secession
The withdrawal of a state from the Union, which Lincoln regarded as the essence of anarchy and an illegitimate, unconstitutional act.
As defined in Lessons from Lincoln, Then and Now (with Diana Schaub)
Where it comes up · 5
- Walter Williams on Life, Liberty and Economics2 claims
- Lessons from Lincoln, Then and Now (with Diana Schaub)2 claims
- Patri Friedman on Seasteading 10/13/20081 claim
- Neil Howe: Fourth Turning Predictions1 claim
- 285 - American Division1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “secession” →
- Lincoln held that rejecting the principle of a constitutional majority—a majority held in restraint by constitutional checks and changing with deliberate shifts in popular opinion—necessarily leads to anarchy or despotism, because unanimity is impossible and permanent minority rule is inadmissible, so secession (like nullification) is the essence of anarchy.Lessons from Lincoln, Then and Now (with Diana Schaub)
- If the States had not believed they retained the right to secede, the Constitution would never have been ratified; later New England States, unhappy with the Louisiana Purchase, themselves initiated secession discussions, showing secession was an accepted principle.Walter Williams on Life, Liberty and Economics
- Government as an industry has high customer lock-in and switching costs, since changing governments on land means leaving your house, job, and friends; floating, modular seasteads that can be moved or rearranged reduce these switching costs and lower the cost of secession.Patri Friedman on Seasteading 10/13/2008
- Once secession occurred, Lincoln believed his Presidential oath obliged him to resist it as an illegitimate, unconstitutional act; he framed the use of the war power as necessary to vindicate the principle of the ballot, because the secessionists were trying to invalidate a perfectly constitutional election result by the bullet, and on democratic theory one bound by the ballot cannot resort to the bullet but must wait for future elections.Lessons from Lincoln, Then and Now (with Diana Schaub)
- The U.S. War Between the States was fundamentally about the right of principals to fire their agents, not over slavery or two sides trying to take over the government; denying States the right to secede means the Federal Government can do whatever it wants to the States.Walter Williams on Life, Liberty and Economics
- There is no single truly important cultural, political, religious, or social trend currently pulling Americans together more than it is pushing them apart; division spans where and how we live, our pop culture, and many fronts simultaneously.285 - American Division
- If Democrats win the 2020 election and implement their policies (taxes, income transfers, Green New Deal), the red zone will likely test the blue zone through nullification or secession, refusing to obey regulations or pay taxes; secession by red states is more plausible than blue zone secession because red states have military/weapons capacity and blue zone would not enforce federal authorityNeil Howe: Fourth Turning Predictions