selection effect
A statistical bias in which an apparent relationship arises because of how cases are selected rather than a direct cause—e.g., smokers quitting because an internal cancer made them able to.
As defined in 77 | Azra Raza on The Way We Should Fight Cancer
Where it comes up · 9
- Talkingtalent3 claims
- Russ Roberts (and Robin Hanson) on Truth and Economics 01/26/20092 claims
- The Bet With Buffett1 claim
- How We Tamed Ourselves and Invented Good and Evil (with Hanno Sauer)1 claim
- Jonathan Rodden on the Geography of Voting1 claim
- Jeremy Giffon - Special Situations in Private Markets - [Invest Like the Best, Replay]1 claim
- 77 | Azra Raza on The Way We Should Fight Cancer1 claim
- Holiday Message 2022: Thinking Really Slowly1 claim
and 1 more
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “selection effect” →
- Any benchmark for a manager mixes allocation decisions, such as choosing small caps versus large caps or US versus global, with selection decisions, and because allocation drives performance, a custom benchmark that adjusts for allocation would eliminate the manager's claim to alpha.The Bet With Buffett
- Trying something new and crazy is more likely to be the next big thing in startups, but when we judge who did well there's a huge selection effect—a thousand people try crazy things, most fail, and we only see the one success and call it genius—exactly analogous to beneficial mutations being exceedingly rare in evolution.Holiday Message 2022: Thinking Really Slowly
- Public debates overstate disagreement because selection effects put forward the most confident, stark advocates, while the roughly 75 percent of reasonable people on each side who are unsure stay silent and are not invited to talk shows or debates.Russ Roberts (and Robin Hanson) on Truth and Economics 01/26/2009
- Under full non-indexical conditioning, a multiverse model in which every pocket universe is life-permitting would be strongly favored over one with selection, because no selection effect can level the playing field, yet that model merely pushes the anthropic question back rather than resolving it.Mindscape Ask Me Anything, Sean Carroll | September 2026
- A study found that long-term smokers who repeatedly fail to quit and then finally succeed have an inordinately high rate of subsequently developing lung cancer, with the conclusion being a selection effect: they could finally stop only because something internal—an already-developing cancer—made them able to, illustrating cancer as a silent killer operating at a subconscious level.77 | Azra Raza on The Way We Should Fight Cancer
- Elite organizations generate value either through selection effects, where prestige comes from picking people as with Harvard or modeling agencies, or through treatment effects, where the program changes the person, as with special forces training; the best organizations do both, and the resulting polish is visible in how people write and think.Jeremy Giffon - Special Situations in Private Markets - [Invest Like the Best, Replay]
- Whether cities make people Left-leaning (a treatment effect, e.g., urban residents valuing public transit or wanting drug problems addressed) or whether already-Left-leaning people sort into cities (a selection effect) is the central analytical question, and disentangling it would ideally require randomly assigning people to urban, suburban, and rural environments.Jonathan Rodden on the Geography of Voting
- The positive selection from moving within the United States, which was strong long ago (e.g., settling California or Utah), is now quite weak because the internet and supermarkets are the same everywhere; moving once and not far is not brave enough to function as a meaningful marker of talent.Talkingtalent
- Anyone who self-selects into an extreme undertaking like interplanetary settlement reveals a great deal about themselves, so you get substantial free selection effect just from the person wanting to be an astronaut or settler, as has been true historically for people settling new continents and nations.Talkingtalent
- Roberts found that the public perception of expert disagreement is misleading because selection effects mean the most confident voices get the airtime, so the exaggerated disagreement in media is larger than among thoughtful ideologues, but persistent one-sided disagreement among ideologues still signals that something is wrong.Russ Roberts (and Robin Hanson) on Truth and Economics 01/26/2009