
Is Israel Committing Genocide in Gaza? | The Ezra Klein Show
What this covers
This is a conversation between Ezra Klein and the international lawyer Philippe Sands, whose book East West Street traces how the idea of genocide entered law. Klein says he first thought South Africa's 2023 case before the International Court of Justice was wrong, and that he has since watched several human rights organizations and genocide scholars reach the opposite view. The episode's task is to separate what the word means in popular use from what it means in law, then ask how that applies to Gaza.
The first half is mostly history. Sands describes how Raphael Lemkin was shaped by a 1921 Berlin trial and a law professor who told him a citizen was, in the law's eyes, property of the state. He also covers Lemkin's disagreement with Hersch Lauterpacht, who invented crimes against humanity to protect individuals rather than groups. Lemkin lobbied Robert Jackson to get genocide into the Nuremberg proceedings. Sands recounts that both men lost nearly all their families and discovered mid-trial that the defendant Hans Frank was responsible. Lemkin's 1944 account also covered more than killing: it included a preparatory sequence of restrictions on language, education, housing, and movement. The 1948 convention narrowed this, and the convention was barely applied until Rwanda and Yugoslavia.
The second half turns to Gaza. Sands explains why genocide is not formally the "crime of crimes," yet is treated as one, and why courts demand that destructive intent be the only reasonable inference from a pattern of conduct, a bar that a claim of self-defense makes hard to clear. He separates genocidal rhetoric from genocidal intent, and says official statements by ministers more easily link words to acts. They discuss the pressure on judges who would be labeling a state genocidal for the first time, the Croatia v. Serbia ruling, Hannah Arendt on indifference as fertile ground, the right timescale for judging, and Israel's defense. Sands notes that Isaac Herzog and Netanyahu have both read his book.
Sands argues that genocide is a legal concept with a high evidentiary bar requiring proof of intent to destroy a group, distinct from both colloquial understanding and the lower bar Lemkin originally conceived; the question of whether Israel's actions in Gaza constitute genocide turns on whether courts will interpret intent narrowly (self-defense) or recognize multiple simultaneous intents (self-defense plus group destruction).
- Lemkin's original 1944 conception of genocide was broader and did not require proof of singular intent to destroy, but the 1948 convention and subsequent court interpretations have raised the bar significantly
- The legal definition of genocide requires proving intent to destroy a group 'in whole or in part,' but courts have interpreted this to require that genocidal intent be 'the only reasonable inference' from conduct, making it extremely difficult to prove when states claim self-defense
- International law developed by Jewish scholars (Lemkin, Lauterpacht) in response to statelessness and Holocaust now faces its greatest test as a Jewish state argues self-defense in ways that mirror historical genocide defenses
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Lemkin was devastated that genocide was not included in the Nuremberg Statute initially, but flew to London just before the trial began and persuaded Robert Jackson and the Americans to include it as a subheading under war crimes.
“Lmin is devastated that there is no inclusion in the statute of the crime of genocide. But he then flies to London just before the trial begins and persuades Robert Jackson and the Americans to include genocide as a subhead of war crimes.”
Lemkin's original conception of genocide in 1944 included not just mass killing but a preparatory process: identification of group members, restrictions on education and language, restrictions on housing, forced relocation, forced labor, confinement in camps, and only then killing—treating the entire process as genocidal.
“He's very methodical in looking at the preparatory work. He he goes through the idea of firstly identifying people by reference to their affiliation to a particular group. Then restrictions on education, restrictions on the use of language, restrictions on housing. Then they've got to live in a particular place. Then they can't do certain jobs. Then they've got to be gathered together in certain places. Then they're sent uh to camps. Then they're sent to another place and then eventually they are killed. But for him the entire process is a genocidal process.”
Lemkin believed that people are not targeted for harm because of their individual qualities or actions, but because they are members of a hated group at a particular time and place—so law must protect groups, not just individuals.
“Lenin rejects that argument and says people don't get killed or attacked or targeted because of their individual qualities or what they've done as an individual. They're targeted because they're a member of a group that is hated at a particular moment in time and place. And therefore, if you want to protect human beings, focus on the group, not the individual.”
Lemkin's law professor told him that under international law at the time (1921), a citizen was 'no different from a chicken'—property of the state that the ruler could kill at will without legal consequence.
“the professor says to him, because under international law, as a citizen, you're no different from a chicken. You're the property of your country, of your ruler, if they want to kill you, they're perfectly free to do it.”
Netanyahu and President Isaac Herzog have both read Sands' book 'East West Street' about the history of genocide law; Netanyahu was photographed reading it, and Herzog reviewed it for Haaretz—meaning they are well aware of the genocide law they are accused of violating.
“There was a piece in Time magazine about a well a few five six years ago uh profile of Benjamin Netanyahu and the piece included a photograph of him reading East West Street... Um, Isaac Herzog, the current president of Israel... who reviewed the book for harets.”
There is a distinction between genocidal rhetoric (statements that a group doesn't exist, has no right to exist, or should be destroyed) and genocidal intent (the actual motivation behind violent or destructive acts).
“genocide rhetoric is an expression um along the lines that X or Y group doesn't exist or has no right to exist or ought to be destroyed as a group... The classic example is in Rwanda there was a radio station called Had Milin radio a thousand hills which put out really nasty stuff... doesn't actually prove that the acts that follow were intended to destroy a group in whole or in part.”
A 1921 Berlin court case involving the killing of a Turkish military officer alleged to have perpetrated Armenian massacres influenced Lemkin's thinking about genocide, when his law professor explained that under international law the victim was considered property of the state with no inherent protections.
“a case in Berlin in 1921... why is the man who killed the Turkish guy, an Armenian called Tieran, why is he being prosecuted for killing the person who killed his family and hundreds of thousands of Armenians? And the professor says to him, because under international law, as a citizen, you're no different from a chicken. You're the property of your country, of your ruler, if they want to kill you, they're perfectly free to do it.”
Lemkin developed the concept of genocide in the 1930s-1940s not as a legal category focused on extermination, but as a description of systematic attacks on groups that could include restrictions on education, language, housing, employment, and forced displacement as preparatory stages before killing.
“He's very methodical in looking at the preparatory work. He he goes through the idea of firstly identifying people by reference to their affiliation to a particular group. Then restrictions on education, restrictions on the use of language, restrictions on housing. Then they've got to live in a particular place. Then they can't do certain jobs. Then they've got to be gathered together in certain places. Then they're sent uh to camps. Then they're sent to another place and then eventually they are killed. But for him the entire process is a genocidal process.”
Lemkin and Lauterpacht, both Jewish lawyers who lost most of their families in the Holocaust, prosecuted Hans Frank at Nuremberg without initially realizing he was responsible for the deaths of their own family members, and they continued to focus on creating legal concepts rather than seeking personal revenge.
“And all three men, my grandfather, Liam Bholds, Hersh, Schloutact, and Rafael Lenin, lost almost their entire families. And what I have found so striking about their story is that despite the fact that this has happened, and they only learn about this after the war has come to an end, they are then remarkably retained respectively by the British and American prosecutors to assist at the Nuremberg trial... And it's only halfway through the trial that they learn that the man they're prosecuting is responsible for the deaths of their families”
The concept of genocide was developed as a way to protect groups that lack a state to protect them, either because they are at the mercy of their own state or because their state is too weak to protect them.
“The other thing threaded through this book, threaded through the debates we're going to talk about here is the existence of international law as a shelter, as a protection, as a shield for people who do not have a state that can protect them. Right? either they are at the mercy of their own state or they are part of a state too weak”
Lemkin's operating principle was that groups have culturally significant identities and that protecting the diversity of groups requires international law—not just domestic law—to obligate every state to safeguard and protect different groups within its community and prevent them from being destroyed.
“To understand what Lincoln was hoping to achieve, you've got to go back to the 1930s and imagine the world as it existed at that point... The operating principle of Lmin's idea is that that needs to change. We need to firstly recognize that groups have identities that are culturally significant and important. And secondly, we want to protect the diversity of groups in our communities. And in order to do that, we need a law to help us. a law at the national level isn't enough because the state can then just change its law. And so what we really want to do, I'm paraphrasing here, is create an international law which says states, every state has an obligation to safeguard, look after, and protect different groups within its community and cannot undermine their existence, cannot threaten them.”
In international law, genocide is not the 'crime of crimes'—if you kill 50,000 people as a war crime, crime against humanity, or genocide, they are 'all on a level playing field' in terms of legal status.
“in the popular conception, in the public conception, genocide has emerged as the crime of crimes. In international law, it's not the crime of crimes. If you kill 50,000 people as a war crime or a crime against humanity or a genocide, it's all on a level playing field.”
Lemkin and Lauterpacht both lost almost their entire families in the Holocaust, yet they were retained respectively by the British and American prosecutors to assist at Nuremberg, and discovered mid-trial that the man they were prosecuting, Hans Frank, was responsible for the murder of their own families
“And all three men, my grandfather, Liam Bholds, Hersh, Schloutact, and Rafael Lenin, lost almost their entire families... they are then remarkably retained respectively by the British and American prosecutors to assist at the Nuremberg trial... And it's only halfway through the trial that they learn that the man they're prosecuting is responsible for the deaths of their families, their siblings, their parents, their cousins, their nephews.”
Courts have adopted the principle that to infer genocidal intent from a pattern of conduct, the pattern must be such that it 'could only point to the existence of such intent'—meaning the only reasonable inference from the acts must be intent to destroy the group, not other motivations like self-defense.
“The court said to state that for a pattern of conduct to be accepted as evidence of existence of genocidal intent, it must be such that it could only point to the existence of such intent... it is necessary and sufficient that this is the only inference that could reasonably be drawn from the acts in question.”
The judges at the International Court of Justice face pressure in these cases because ruling a state is responsible for genocide would permanently label that state as a 'genocidal state,' which has never happened before.
“they're in this rather awkward position of having to decide for the first time, it'll be in the Myanmar case brought by the Gambia, but then it will also be in the South Africa case with Israel. Do we put the label of genocidal state on the forehead of one or both of these countries, something that has never happened before. And that, I think, concentrates the minds of judges.”
Genocide has emerged in public and judicial consciousness as the 'crime of crimes'—if an atrocity is not called genocide, there is disappointment and a sense that it hasn't been adequately condemned, even though under law genocide is not formally ranked above war crimes or crimes against humanity.
“in the popular conception, in the public conception, genocide has emerged as the crime of crimes. In international law, it's not the crime of crimes. If you kill 50,000 people as a war crime or a crime against humanity or a genocide, it's all on a level playing field.”
In the case of Croatia v. Serbia about Vukovar, the International Court of Justice ruled it was not genocide but crimes against humanity and war crimes, causing devastation within Croatia and the region because people felt their suffering was not given the highest designation.
“I've mentioned the case that I argued for 15 years for Croatia against Serbia on what had happened at the town of Vukavar in the 1990s where Croatia went to the International Court of Justice and argued this was the crime of genocide and the International Court of Justice said no it's not and left the consequence that it was yeah crimes against humanity and war crimes and the consequence has been devastating.”
Klein and Sands discuss Hannah Arendt's concept that indifference, not just hatred, is the soil in which genocide can emerge, and that widespread indifference among Israeli Jews to Palestinian suffering is more concerning than explicit hatred.
“this goes back to you know um Hana Ren's books and and indifference is actually not just hatred but indifference as the soil in which something like a genocide can can emerge”
The term 'genocide' has become the 'crime of crimes' in popular conception and carries more political and emotional weight than the precise legal term, so prosecutors and advocates label crimes as genocide to ensure they are treated with the highest seriousness.
“in the popular conception, in the public conception, genocide has emerged as the crime of crimes. In international law, it's not the crime of crimes. If you kill 50,000 people as a war crime or a crime against humanity or a genocide, it's all on a level playing field. And and the issue that has arisen in my mind is this problem of labeling. What Lenin did was he invented a word that has opened the imagination. It's a brilliant word. It's it's not technical like war crimes and crimes against humanity. It portrays absolute horror.”
Lemkin's counterpart Hersch Lauterpacht invented the concept of 'crimes against humanity' which focused on protecting individual human beings rather than groups, and the two men fundamentally disagreed on whether the law should protect individuals or groups from state violence.
“And there are basically two ideas that emerge at exactly the same moment. Raphael Lekin invents the concept of genocide which is focused on the protection of groups. And then his counterpart who he never actually meets Hersh Lipact who studied amazingly at the same law school comes up with a different conception crimes against humanity which is focusing on the protection of individual human beings.”
Between 1948 and the 1990s, there was essentially no application or interpretation of the genocide convention. It was only with the horrors of Rwanda and the former Yugoslavia in 1993-1994 that new international tribunals began to interpret and apply genocide law.
“Between 1948 and the 1990s, nothing happened really with the interpretation application of the genocide convention. Then in 93 and 94, we had the horrors of Rwanda, which you've already mentioned, and of the former Yugoslavia.”
While genocide law and international courts have limits and cannot immediately stop ongoing atrocities, they establish standards that tell the world this kind of treatment is wrong and should not happen—providing hope and moral clarity even when unable to prevent horror.
“it may not have stopped what happened but it would have given us hope and it would have given us an understanding that what was being done to us was wrong and it should not happen... at the very least that is where we are today. We have standards which tell us... this kind of behavior, this kind of treatment of human beings, of kids, of elderly people... is totally unacceptable, totally intolerable, must be held to account and must be punished.”
Dehumanization—viewing people as 'not like us,' as different and therefore free to mistreat—is the consistent pattern across all mass atrocities and genocides that Sands has studied.
“It's always about dehumanization. They're not like us. They're different. And therefore, we are free to treat them in this way.”
International law operates on the principle that 'rules like other rules are not intended for us, they're only intended for others when it suits us,' but this will eventually harm even those who break the rules when their turn comes to be vulnerable.
“And it rather proves the old adage that the international rules like other rules are not intended for us. They're only intended for others when it suits us. And I think that will come back to haunt because at the end of the day, any community requires protections not only under domestic rules, but under international rules.”
Over time, through multi-decade to multi-century projects of building international legal institutions and norms, international law can constrain state violence, but progress is non-linear—one step forward, one step sideways, one step back, then another forward.
“It will take time. And in the meantime, there will be horror after horror after horror... But it's one step forward and one step sideways and one step back and then hopefully another step forward... it's a multi-decade century uh project and we have to be honest about that but it's a project worth engaging in.”
The prosecutors at Nuremberg had a problem: they had no international crimes with which to charge the Nazis. War crimes existed but were limited in scope to conduct during wartime; there was no legal framework for crimes against humanity or genocide.
“They've got no crimes to charge them with. The only crime that exists at the time is something called war crimes, which doesn't govern the totality of what's happened. And that was pretty limited in terms of its scope.”
The term 'genocide' was invented by Raphael Lemkin, a Jewish lawyer born in what is now Belarus in the late 19th/early 20th century, who was motivated to develop genocide law after witnessing a 1921 Berlin trial of an Armenian who killed a Turkish military officer allegedly involved in the Armenian massacre.
“His own recordings of the path that he took are complex and I noticed doing the research on them prone to exaggeration or sometimes even invention. But it does seem that the crucial factor that influenced him was a case in Berlin in 1921. Uh the killing of a Turkish military guy who was alleged to have been involved in the massacre of the Armenian population.”
To prove genocidal intent, one must show a connection between official rhetoric and the actual acts of killing, targeting, starvation, or extermination—and if the expression is made by a minister in official capacity, this connection is much easier to establish.
“You have to show a connection between the expression and the act on the ground. If the expression is made by a minister acting in an official capacity, it's going to be much easier to show a connection between an expression of genocidal intent as rhetoric on the one hand and the act of killing or targeting or exterminating on the ground on the other hand.”
The International Court of Justice ruled a year ago that Palestinians have not only a right of self-determination but that this right implies the existence of a sovereign state.
“Things were indeed happening before on the West Bank in terms of the settlements in terms of the right of self-determination, which the International Court of Justice a year ago said not only that the Palestinians have a right of self-determination, but that the right of self-determination implies the existence of a sovereign state.”
The definition of genocide in the 1948 convention includes 'causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group' and 'deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part,' which is more expansive than the Holocaust analogy but requires high evidentiary standards.
“causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group. deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part”
If genocidal rhetoric is made by a minister acting in official capacity, it is much easier to show a connection between expression of genocidal intent and acts of killing or targeting on the ground.
“If the expression is made by a minister acting in an official capacity, it's going to be much easier to show a connection between an expression of genocidal intent as rhetoric on the one hand and the act of killing or targeting or exterminating on the ground on the other hand.”
Hersh Lauterpacht became professor of international law at Cambridge University, worked with Robert Jackson on arguments for US entry into World War II and on the creation of the Nuremberg Tribunal statute, and founded the idea of international human rights law based on the principle that every human being has minimum rights under international law.
“he moved into an academic direction and he then becomes professor of international at Cambridge University and when the war begins he his family moves to America and he is introduced by um Felix Frankfurt a justice at the Supreme Court to Robert Jackson and he works with Jackson on the arguments to allow the United States to enter the Second World War um and to get round the arguments on neutrality. And then he works with Jackson on the creation of the statute of the Nuremberg Tribunal. And his fundamental interest in life is the belief that every human being has minimum rights under international law. He's one of the sort of parents, the fathers of the idea of international human rights law.”
The 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of Genocide was the first modern human rights treaty adopted with strong support from the United States and about 50 other countries.
“in December 1948 he succeeds and the first modern human rights treaty adopted with the strong support of the United States and about 50 other countries is the adoption of the convention on the prevention and punishment of genocide in 1948.”
The classic example of genocidal rhetoric creating genocidal context is Radio Télévision Libre des Mille Collines (RTLM) in Rwanda, which broadcast nasty propaganda that created an environment in which people implemented genocidal acts on the ground.
“The classic example is in Rwanda there was a radio station called Had Milin radio a thousand hills which put out really nasty stuff and that created an environment in which people on the ground then implemented genocidal acts.”
Raphael Lemkin was born at the turn of the 19th and 20th centuries in what is now Belarus, grew up hearing his mother sing songs about mass killings from history, heard about pogroms in Russia, and began thinking in the early 1930s as a public prosecutor about how international law could protect human beings from mass atrocity.
“Born at the turn of the 19th and 20th century in a territory, a small hamlet that is now in Bellarus. grows up, loves his mother, who sings him songs about mass killings in the past, the Romans killing the Christians and so on and so forth. There are pograms in parts of Russia that he hears about... in the early 1930s as a public prosecutor, starts thinking about how the law, international law, can protect human beings from mass atrocity.”
Raphael Lemkin escaped Poland on September 1, 1939 when Germany attacked, eventually reaching the United States via Sweden, but traveled with no personal luggage and no money while carrying only pieces of paper containing decrees passed by the Nazis across occupied Europe.
“Lmin has a remarkable escape from Poland. He's there on the 1st of September 1939 when Germany launches an attack on Poland and starts what is now known as the Second World War and then makes his way up through Latvia and eventually to Sweden. And then he procures an invitation from Duke University Law School to be a visiting professor... He travels from Europe to the United States with no personal luggage and no money. He's completely broke, but he travels with a lot of luggage full of pieces of paper because he's been collecting all the decrees passed by the Nazis across occupied Europe.”
War crimes, the only pre-existing international crime, was limited in scope and basically prohibited how you attack enemies during war while distinguishing between combatants and non-combatants.
“The only crime that exists at the time is something called war crimes, which doesn't govern the totality of what's happened. The only crime that exists at the time is something called war crimes, which doesn't govern the totality of what's happened. What it basically did was said how you attack your enemy in times of war is limited. You have to distinguish between combatants and non-combatants and so on and so forth.”
Between 1948 and the 1990s, nothing significant happened with the interpretation and application of the genocide convention until the horrors of Rwanda and the former Yugoslavia, which prompted the creation of two new international tribunals.
“That was 1948 and he accepted it. What happened next? Between 1948 and the 1990s, nothing happened really with the interpretation application of the genocide convention. Then in 93 and 94, we had the horrors of Rwanda, which you've already mentioned, and of the former Yugoslavia. And the Security Council creates two new international uh tribunals to deal with those horrors.”
Lemkin cited examples of relatively small acts including Russian pogroms against Jews in particular towns as genocidal acts, establishing that his conception did not require the murder of millions to constitute genocide.
“In Lenmin's notes, we find examples of relatively small acts of killings of groups in part a part of a community living in a particular part of the world. For him, for example, the pograms that were carried out in Russia about against Jews in particular towns, those were genocidal acts.”
Mass atrocities are always about dehumanization—'They're not like us. They're different. And therefore, we are free to treat them in this way'—which is the underlying mechanism in Sands' work across all mass atrocity cases.
“Save that as with so much of the work that I do in cases about mass atrocity. It's always about dehumanization. They're not like us. They're different. And therefore, we are free to treat them in this way.”
Lemkin flew to London just before Nuremberg began and persuaded Robert Jackson and the Americans to include genocide as a subsection of war crimes in the statute, despite initial resistance.
“Lmin is devastated that there is no inclusion in the statute of the crime of genocide. But he then flies to London just before the trial begins and persuades Robert Jackson and the Americans to include genocide as a subhead of war crimes.”
The Nuremberg trials represented the first time in human history that leaders of a nation were put on trial for international crimes before an international court, and they invented three new crimes: crimes against humanity, crime of aggression, and genocide (though genocide was not included in the final judgment).
“So, this is the first time in human history that the leaders of a nation are put on trial for international crimes before an international court. It has never happened before... They then agree the three leaders at Yala that there will be for the first time an international military tribunal to deal with the leaders. And they have a problem. They've got no crimes to charge them with.”
American prosecutors were skeptical of genocide because Southern senators worried the concept would be invoked against American lynchings of Black Americans and genocide against Native Americans, so Jackson never mentioned genocide and Americans never invoked it.
“Jackson comes under pressure from southern senators in the United States who are extremely worried that um the crime of genocide will be invoked in relation to lynchings in the southern states of African-Americans, black people, and also historically in relation to um Native Americans. And the effort works. Um Jackson never mentions the word genocide. The Americans never mention it.”
The 1948 UN Convention on Genocide adopted a narrower definition than Lemkin originally conceived, requiring proof of specific intent to destroy a group and excluding political groups, which Lemkin accepted as 'the best is the enemy of the good.'
“If you look at the definition here, just a couple of examples that you read out, committed with intent to destroy, Lmin's conception didn't have what has emerged as a special intention that has to be proven. And Lin also had a much broader conception of which groups were covered. You'll have noticed political groups are excluded and in a sense had to accept that the best is the enemy of the good.”
International courts in the 1990s and 2000s raised the bar for genocide further by interpreting 'intent to destroy' to require that genocidal intent be 'the only reasonable inference' from conduct, creating a gap between popular understanding of genocide and the legal definition.
“You start with Lenin's conception in 1944 at a lower bar. You then get the convention definition in 1948, which pushes the bar higher. And then in the 1990s and in the 2000s, the bar is pushed even higher by international judges who want to limit what genocide means in international law. And the end result is you've got a gap. You've got a gap between what ordinary folk think of as genocide, which is much closer to what Lenin imagined it to be on the one hand, and the legal definition taken by international courts.”
The challenge in proving genocide is not determining whether crimes are being committed, but rather determining the intention behind the acts of killing, destruction, and harm.
“The challenge, as we've seen, is not to determine whether crimes are being committed. There's no question that what you're describing is a war crime. There's no question in my mind either that it is so systematic that it's likely also to be a crime against humanity in the conception of international law. The debate and it's a legal debate which as I've said is not a helpful one is what is the intention behind the acts that you are describing.”
Hersh Lauterpacht, Lemkin's contemporary at the same law school, developed the concept of crimes against humanity focusing on protection of individuals rather than groups, and opposed Lemkin's focus on group protection, fearing it would replace tyranny of the state with tyranny of the group.
“And then his counterpart who he never actually meets Hersh Lipact who studied amazingly at the same law school comes up with a different conception crimes against humanity which is focusing on the protection of individual human beings. And this juxposition of the tension between the protection of the individual and the protection of the group has gone on ever since 1945. And interestingly Laipact was always opposed to the concept of genocide. He worried that the concept of genocide focusing on the protection of groups by reason of ethnicity, religion, race, nationality, whatever it may be, would replace what he considered to be the tyranny of the state, the power of the state with the tyranny of the groups, the power of the group.”
American senators opposed the inclusion of genocide as a crime at Nuremberg because they feared it would be invoked against American lynchings of African-Americans and historical atrocities against Native Americans.
“Jackson comes under pressure from southern senators in the United States who are extremely worried that um the crime of genocide will be invoked in relation to lynchings in the southern states of African-Americans, black people, and also historically in relation to um Native Americans.”
Hans Frank, Adolf Hitler's lawyer, argued at Nuremberg that genocide and crimes against humanity were retroactively invented crimes, violating the principle of non-retroactivity of law, and this argument had force despite the horrors those laws were meant to address.
“His reaction with his lawyer is going to be, 'What's this about? These have been invented. This has been invented for this trial. There's a principle of the non-retroactivity of the law. you can't invent uh you know a crime in 1945 and then apply it retroactively to what happened in 1940 or 1937 uh or whatever. And it was one of those moments in life where you know the horrors of what had happened crystallized a um sentiment that yeah there's probably force to those arguments”
In genocide trials across history, including Nazi Germany, perpetrators claim self-defense and argue that the targeted group posed a threat that justified destruction, which Sands identifies as a timeless argument.
“How much does that also extend to the arguments around self-defense which is to say that when you look at the history of genocide proceedings? I think it is very hard to find one that does not claim on behalf of those who committed the genocide, going back to the Germans, that they were acting in self-defense, that they faced a threat from this group.”
Palestine's lack of statehood recognition for decades meant Palestinians had no international legal standing or protection and were entirely subject to Israeli control, which relates to why international law protections exist—to protect groups without states.
“the existence of international law as a shelter, as a protection, as a shield for people who do not have a state that can protect them. Right? either they are at the mercy of their own state or they are part of a state too weak and it's not an accident these ideas are are developed by Jewish lawyers during and then after the Holocaust but but there's something here about not just the the way in which you could have been the property of the state but what does it mean to not have a state that can protect you to not have a state that can advocate for you”
Even if Hamas integration into civilian infrastructure is true, international humanitarian law does not permit total war and total destruction as a response, and accepting such arguments would end the rules developed over 150 years limiting warfare.
“even if it's true, it doesn't justify what's going on under international law in terms of international humanitarian law, war crimes law, crimes against humanity, and perhaps even crossing the line in due course, whatever the judges decide, it's not an answer to those claims. And if it is an answer to those claims, then you have opened the door to an end to these rules that we've spent 150 years struggling to put in place.”
The political reality that matters most is stopping the horror now, not the legal label applied to it—and Sands is less concerned about whether something is called genocide, war crime, or crime against humanity than with causing the killing and suffering to stop.
“I'm not focused on whether it's a war crime or a crime against humanity or a genocide, which is a distraction from the real issue. It is utterly appalling and unjustifiable and it should not be happening. And these debates about whether to characterize something of X or Y or zed are not helpful because they distract us from the horror that is happening.”
In the Nuremberg judgment on October 1, 1946, the word 'genocide' was not mentioned even once—there was no reference to it, no rejection of it, just silence.
“when you then come to the judgment on the 1st of October 1946, the word genocide is not mentioned. Not even once. There isn't even a reference to it was argued but we're rejecting it for the following reasons. The four principal judges just pass in silence on it.”
The Nuremberg Trials represent the first time in human history that leaders of a nation were put on trial for international crimes before an international court, setting a revolutionary precedent.
“So, this is the first time in human history that the leaders of a nation are put on trial for international crimes before an international court. It has never happened before.”
Psychologists argue that when human beings have an intent to act, they're typically motivated by multiple different intents simultaneously; therefore requiring a single exclusive intent as the legal standard for genocide sets the bar far too high.
“the psychologists that I speak to say that when human beings have an intent to act, they're often motivated by multiple different intents. And to say you've got to have only one intent makes it very very difficult to prove.”
The phrase 'Never Again' emerged from Holocaust memory and comes to define what genocide means culturally—a promise that the worst thing humans have done (the Holocaust) will never happen again; this ties genocide culturally to the Holocaust even as the legal definition is different.
“When we say never again, never again is meant to describe the Holocaust. It's something very specific and it is from that specific thing that our collective fear exists, right? The what do we do? What structures need to exist to make sure that level of barbarism in humanity never reveals itself again.”
Benjamin Netanyahu has repeatedly referenced biblical verses about the Amalekites—specifically commands to 'blot out the memory' of Amalekites and 'completely destroy everything they have... kill all the men, women, children, and babies'—invoking a biblical genocide narrative.
“Benjamin Netanyahu, the prime minister, has repeatedly referred to biblical verses around um the Jewish people's war with the Amalcch. And in in Deuteronomy, specifically in the area that he's referring to, it it God commands uh the Jewish people to blot out the memory of Amalcch from under heaven. There's elsewhere in in the book of Samuel, go and attack the Amalachites and completely destroy everything they have. Don't leave a thing. Kill all the men, women, children, and babies, the cattle, sheep, camels, and donkeys.”
The closest precedent is Bosnia v. Serbia, where the International Court of Justice found that genocide occurred but ruled Serbia was not directly responsible—only that Serbia failed to prevent genocide by paramilitary groups.
“In the case brought by Bosnia against Serbia, the court said yes, there was a genocide, but it wasn't one that was intended by the state of Serbia. Serbia failed to prevent a genocidal act by paramilitary groups.”
Netanyahu has effectively become the prosecutor of his own case—his published and broadcast genocidal rhetoric makes it easier for South Africa to prove genocidal intent even though his statements make Israel's legal position more difficult.
“Tell your ministers to zip it to start with. Stop making these statements... The argument, the only argument that is available to Israel is the one that is based on a very particular reading of the language... Israel will say, 'We are acting in self-defense... Our intention is self-defense, self-protection. It is not the extermination of a group in whole or in part.'”
Intent in Sands' conception can include 'turning a blind eye' to what is happening—deliberate inattention to the suffering being caused can constitute genocidal intent.
“Intent in my book can also be turning a blind eye to what is happening and a blind eye is being turned and I to be frank find it incomprehensible.”
Sands responds that even if Israel's self-defense arguments are true, under international law this kind of treatment is not justifiable, and that while Israel is entitled to use force in self-defense, 'the right to use force is not unlimited and it is constrained by the requirements of international law and it may not go beyond those requirements'
“even if all of this is true, under international law, this kind of treatment is not justifiable... Israel is entitled to say is that the attack that occurred on October the 7th was such as to entitle it to respond. But... the right to use force is not unlimited and it is constrained by the requirements of international law and it may not go beyond those requirements.”
The 1948 definition differs from Lemkin's original conception: it added a special intent requirement ('intent to destroy') that Lemkin's original definition lacked, and it excluded political groups from protection, though Lemkin's original conception covered them.
“the definition that is adopted in the 1948 convention is different from the definition that Lincoln originally conceived of. As I've already explained, he set the bar much lower. If you look at the definition here, just a couple of examples that you read out, committed with intent to destroy, Lmin's conception didn't have what has emerged as a special intention that has to be proven. And Lin also had a much broader conception of which groups were covered. You'll have noticed political groups are excluded”
Israeli President Isaac Herzog has said 'It's an entire nation out there that is responsible' for Hamas, explicitly rejecting the distinction between civilians and combatants.
“President Isaac Herszog um of of of Israel, it's an entire nation out there that is responsible. It's not true this rhetoric about civilians not aware, not involved. It's absolutely not true.”
If Israel stops bombing and restricting aid, the genocide case weakens; if it continues, the case for genocide strengthens over time—creating a dynamic where continued military operations make the genocide charge harder to defend against.
“The longer this goes on, the more difficult it is going to be for Israel to resist the argument that this meets the definition of genocide under international law... The more you persist in this direction, the more likely you make it that ultimately one or other international court is going to conclude not only colloquially but as a matter of law that these facts constitute a genocide.”
Churchill wanted to simply execute Nazi leaders after WWII; Roosevelt and Stalin insisted on a trial instead, though for different strategic motivations.
“Churchill in short would like to line them up and shoot them. Roosevelt and Stalin say no we're going to put on a trial. They obviously have different motivations as to what that trial should be about.”
Palestinians have a reasonable understanding that the conflict with Israel has been a long process of their erasure and encroachment, not beginning with October 7th; to them, the October 7th violence was an eruption within a longer trajectory of occupation, settlement, and denial of self-determination.
“To them, the reason the the concept of genocide was so close at hand was they believe this is something Israel has been seeking for some time... they self-epport. Um that this that the way they understand this period is that October 7th in some ways opened up a window of opportunity for Israel to execute a project that some in it had been thinking about and planning for some time... For Palestinians I talked to, this all did not begin on October 7th. One of their one of the ways they believe the conversation is biased against them is is we speak of October 7th as a beginning.”
Palestinians view the current war as an eruption of violence within a long historical process of dispossession and displacement, not as beginning with October 7th, and understand Israel as viewing Palestinians as a 'problem to be solved' rather than a people to coexist with.
“many of the Palestinians I've talked to about this. To them, the reason the the concept of genocide was so close at hand was they believe this is something Israel has been seeking for some time that that the Palestinian people look to Israel as a problem to be solved. Maybe caged up in in Gaza and unable to leave. Maybe their existence in the West Bank made more and more tenuous and more and more difficult and more and more dangerous.”
Ethnic cleansing, the forced removal of a population from their homelands, has been ruled not to constitute genocide in international law despite the serious harm it causes.
“One of the complexities here also is that ethnic cleansing, moving a population out of their homelands, and people will find this difficult to believe has been ruled not to be genocidal in international law on the particular definition that international courts have taken.”
There is an important dynamic between the political and the legal in genocide cases. Whether judges are willing to cross the line and rule for genocide depends on both legal and political considerations, and courts have all the material to rule for South Africa if they choose to do so.
“It's it's become a lightning rod for so many different perspectives and difficult issues... It's it's very much in that direction. whether a group of judges are going to be willing to cross the line. If they want to, they've got all of the material to allow them to do it to make a finding in favor of South Africa.”
Klein argues that the debate over genocide versus war crimes is really about political and cultural meaning rather than purely legal categories, as the goal is to transform how the Jewish state is understood in historical memory.
“I do think the distinction here between the political and legal is is important because on some level I don't understand all of this to be really about a court case that will happen at some point in the future. I understand it to be about a cultural understanding that that the real damage here, the the real demand here, the real effort here is to attach to Israel, to Israel's current leadership to the Jewish state the charge of genocide and make it stick in cultural memory to to change the meaning of of the Jewish state.”
The longer the war continues, the more difficult it becomes for Israel to demonstrate military justification, and if judges cannot find military justification, the only remaining inference is genocidal intent to destroy the group.
“The more difficult it becomes to answer that question what is the military advantage that they seek to gain? And the more difficult it becomes to answer that question, the more likely it is that a group of judges at the International Court of Justice will conclude there is no military justification. The only intention is to destroy large parts of this group.”
The targeting of infrastructure including health care, universities, cultural institutions, and food/water systems, combined with population targeting, reveals an intent not just to defeat a military force but to make Gaza functionally uninhabitable and destroy Gaza as a human collective entity.
“And so the claim being made here, the argument being made here is that it's more than just the attacks on the people that in destroying everything that Gaza was making it functionally uninhabitable by human beings. That that that is part of genocide. That that is part of revealing an intent to make this place and people no longer exist in in the form they once did.”
If a state's claim of self-defense can justify any level of destruction, then 'when you find yourself under attack in such conditions you need to say this is not permissible,' creating a reciprocal risk that others will later use the same justification against that state.
“And if you use it one day against others, then others one day will use it against you. And you ought to be prepared for that time when you find yourself under attack in such conditions and you need to say this is not permissible.”
Lemkin described the day of the Nuremberg judgment as 'the blackest day of his life, worse even than the day on which he discovered the loss of his beloved parents and his cousins and uncles and aunts.'
“Lmin describes the day of the judgment as the blackest day of his life, worse even than the day on which he discovered the loss of his beloved parents and his cousins and uncles and aunts and so on and so forth.”
The argument that Hamas is 'interwoven into civilian life' and uses civilians as shields justifies infrastructure destruction does not excuse violations of international humanitarian law even if true, because accepting this argument would open the door to total war and the end of rules protecting civilians.
“even if it's true, it doesn't justify what's going on under international law... if you accept those kinds of arguments, you are in effect accepting that total war, total destruction, total annihilation is now permitted under international law in such circumstances. And if you use it one day against others, then others one day will use it against you.”
Lemkin spent World War II collecting Nazi decrees from occupied Europe and traveling to the United States with no personal luggage but full of documentation, where he received a commission from the Carnegie Foundation to write about what he had witnessed.
“He travels from Europe to the United States with no personal luggage and no money. He's completely broke, but he travels with a lot of luggage full of pieces of paper because he's been collecting all the decrees passed by the Nazis across occupied Europe. And there in North Carolina, he receives a commission from the Carnegie Foundation to write a book um on what he has seen in occupied Europe.”
The Nazi governor of occupied Krakow once rejected a request to protect a Jewish child on grounds that laws concerning the threat posed by Jews meant 'we have no other way of proceeding than to apply the full force of the law to them in order to protect ourselves'—showing genocide is justified by perpetrators using self-defense arguments.
“I've looked into this. Yes, this child is present in our territory. But I have to tell you that the laws that we have in relation to the threat posed by these people, including the children, is such that we have no other way of proceeding than to apply the full force of the law to them in order to protect ourselves.”
After the Nuremberg judgment, Lemkin resumed his campaign within the UN General Assembly, which passed a resolution in December 1946 saying the tribunal got it wrong and genocide is part of international law, leading to a commitment that a Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of Genocide would be negotiated.
“and he resumes his campaign and he begins to lobby within the context of the UN General Assembly which passes a resolution in December 1946 saying basically the tribunal got it wrong and genocide is part of international law and what he achieves is a commitment by a general assembly resolution that there will then be negotiated a convention against genocide”
The United Nations General Assembly passed a resolution in December 1946 asserting that genocide is part of international law, contradicting the Nuremberg judges' silence on it, and Lemkin then lobbied for a Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of Genocide adopted in December 1948.
“he resumes his campaign and he begins to lobby within the context of the UN General Assembly which passes a resolution in December 1946 saying basically the tribunal got it wrong and genocide is part of international law and what he achieves is a commitment by a general assembly resolution that there will then be negotiated a convention against genocide on the prevention and punishment of genocide and that is again his almost one-man show in December 1948 he succeeds and the first modern human rights treaty adopted with the strong support of the United States and about 50 other countries is the adoption of the convention on the prevention and punishment of genocide in 1948.”
Genocide was mentioned in the Nuremberg indictment but not in the final statute, and judges passed in silence on it in their judgment of October 1, 1946, which Lemkin described as the blackest day of his life.
“Genocide is mentioned in the indictment but not in the statute. And when you then come to the judgment on the 1st of October 1946, the word genocide is not mentioned. Not even once... Lmin describes the day of the judgment as the blackest day of his life, worse even than the day on which he discovered the loss of his beloved parents”
The paradox of Lemkin's legacy is that the rules against genocide were created by Jews at a moment when Jews had no power and faced annihilation, but now that Jews have state power, they are flouting these rules profoundly—a historical tragedy and irony.
“The historical tragedy, which is that the creators of these rules, Lumpin and and around crimes against humanity, latter pock, they were Jewish people at a time when Jewish people had no power and could be annihilated by states. And now that Jewish people have a state and have power, they are flouting these rules profoundly.”
Spain and Ireland became the first two European countries to break consensus by recognizing Palestinian statehood, followed by France (a permanent Security Council member) and the UK, which has created a shift that puts Palestine and Israel 'on a level footing' in international law.
“The first two European countries to break with a consensus against recognition were Spain and Ireland. And they've now been followed by France, which is very significant because it's a permanent member of the security council. And now the United Kingdom has effectively said in September it will recognize the existence of a Palestinian state.”
Benjamin Netanyahu has repeatedly referred to biblical verses about the Amalekites, where God commands the Jewish people to 'blot out the memory' of the Amalekites 'from under heaven,' and to 'completely destroy everything they have. Don't leave a thing. Kill all the men, women, children, and babies, the cattle, sheep, camels, and donkeys.'
“Benjamin Netanyahu, the prime minister, has repeatedly referred to biblical verses around um the Jewish people's war with the Amalcch. And in in Deuteronomy, specifically in the area that he's referring to, it it God commands uh the Jewish people to blot out the memory of Amalcch from under heaven. There's elsewhere in in the book of Samuel, go and attack the Amalachites and completely destroy everything they have. Don't leave a thing. Kill all the men, women, children, and babies, the cattle, sheep, camels, and donkeys.”
Judges at the International Court of Justice are deeply concerned about famine as shown in provisional measures orders, and only 1.5% of arable agricultural land remains in Gaza, making it mathematically impossible for a population of 2 million to sustain itself.
“I think there was another statistic in a paper in the last few days that I think 1 and a half% of arable agricultural land remains in the whole of Gaza. It is not possible for a population of that size to sustain itself with that amount of arable land.”
In recent polling, 79% of Israeli Jews surveyed reported they are 'not so troubled' or 'not troubled at all' by reports of famine and suffering among Palestinians in Gaza.
“a poll came out that was reported on by Harets uh where 79% of Israeli Jews 79% said they are not so troubled led or not troubled at all by the reports of famine and suffering among the Palestinian population in Gaza.”
There was a siege on Gaza before October 7th; Israel had blockaded Gaza for quite some time, which is why tunnels were built. The current siege is tighter, but part of a continuous pattern of Palestinian confinement.
“There was a siege on Gaza before. The siege is tighter now, but Israel had Godzilla blockaded for quite some time. That's why there were tunnels in part.”
The use of starvation and famine as weapons in Gaza constitutes a war crime and likely a crime against humanity, regardless of whether it meets the legal definition of genocide.
“This is hunger as a policy, hunger as a weapon of war. This is a siege.”
The Lancet medical journal has concluded that the true death toll in Gaza is likely far higher than the Hamas Ministry of Health's estimate of 61,000.
“It's from the Hamas run Ministry of Health, we're told. But when the Lancet, the medical journal, tried to fill in the gaps in the data, they concluded that the true number, the real death toll, is likely far higher.”
Ethnic cleansing has been ruled not to constitute genocide in international law under the current judicial definition, despite Lemkin's original conception including displacement and exclusion as genocidal acts.
“ethnic cleansing, moving a population out of their homelands, and people will find this difficult to believe has been ruled not to be genocidal in international law on the particular definition that international courts have taken.”
The International Court of Justice ruled a year ago not only that Palestinians have a right of self-determination but that this right implies the existence of a sovereign state.
“things were indeed happening before on the West Bank in terms of the settlements in terms of the right of self-determination, which the International Court of Justice a year ago said not only that the Palestinians have a right of self-determination, but that the right of self-determination implies the existence of a sovereign state.”
Since the 1990s, international courts have progressively raised the bar for what counts as genocide by adopting an increasingly strict interpretation of what 'intent to destroy' means, creating a widening gap between public understanding of genocide (mass killing) and the legal definition.
“And the end result is you've got a gap. You've got a gap between what ordinary folk think of as genocide, which is much closer to what Lenin imagined it to be on the one hand, and the legal definition taken by international courts.”
Sands argues that the 2015 'only inference' standard is too high because psychological research shows that human beings are typically motivated by multiple simultaneous intents rather than a single dominant intent.
“My own personal view is that that definition is wrong. It sets the bar far too high. that the psychologists that I speak to say that when human beings have an intent to act, they're often motivated by multiple different intents. And to say you've got to have only one intent makes it very very difficult to prove.”
Klein argues that Israel's conditions for ending the war (Hamas surrender, hostage releases) are not a legal or moral defense against genocide charges because the Holocaust could not have been stopped by Jewish surrender, showing that genocide's defining feature is its unconditional intent.
“to be fair to that debate, there was not a surrender the Jews could make in 1940 that would have ended the Holocaust or stopped the Holocaust. Here, this is this is the view I hear from Israeli Jews and and from many Jewish people here. There are conditions Israel has laid out if Hamas capitulated... that to call this a a genocide is flatly untrue even under any colloquial definition of genocide because this would at least they believe stop if Hamas surrendered”
Before 1945, states had basically absolute power under international law to treat anyone subject to their jurisdiction as they wished; there were no restrictions, no human rights law, and the only international crimes recognized were war crimes, not crimes against humanity or genocide.
“But it was different in this way also. Until 1945, a state was basically free to treat anyone subject to its jurisdiction as it wished. There were no restrictions. There was nothing called human rights law. Under international law, the only international crimes were in relation to war crimes. There was no such thing as crimes against humanity or genocide.”
In Rwanda, the radio station Télévision Libre des Mille Collines broadcast genocidal rhetoric that created an environment for people to implement genocidal acts, showing how rhetoric can enable mass killing.
“The classic example is in Rwanda there was a radio station called Had Milin radio a thousand hills which put out really nasty stuff and that created an environment in which people on the ground then implemented genocidal acts.”
In December 1948, the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of Genocide became the first modern human rights treaty adopted with strong US support and about 50 other countries, largely due to Lemkin's advocacy.
“In December 1948 he succeeds and the first modern human rights treaty adopted with the strong support of the United States and about 50 other countries is the adoption of the convention on the prevention and punishment of genocide in 1948.”
A letter from 600 former Israeli military officers, including former heads of Mossad and Shin Bet, states that 'It is our professional judgment that Hamas no longer poses a strategic threat to Israel.'
“A group of about 600 ex-Israeli military officers, including former heads of MSAD and Shinbet, released a letter saying that quote, 'It is our professional judgment that Hamas no longer poses a strategic threat to Israel.'”
Since October 7th, the death toll in Gaza is estimated at over 61,000 people, and for a nation the size of Israel, this represents approximately 15 times the scale of the 9/11 attacks in terms of population-adjusted casualties.
“For a nation the size of Israel, it was like 15 911s. 15 9/11s. Imagine that level of trauma. Imagine that loss. We're almost 2 years on. The death toll in Gaza is now estimated to be over 61,000 people.”
Klein initially opposed South Africa's genocide accusation as wrong because Israel had been attacked and self-defense was legitimate; but over time, as human rights organizations, Holocaust scholars, and genocide experts came to the same conclusion, his view evolved.
“In December of 2023, when South Africa accused Israel of genocide before the International Court of Justice, I thought they were wrong to do so. Israel had been attacked. Its self-defense was legitimate... But over the last year, I've watched a slew of organizations and scholars come to the view that whatever this began as, it has become genocidal.”
The death toll in Gaza is now estimated to be over 61,000 people, which for a population of about 2 million Gazans represents a catastrophe equivalent to approximately 2,500 9/11s when scaled to the US population.
“The death toll in Gaza is now estimated to be over 61,000 people. There are a little over 2 million Gazins... it is like 2500 911s.”
Israel argues that Hamas hides within civilian infrastructure (hospitals, universities, mosques) and diverts food aid, justifying the targeting of civilian infrastructure, but investigations have found Hamas has not systematically diverted food aid.
“Hamas is interwoven into civilian life in in Gaza both inextricably and strategically. It operates out of mosques, out of um hospitals, out of universities... Israel has argued that Hamas has been diverting food aid, which is why Israel had to stop the food aid... Now, I am not saying I buy this argument and I I do want to say that the investigations have found that Hamas has not diverted food aid systematically”
Israel has dropped more than 100,000 tons of explosives on Gaza since October 7th—more tonnage than was dropped on Dresden, Hamburg, and London combined during World War II.
“Since October 7th, Israel has dropped more than 100,000 tons of explosives on this sliver of land. That is more tonnage of explosives than was dropped on Dresden, Hamburg, and London combined during World War II.”
Aerial photography shows that 70% of all structures in Gaza—homes, hospitals, mosques, and schools—are severely damaged or destroyed.
“Aerial photography shows that 70% of all structures in Gaza, all the homes and hospitals, mosques and schools are severely damaged or destroyed.”
A group of about 600 ex-Israeli military officers, including former heads of Mossad and Shin Bet, released a letter stating that Hamas no longer poses a strategic threat to Israel.
“A group of about 600 ex-Israeli military officers, including former heads of MSAD and Shinbet, released a letter saying that quote, 'It is our professional judgment that Hamas no longer poses a strategic threat to Israel.'”
Klein observes that 1.5% of Gaza's arable agricultural land remains, meaning it is mathematically impossible for a population of 2 million to sustain itself, establishing that starvation is not an accidental byproduct but a direct result of policy choices
“I think there was another statistic in a paper in the last few days that I think 1 and a half% of arable agricultural land remains in the whole of Gaza. It is not possible for a population of that size to sustain itself with that amount of arable land.”
Israel blockaded aid into Gaza for 11 weeks in March, then largely ended the existing UN aid infrastructure and replaced hundreds of operating aid distribution sites with four sites run by inexperienced American contractors, contributing to famine conditions.
“Then in March, Israel blockaded aid into Gaza for 11 weeks. Then it largely ended the existing aid infrastructure the UN had built and replaced the hundreds of operating sites of aid distribution with four sites, four run by inexperienced American contractors.”
President Joe Biden referred to killings in Ukraine by Russian troops as genocide, which Sands argued was imprecise because genocide sets a high bar, though he acknowledged the acts were definitely war crimes and possibly crimes against humanity.
“President Biden took to the airwaves in a moment and said the killings in Ukraine by Russian troops looked to him like genocide. And I wrote an op-ed piece in the New York Times to say, 'Hang on a second. Let's be careful what we're talking about. It certainly looks like crimes. It certainly looks like war crimes. It may be systematic and crimes against humanity, but the definition of genocide sets a high bar.'”
Spain, Ireland, France, and the United Kingdom have begun recognizing Palestinian statehood, which changes Palestine's standing in international law and makes it impossible for Israel to annex West Bank territory or occupy Gaza without violating international law.
“The first two European countries to break with a consensus against recognition were Spain and Ireland. And they've now been followed by France, which is very significant because it's a permanent member of the security council. And now the United Kingdom has effectively said in September it will recognize the existence of a Palestinian state.”
Israeli President Isaac Herzog and other Israeli leaders have stated that 'it's an entire nation out there that is responsible' for Hamas and that 'there's not a distinction worth making' between Hamas and the Gazan population, treating all Palestinians as targets rather than distinguishing combatants from civilians.
“President Isaac Herszog um of of of Israel, it's an entire nation out there that is responsible. It's not true this rhetoric about civilians not aware, not involved... Many of Israel's leaders have simply said that Hamas is the Gazins and the Gazins are Hamas, that there's not a distinction worth making.”
The main group in Israel representing families of hostages stated that 'Netanyahu is leading Israel and the hostages to doom.'
“The main group in Israel representing the families of the hostages said, quote, Netanyahu is leading Israel and the hostages to doom.”
Sands relates a conversation with Thomas Buergenthal, a former American judge at the International Court of Justice who survived Auschwitz as a young child, in which Buergenthal said that if in 1944 when he was at Auschwitz there had been a Genocide Convention and international court, even if it didn't stop what happened, 'it would have given us hope and it would have given us an understanding that what was being done to us was wrong and it should not happen'
“I had an extraordinary conversation just before I argued the provisional measures order in the case for the Gambia against Myanmar with a man called Thomas Burgental. Thomas Bogen was the American judge at the International Court of Justice, but before that he was a young Jewish kid in Poland and he was at Ashvitz... there had been a piece of paper called the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of Genocide. And there'd been an international court. and that there had been a country far away which had gone to that court and said you can't treat those kids in that way. This is inhuman... it may not have stopped what happened but it would have given us hope”
International law principle established at 1945 is that the state's power is not absolute, and humans have rights as individuals and as groups; countries that violate this principle are attempting to roll back to a pre-1945 world.
“in order to safeguard human beings against these type of arguments, we under international law are going to protect and ensure the protection of the rights of those human beings. And that's right now what is under attack in the world to basically roll back the frontiers to a pre-1945 world in which the ideas of Laact and Lmin rights for individuals and rights for groups not under domestic law but under international law are rolled back”
The fundamental irony of current events is that international humanitarian law and genocide law were created by Jewish lawyers (Lemkin, Lauterpacht) when Jews were stateless and vulnerable, but now that Jews have a state, that state is violating the very rules these Jews created.
“The creators of these rules, Lumpin and and around crimes against humanity, latter pock, they were Jewish people at a time when Jewish people had no power and could be annihilated by states. And now that Jewish people have a state and have power, they are flouting these rules profoundly. And watching a structure of law built by Jews in their moment of absolute weakness and vulnerability, destroyed by them in some way. And as they have become stronger and more statebound, it it's almost a like a historical tragedy irony strangess.”
To accuse a state of genocide, especially Israel, is to tie it in cultural memory to the worst acts humans have ever committed, and if Israel is seen not just as the state born of a genocide but as one that perpetrated one, it will forever transform the meaning of the Jewish state.
“To accuse Israel, to accuse any state or group of genocide, is to tie them in cultural memory to the worst acts human beings have ever committed. If Israel becomes widely seen, not just as the state born of a genocide, but as the state that then perpetrated one, it will forever transform the meaning of the Jewish state.”
It is incomprehensible to Sands that the people most responsible for current operations are people who have 'read themselves into' the history of genocide and genocide law through studying East West Street, suggesting they 'should know better.'
“I find this very I find this very painful. Um that the idea that the person who is most responsible for what is going on right now is someone who is well aware of the historical matters because he has read himself into them and frankly he should know better.”
Klein notes that if Hamas capitulated and released hostages while an alternative occupation took control of Gaza, we cannot know what Israel would actually do in that scenario, making the counterfactual argument incomplete.
“I I mean it's a you know a hypothetical. We have no idea what would happen if they laid down arms now and said here are your 20 remaining hostages and we give up and you take over and you occupy. We we have no idea what Israel would actually do in those circumstances.”
The main Israeli organization representing hostage families has stated that 'Netanyahu is leading Israel and the hostages to doom,' indicating the war strategy is not effectively pursuing hostage recovery.
“The main group in Israel representing the families of the hostages said, quote, Netanyahu is leading Israel and the hostages to doom.”
Sands notes that the revolution in international law in 1945 was supposed to establish that 'the state's power is not absolute' and that 'human beings have rights as individuals and as groups,' but that what is happening now threatens to 'roll back the frontiers to a pre-1945 world in which the ideas of Laact and Lmin rights for individuals and rights for groups under international law are rolled back'
“what happened in 1945, this was the revolutionary moment was no, that's not a defense anymore. You're not allowed to do that. Everyone has rights either as an individual or as a member of a group. And in order to safeguard human beings against these type of arguments, we under international law are going to protect and ensure the protection of the rights of those human beings. And that's right now what is under attack in the world to basically roll back the frontiers to a pre-1945 world in which the ideas of Laact and Lmin rights for individuals and rights for groups not under domestic law but under international law are rolled back”
Klein argues that the real stakes of the genocide label are not primarily legal but cultural and historical—the debate is about whether Israel will be seen in cultural memory as both 'the state born of a genocide' and 'the state that then perpetrated one,' which would transform the meaning of the Jewish state
“I don't understand all of this to be really about a court case that will happen at some point in the future. I understand it to be about a cultural understanding that that the real damage here, the the real demand here, the real effort here is to attach to Israel, to Israel's current leadership to the Jewish state the charge of genocide and make it stick in cultural memory to to change the meaning of of the Jewish state.”
Israel has dropped more than 100,000 tons of explosives on Gaza, which is more tonnage than was dropped on Dresden, Hamburg, and London combined during World War II.
“Israel has dropped more than 100,000 tons of explosives on this sliver of land. That is more tonnage of explosives than was dropped on Dresden, Hamburg, and London combined during World War II.”
70% of all structures in Gaza (homes, hospitals, mosques, schools) are severely damaged or destroyed according to aerial photography.
“Aerial photography shows that 70% of all structures in Gaza, all the homes and hospitals, mosques and schools are severely damaged or destroyed.”
Israel blockaded aid into Gaza for 11 weeks in March and then replaced the UN's hundreds of aid distribution sites with only four sites run by inexperienced American contractors, contributing to famine conditions.
“Then in March, Israel blockaded aid into Gaza for 11 weeks. Then it largely ended the existing aid infrastructure the UN had built and replaced the hundreds of operating sites of aid distribution with four sites, four run by inexperienced American contractors.”
Benjamin Netanyahu and Isaac Herzog have read Philippe Sands' book 'East West Street,' with Netanyahu photographed reading it and Herzog having reviewed it for Haaretz, meaning they are aware of the history of genocide law.
“There was a piece in Time magazine about a well a few five six years ago uh profile of Benjamin Netanyahu and the piece included a photograph of him reading East West Street and I have to say it's astonishing. I find this very I find this very painful. Um that the idea that the person who is most responsible for what is going on right now is someone who is well aware of the historical matters because he has read himself into them and frankly he should know better.”
A Haaretz poll found that 79% of Israeli Jews report they are not troubled or not at all troubled by reports of famine and suffering among Palestinians in Gaza.
“a poll came out that was reported on by Harets uh where 79% of Israeli Jews 79% said they are not so troubled led or not troubled at all by the reports of famine and suffering among the Palestinian population in Gaza.”
The International Court of Justice has never ruled that any state is responsible for genocide, though it did find genocide occurred in Bosnia but was not intended by the state of Serbia (Serbia failed to prevent it).
“In the whole of human history, the International Court of Justice has never ruled that a state is responsible for genocide. It has never happened. In the case brought by Bosnia against Serbia, the court said yes, there was a genocide, but it wasn't one that was intended by the state of Serbia. Serbia failed to prevent a genocidal act by paramilitary groups.”
Thomas Buergenthal, a Holocaust survivor and former ICJ judge, told Sands that even if legal proceedings couldn't have stopped the Holocaust, they would have given hope and affirmation that what was being done was wrong and against international law.
“I had an extraordinary conversation just before I argued the provisional measures order in the case for the Gambia against Myanmar with a man called Thomas Burgental. Thomas Bogen was the American judge at the International Court of Justice, but before that he was a young Jewish kid in Poland and he was at Ashvitz. And just before I argued the case on the allegations of genocide in relation to Myanmar, Tom, who's sadly no longer with us, said to me, 'Philipe, can you imagine if in 1944 when I was at Ashvitz, there had been a piece of paper called the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of Genocide. And there'd been an international court. and that there had been a country far away which had gone to that court and said you can't treat those kids in that way. This is inhuman. This is a crime. This is against international law. Phipe he said it may not have stopped what happened but it would have given us hope'”
Famine is now spreading across Gaza and people are dying of hunger; hundreds have been killed at aid distribution sites where desperate populations gather.
“Famine is now spreading across Gaza. People are dying of hunger... Hundreds having been killed at these aid distribution sites.”
Amos Goldberg, professor of Holocaust history at Hebrew University, and Melanie O'Brien, president of the International Association of Genocide Scholars, have both concluded that what is happening in Gaza constitutes genocide.
“Amos Goldberg, professor of Holocaust History at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Melanie O'Brien, the president of the International Association of Genocide Scholars. I would determine that what is happening at the moment in Gaza constitutes genocide.”
South Africa's case for genocide in Gaza rests on the argument that the only reasonable inference from patterns of behavior including genocidal rhetoric and the use of famine as an instrument of conflict is an intention to destroy a group in whole or in part.
“The case the case for South Africa is very straightforward. It is that the only reasonable inference you can infer from the pattern of behavior, particularly in relation to statements of genocidal rhetoric by various ministers and the um in particular use of famine as an instrument of conflict. The only reasonable inference you can draw from that is an intention to destroy a group in whole or in part.”
Israel will argue in its defense that it is acting in self-defense against an existential threat from Hamas, and that its intention is self-protection rather than the extermination of Palestinians as a group.
“Israel will say, 'We are acting in self-defense. The bombs continue to fall on us. The hostages continue to be held. We are entitled to take these steps in order to protect ourselves from an existential threat. And therefore, our intention is self-defense, self-protection. It is not the extermination of a group in whole or in part.'”
Famine is now spreading across Gaza and people are dying of hunger, with hundreds killed at aid distribution sites.
“Famine is now spreading across Gaza. People are dying of hunger. the images and the videos and the stories here, not just of the starving, but of the people, of the children. They're bowls out begging for help... Hundreds having been killed at these aid distribution sites.”
Klein came to accept the genocide characterization over the months of the war after watching Holocaust scholars and human rights organizations reach that conclusion, particularly because of Israel's targeting of civilian populations through siege tactics and continued starvation even after Hamas was degraded as a military force.
“I have watched over the months and months as that have gone on, as many Holocaust scholars, as many human rights groups, even people who did not agree with South Africa at that moment have come to accept the term genocide. And and it seems to me for for a few reasons... the most important is the targeting of civilian populations through siege tactics. That if Israel wants to argue that all they are attempting to do is to destroy Hamas, Hamas is completely degraded as a military fighting force... and yet they are starving the people of Gaza”
Israel could prove that reported famine and suffering in Gaza is not occurring by letting reporters and independent inspectors in, but they won't do that, indicating that the claims are true and hunger is being used as a weapon of war—this is a siege.
“If it really isn't that bad, if this is all just propaganda, Israel could prove that easily. Let reporters in. Let independent inspectors in. But they won't do that because this is not a trick. Because it is not just propaganda. This is hunger as a policy, hunger as a weapon of war. This is a siege.”
Sands is currently counsel for the Gambia in a genocide case against Myanmar alleging genocide against the Rohingya, which will come before the International Court of Justice before the Israel case, and this case faces the same legal issues as the Israel case about whether self-defense or national security justifications defeat genocide charges
“I'm counsel for another case that's coming up before the International Court of Justice in the next few months. A case brought by the Gambia against Myanmar alleging genocide in relation to the mistreatment of the Rohhinga... they will have to determine whether Myanmar's arguments that it is acting in self-defense against a threat to its national security justifies the court ruling that this is not genocide.”
Whether international consequences will be sufficient in time to stop suffering of children and civilians is uncertain, but Sands notes that 'every act has unintended consequences' and the Israeli government may have 'taken things too far' and made conditions 'too intolerable and unacceptable' for too many people.
“Now whether that is sufficient in time to stop suffering on the ground of children and moms and people who have nothing to do with a military conflict, time will only tell. We know in life that every act has unintended consequences. And it may well be that this Israeli government has simply now taken things too far and made things too intolerable and unacceptable for too many people around the world that finally something will crack.”
When President Biden stated that killings in Ukraine 'looked like genocide,' it made front-page news worldwide. If he had said 'war crimes' or 'crimes against humanity,' it would have passed in silence or appeared on page 15. This demonstrates the political power of the genocide label.
“What that means is that if an American president takes to the airwaves and says, 'I've just seen something happen. That's a genocide.' It will be on the front page of every single newspaper in the world. But if the president says, 'Oh, that's war crime or crimes against humanity,' it will pass in silence or it'll be on page 15.”
Sands argues that whether something is classified as war crime, crime against humanity, or genocide is less important than stopping the atrocities, and that excessive focus on legal labels distracts from the moral imperative to end the suffering.
“I'm not focused on whether it's a war crime or a crime against humanity or a genocide, which is a distraction from the real issue. It is utterly appalling and unjustifiable and it should not be happening. And these debates about whether to characterize something of X or Y or zed are not helpful because they distract us from the horror that is happening”
Sands struggled throughout his book between intellectually favoring Lauterpacht's focus on individual rights and eventually being moved by Lemkin's insight about group targeting, particularly when visiting a mass grave containing his own family's remains.
“throughout the book I've got this internal struggle in myself. Am I with Laapact protection of individuals or lenin protection of groups?... And then we get right to the end of the book and I am taken in a small town called Julie Kiev just outside Leiv in Ukraine to a forest and in that forest is a mass grave and in that mass grave on the 25th of March 1943 and a half thousand people from the village of Kiev were taken made to walk along a plank shot in the back in the head and killed. And in that mass grave today, unmarked today, lie the bodies of Lapak's family and my grandfather's family. And at that moment, I understood what it was that Lenin was trying to do.”
International law will take generations or centuries to fully enforce, and the difference between 1945 and today is that we have written treaties and international courts that make room for hope even if immediate enforcement is limited.
“The difference between today and 1939 and 1941 is we have these pieces of paper called treaties on torture on genocide... It's it's a multi-deade century uh project and we have to be honest about that but it's a project worth engaging in.”
Klein describes reading 'East West Street' in Berlin and Poland as producing an emotional vertigo—recognizing that the people around him enjoying ordinary life had ancestors who perpetrated genocide, and that this ordinary dehumanization is the soil in which genocide grows.
“Reading your book is really hard for me... being in these places while reading this book... was to to really try to imagine all this and how it had happened and how the people around me... their grandparents and and great-grandparents could have done this... It it imbuss the world with an unreality.”
Reading East West Street in Berlin and Poland, Klein experienced an unreality—imagining that people around him enjoying coffee shops and music could have been the grandchildren of perpetrators of Holocaust and genocide, which imbued understanding of what allows dehumanization of others.
“being in these places while reading this book, which was maybe not my greatest idea ever, was to to really try to imagine all this and how it had happened and how the people around me where I was enjoying their coffee shops and going to to see music and how, you know, their grandparents and and great-grandparents could have done this... It it imbuss the world with an unreality.”
South Africa will argue that there is no military justification for the continued starvation, and therefore the only inference is intent to destroy the group. Israel will argue it is acting in self-defense against further attacks. The International Court of Justice judges will assess which interpretation of intent to apply.
“South Africa will make a strong argument that there is no military justification and therefore there cannot be an intention other than to destroy the group in whole or part. That is the argument that they will make and the judges of the international court of justice will then assess that on the basis of the evidence that is before them and they will assess it presumably on the basis of an argument by Israel. No, we're not intending to destroy a group in whole or in part. We're seeking to protect ourselves against further attacks of this kind.”
Sands predicts that if Israel continues starvation and military attacks, there will be further European recognition of Palestinian statehood, international sanctions on Israel similar to those imposed on Russia for Ukraine, trade sanctions not just on arms but on other products, and Israel's position will become 'increasingly isolated and increasingly untenable'
“if this path continues, if the star use of starvation and if the military attacks continue, there's going to be recognition of Palestinian statethood and there are going to be other consequences in relation to trade uh with Israel, not just armaments but also other products. uh I suspect and it will become an overwhelming cry in many countries around the world to adopt the kinds of sanctions that have been adopted in relation to Russia uh on Ukraine and the Israeli position will become increasingly isolated and increasingly untenable.”
If Lemkin were to evaluate current events, he would have characterized the October 7th attacks as meeting his definition of genocide and would certainly characterize what is happening now in Gaza as genocidal.
“I've already said publicly that if Lenmin were to view what has happened, he would have characterized what happened on October the 7th as meeting his definition of genocide. And he would certainly characterize what is happening now in Gaza as genocidal for exactly the reason that you um have stated.”
It is incomprehensible how individuals who have lived through the Holocaust in a historical sense (as descendants or survivors) can justify genocide-like behavior. This represents a profound failure of historical memory and learning.
“It's very difficult for me to comprehend how individuals who have themselves through their own family stories, lived through in a historical sense, the kinds of things that happened to their forebears, can find a justification for this kind of behavior is very difficult for me to comprehend.”
Klein presents Israel's defense argument: Hamas attacked on October 7th, holds hostages, and if it laid down its arms and released hostages, the war would end, therefore what is happening is a siege to compel Hamas capitulation rather than genocide, and Israel is not attempting to exterminate Gazans but to destroy Hamas and deter future attacks
“Hamas attacked on October 7th. Hamas has held the hostages since. The way you know that it is not genocidal in intent is if Hamas would lay down its arms, give itself up as an organization, release the hostages, this would have ended long before now... they are sieging Gaza until what used to be the government of it. Gives up gives up the hostages and ends the war. And Israel is not attempting to exterminate the Gazan people.”
In the days after October 7th, President Joe Biden attempted to help Americans understand Israel's trauma by comparing it to 15 9/11s, translating the scale of Israeli casualties into US terms for emotional comprehension.
“we've seen it described as Israel's 911. But for a nation the size of Israel, it was like 15 911s. Imagine that level of trauma. Imagine that loss.”
Sands is publishing a sequel to East West Street called '38 London Street' that examines the relationship between Augusto Pinochet and a Nazi who became a king crab cannery manager in Punta Arenas, Chile, continuing his examination of personal responsibility in times of conflict.
“But it raises many of the similar issues today that we've been discussing on personal responsibilities. In a sense, I'd say that's the theme between the three books. Personal responsibility in times of conflict. I'm publishing shortly called 38 Londre Street which is a sequel to East West Street and examines the relationship between Agustoa Pino and a Nazi who became the manager of a king crab canary in Puna Arenus in Chile.”
Sands will argue the Gambia's case against Myanmar for genocide against the Rohingya at the ICJ in January (the next year after the interview), and the Myanmar case may come before the Israel case, creating precedent either way.
“That's why I stand up at the International Court of Justice uh in January next year on behalf of the Gambia, a small African country, making allegations in relation to the mistreatment uh of the Rohingya.”