Mindscape Ask Me Anything, Sean Carroll | September 2026
What this covers
This is the September 2026 Ask Me Anything from Sean Carroll's Mindscape, a monthly episode whose questions come from Patreon supporters. What survives here is the questioning: a run of listeners, among them David, JJPMaster and Michael Lacy, each posing a question or premise. Many refer back to Carroll's earlier episodes, books and papers, including his Mad-Dog Everettianism paper, so the questions show what listeners took from his past work.
The physics questions go deepest. One asks how to picture time emerging from correlations with a clock in a timeless Wheeler–DeWitt state alongside branching through decoherence in Everettian quantum mechanics. Others ask whether locality from dividing Hilbert space is unique, whether a Boltzmann brain can form in a universe accelerated by dark energy, and whether Sagittarius A* could be a horizonless dark matter core rather than a black hole. There are also challenges to treating entropy as a force, and to whether a final theory exists or physics only ever yields effective theories.
The philosophical questions are more contentious. They cover whether the free will debate is mostly semantic once compatibilism is on the table, and whether monism is a leftover Greek aesthetic. They also ask how Bayesian updating squares with stating forecasts as percentages, and how anthropic reasoning fares under full non-indexical conditioning. A moral thread asks whether Carroll's justification for eating animals would also permit painlessly killing unowned kittens, and another asks what justifies intellectual property. One question asks where Carroll's credences now stand on whether large language models have rediscovered human ways of thinking.
This Mindscape AMA transcript contains only listener-submitted questions and no host answers, so it documents what Patreon supporters asked about physics, philosophy, and science rather than any position Sean Carroll took.
- Every entry is a question or premise posed by an audience member; no reply from Sean Carroll appears in the transcript
- Topics span quantum foundations, cosmology, free will, AI consciousness, and academic career advice
- Several questions quote or reference Carroll's earlier episodes, books, and statements, which are not included here
A tabletop experiment with balanced charged masses could test whether length scales shrink instead of space expanding.
- The asker proposes a tabletop test of the hypothesis that all length scales shrink rather than space expanding, using a pair of charged masses on a frictionless track whose gravitational attraction is balanced by electrical repulsion.
“I was wondering if one could test the hypothesis with a tabletop experiment comprising a pair of charged masses on a frictionless track”