Palestine full UN membership.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“to make Palestinians to make Palestine a full member of the UN would take a security Council approval the US would veto that our position is in a Palestinian State should only emerge through negotiations between Palestinians and Israelis”

0.29

Israel's response was framed as seeking to destroy Hamas as an organized fighting force that cannot be allowed to continue to exist as a structure, based on the view that as long as Hamas exists it will continue to plan and find creative ways to strike at Israel's weaknesses.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Aziz Bali

“Israel has responded with the view that Hamas is a kind of organized fighting force that cannot be allowed to continue to exist as any kind of fighting force that as long as Hamas exists as a structure it will continue planning and and using creative means to try to figure out how to how to strike at Israel's weaknesses and so that they need to destroy Hamas they can't just treat it as something where a couple people committed a crime the thing that was Hamas cannot be allowed to exist”

0.24

American public opinion shows consistent majorities supporting a permanent ceasefire in Gaza, but these preferences have not translated into US policy changes without the language of international law to justify shifts.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Aziz Bali

“polls show that consistent majorities in the United States support a permanent ceasefire in Gaza”