What this covers

This is a conversation between Neil Howe, the generational theorist and Hedgeye demographer, and host David McAlvany, recorded for the McAlvany Commentary in the summer of 2020. It begins with the theory itself. Howe describes how the Fourth Turning treats social mood as a feedback loop: events shape generations, and those generations later shape the mood as they age. McAlvany opens by treating the model as provisional, comparing it to the way Ptolemy gave way to Copernicus. From there the talk moves to the pandemic, the stimulus that followed it, and the long-run picture of inequality, politics, and rivalry with China.

The economic thread is blunt. Howe says the pandemic response put modern monetary theory into practice at a scale with no precedent, and that the Fed and fiscal authorities now backstop corporate bond markets as well as banks. McAlvany ties this to Minsky's Instability Thesis: raising the debt stakes to solve an earlier debt problem produces a more fragile system than the one that existed before 2008.

The generational material is the most distinctive part. Howe describes the GI generation as the one that brought inequality to its 20th-century low. He argues that younger cohorts then pushed the country back toward individualism and inequality, and that peacetime entrenches the old, with Proposition 13 passing to heirs as one example. He also describes the Silent generation as protected, conformist children, and notes that Joe Biden is the first of them to reach the presidency. Citing Walter Scheidel's The Great Leveler, he expects equality to return as a policy question, through redistribution or through destroyed wealth.

The more contentious turns are political. Howe argues that Populism and Authoritarianism are two sides of one coin, tracing the pattern back to Caesar's populares. He places Xi Jinping, Narendra Modi, and Rodrigo Duterte in a global current of ethnic nationalism and deglobalization. He also claims that past crises demanded conformity and suppressed dissent, and that Americans have unified mainly against an external enemy. McAlvany asks whether a planned economy, with tools like a social credit system, could manage social mood differently.

Sharpest takeaway

Neil Howe argues that America is in a Fourth Turning—a generational crisis period characterized by civic upheaval, institutional breakdown, and the necessity for authoritarian consolidation to restore order, though the outcome remains contingent on whether America can preserve liberal values while unifying around a common purpose.

  • Generational cycles drive recurring periods of crisis (~80-90 years) where old civic orders are displaced by new ones, with the current Fourth Turning showing signs of institutional dysfunction and populist authoritarianism globally
  • The pandemic and monetary/fiscal interventions have accelerated rather than resolved underlying crises, raising the stakes (debt-to-GDP approaching WWII levels) and making the eventual reckoning larger
  • Successful Fourth Turnings historically require mobilizing society around a single civic purpose, often through increased surveillance and conformity, followed by more equal, convention-centered societies

The claims · ranked59 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

All models, including the Fourth Turning, are helpful for organizing data and understanding but must be treated as provisional frameworks subject to replacement as science progresses—just as the Ptolemaic model was replaced by the Copernican model, and heliocentrism may eventually be superseded by frameworks needed for interstellar travel

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· David McAlvany

“models are helpful for explaining how things work they're they're useful for organizing data and understanding what it means we also know from the history of science that models change and that interpretive frameworks uh once accepted as a helpful sort of rosetta stone by which you understand and interpret things they can be discarded so you had the telematic model accepted for hundreds of years then came the copernican model”

0.79

The COVID-19 pandemic prompted massive monetary and fiscal stimulus on an unprecedented scale, implementing modern monetary theory in practice and flooding the economy with liquidity at orders of magnitude never before seen in history, effectively converting ideologically contested concepts like 'socialism' into practical policy

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“some of the biggest changes we've seen were already introduced with a pandemic right the really practical implementation of modern monetary theory and flooding our economy with liquidity both you know fiscal stimulus and you know fed purchases to their balance sheet uh on an order of magnitude higher than we've ever seen before in history”

0.73

The Fourth Turning thesis holds that American social mood follows a cyclical pattern driven by generational aging, with generations shaped by historical events that later shape the mood as those generations age, completing a feedback loop

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“the social mood in america follows a cyclical pattern and that this cycle is driven by generational aging that is to say you know history creates generations and and shapes them and then later on these generations get older and they in turn shape the mood right so it's a it's sort of a completed loop a completed feedback loop”

0.72

History is written by victors, and the interpretation of past events changes depending on who wins; the future will reinterpret the past as victors impose their narrative, making predictions of the future inherently uncertain because we don't know how the future will rewrite the past

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Neil Howe

“history you know history is written by the victors right that's the other thing we forget you know there's an old eastern european joke about that where i don't know whether it was a bulgarian or a romanian or a pole but he used to say gee i i wonder what the world is going to be like you know i wonder what the future is going to be like in 15 years and the other person says can't possibly tell that we don't even know what the past is going to be like in 15 years so but that's the point right who knows how in the future we're going to rewrite the past and how we're going to reinterpret everything that's one thing by the way as an historian i constantly emphasize when i talk to you know listeners and that is we look on the past and we just think we're seeing it as it was no we're seeing it interpreted as the winners eroded right”

0.72

Walter Scheidel's 'The Great Leveler' documents that since the Neolithic Revolution 10,000 years ago, civilizations always become more unequal in peacetime, and only four forces reverse this: plagues, famines, total revolutions, and total wars—the 'great levelers'

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Neil Howe

“there's a great book but on this actually if anyone's interested sort of a longer uh creative history about walter scheidel called the great leveler on how it's uh in in ever since the neolithic revolution you know 10 000 years ago uh society's civilizations always become more unequal over time it's a great book except for periods of great crisis right those are always the great equalizers what he calls the great levelers and these are plagues famines total revolutions and total wars”

0.72

Populism and authoritarianism are two sides of the same coin historically; the term 'populares' originated with Caesar's supporters in Rome, opposed by the 'optimates' (elite). When a populist party succeeds and pushes out elites, it requires one person to embody the popular will, necessitating a single authority figure and creating authoritarianism

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Neil Howe

“populism moves from becoming the outside to the inside i mean what happens when populist this is why populism and authoritarianism are actually two sides of the same coin and that goes back historically to the very origin of the term who were the first populares as we used to call them you know when in latin they were the ones that supported caesar he was he was the first dictator i mean he was the first you know he spelled the end of the roman republic and those who opposed him were the optimates you know that the good people the senators you know the the elite class those who deserve to rule well when a popular party takes over because it's pushing out all the all the encrusted elites who used to run things they need one person right to embody their will and run it right i mean you get the logic here right so you need the the populism almost needs a single authority figure to give expression to what it wants and this is why the two have always been linked historically”

0.71

In historical Fourth Turnings, the management of communication and expression has always been a feature, with dissent suppressed through social pressure, violence, or fear (e.g., tar and feathering during American Revolution), resulting in post-crisis eras of more homogeneous political/cultural opinion

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“the managing of communication uh the managing of everything from the top has been a feature of all fourth turnings in our history it was certainly true during the american revolution uh you know you backed the wrong position you know tired and feathered ridden out on a rail uh there's a tremendous amount of terror that went on during the american revolution”

0.71

Growth in authoritarianism and populism has expanded globally over the past decade across Europe, South Asia, East Asia, and Latin America, and these generational currents driving the trend are aligned internationally, not merely localized to the United States

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“one element that we've seen over the past decade is this growth in authoritarianism and populism around the world and you know europe uh i think particularly south asia east asia and latin america most recently in the past couple of years and obviously we're seeing some of that in the united states right and this is to some extent these generational currents are are global you know they're they're aligned uh it's not just us uh it's happening everywhere”

0.71

Younger generations (boomers, silent) pushed American society toward increased inequality and individualism, with boomers particularly comfortable with inequality and opposed to strong middle-class conformity, specifically pushing for 'diversity and individualism' and letting loose 'all the prices and virtues' of America

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“younger generations took over and just pushed american completely different way obviously uh the silent generation particularly boomers after them were much more in favor of untethering individualism and boomers in particularly much more comfortable with uh inequality uh and individuals going their own way boomers hated the idea of a strong middle class do you remember all that conformity the pleasant valley sunday you know we all thought the same and we were all we were all relatively similar boomers have been pushing all their lives for a let loose all the diversity and individualism of america all their talents all the prices and virtues let it go and this is the result we're living in it today”

0.71

Throughout American history, during crises the nation has come together but always around an external enemy representing enslavement or existential threat (Britain, the Slaveocracy, fascism), and the paradox of crises is that they require surrendering liberties to preserve the liberties people truly value

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“in almost all of our crises we've come together as a nation but it's always to protect america against an enemy another that represented enslavement you know what i mean the the opposite of liberty you know whether it was britain or whether it was the slaveocracy of you know unbridled expansion of the south or or whether it was um whether it was the growth of fascism right there's always a vision of the complete enslavement right which requires the country to come together to actually take away liberties in order to preserve what liberties it truly values right”

0.71

Authoritarian leaders like Xi Jinping, Modi, Putin, Duterte, and Abe are taking advantage of social mood by focusing on ethnic nationalism and deglobalization, which contrasts with earlier periods emphasizing transnational identity and 'global citizenship'; this oscillation between specific and vague national identity coincides with conflict.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· David McIlvaney

“you're trending and taking advantage of social mood as well and it's it's in sort of a deglobalization trend that they're moving towards their ethnic center...geopolitical problems usually express themselves and people have very clear understanding of who they are and it's distinct from who anyone else is...you tend to see sort of transnational emphasis and and a move towards understanding yourself as a global citizen in one period of history and then it kind of shrinks back from this vague identity of who we are to a very specific identity of who we are and that very specific identity of who we are does coincide with some conflict because now it's not about all of us it's about us versus them”

0.69

The GI generation took America to its lowest point of economic inequality in the 20th century in terms of both wealth and income, with the Gini coefficient reaching all-time lows in the late 1960s-early 1970s, before younger generations pushed America toward inequality again

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“they took america in that post-war era by the time they started retiring which would have been the mid to late 1960s they took america to its low point of economic inequality in the 20th century in terms of both wealth and income which the genie co-op efficient probably reached its all-time low in the late 60s very early 1970s”

0.69

The Silent generation—despite many becoming communists and radicals in youth—never produced a U.S. president until Joe Biden, making them the only generation in American history never to produce a president, with Biden representing their 'last chance' to claim the presidency.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“the silent generation has never had a president the only generation in american history never to produce a president but at the very last clearly they're absolutely last chance to produce a president it looks as though this generation may well do it right with joe biden right those who came of age uh in the 50s uh very early 60s”

0.68

In peacetime, all groups entrench their own interests and those of their families; America now exemplifies this with Proposition 13 becoming hereditary (allowing tax values to pass to children), creating a 'grandfather class society' where the elderly have entrenched interests that throttle growth and opportunity for younger generations

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“inevitably in peace time we all sort of entrench our own interests in the interest of our families right now look around america today right we've got older people who've entrenched their own interest in the budget we got prop 13 in america which is actually now hereditary right you can pass on the tax value of your home to your kids believe it or not uh you know that that favored tax value i mean we've become an incredible sus a grandfather class society right where we've entrenched our interests”

0.68

Equality will be a major policy issue in the emerging Fourth Turning, as it was in the 1930s; post-crisis societies become more equal both through deliberate government redistribution and through destruction of pre-existing wealth (physical or market capitalization)

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“i think one thing you have to watch for if you're really looking at where we end up i think equality is going to be a big issue it was in the 30s uh and it certainly was not not just as an ideological issue but in fact we became a much more equal society coming out of the 30s and particularly the 40s a lot of that was done almost equally part of it was deliberate through government taxation and benefit programs a lot of it was done simply due to destruction of pre-existing wealth you know either physical destruction or just destruction of its of its market cap”

0.68

Raising the stakes by increasing debt to solve a previous debt problem (pandemic stimulus following 2008 crisis stimulus) echoes the same pattern from 2008-2009 and creates compounding instability, similar to Minsky's instability thesis where complacency breeds increasingly risky behavior

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· David McAlvany

“raise the stakes increase debt to solve what was a debt problem seems like an echo of what we did in 2008 and 2009 not that we have to learn from the past but we had the opportunity to”

0.68

A Fourth Turning crisis clears away obstacles to growth and freedom, preventing the next generation from growing, and resets the playing field from the old back to the young; this is followed by massive public investment in the young, including in higher education

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“it takes a crisis to break that stuff apart and people sometimes tell me you know neil you're you're worth trying it just sounds like a lot of chaos in disaster and i say no you clear out all the stuff that throttles growth and freedom and that prevents the next generation right from growing you rewrite the playing field away from the old back to the young again that's another theme by the way of fourth turnings going into what follows and that is a huge new emphasis on investing in the young”

0.68

For much of the boomer era, higher education was publicly funded; in recent decades (since 1970s), this has shifted to socializing the costs of growing old (Social Security, Medicare) while privatizing the costs of raising kids, creating perverse incentives against having children and suppressing fertility rates

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“higher education when boomers are growing up was still largely funded by the public we move toward completely socializing the cost of growing old in this country and privatizing the cost of raising kids right and then we wonder why their fertility rate's going down”

0.68

Unlike recent American experience, previous Fourth Turnings have had internal resolution (American Civil War), not external, and the civil war Fourth Turning had a 'muddled outcome difficult to define victory' when Americans killed each other, contrasting with typical crisis-and-victory pattern

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· David McAlvany

“let's take the normal american pattern of crisis and victory where that's generally been the case for us maybe you take the civil war out of that mix very different sort of an outcome muddled outcome difficult to define victory when when we're killing ourselves”

0.68

The Federal Reserve and fiscal authorities have now backed not just banks but corporate bond markets, bringing interest rates to near zero and dramatically increasing leverage in the system, creating a more fragile financial architecture than pre-2008

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“there's so much disintermediation now so many companies are borrowing in markets that the fed now had to actually back the bond markets as well as back the banks you know and bring interest rates down”

0.68

Post-crisis Fourth Turnings shift toward conventionality and reinforcement of conventional norms, with fringes de-emphasized; successful populism always legitimizes the center of culture, not the fringes, as seen in the American Revolution, Vietnam, Modi's India, Xi's China, Abe's Japan, and Duterte's Philippines

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“in terms of culture we will actually move toward conventionality uh reinforcement of you know more conventional norms and these will be actually that may seem surprising to believe right now but that's going to be somewhere in kind of the you know ethnic and the linguistic center of america it's going to be a world in which the fringes will be de-emphasized um and populism always moves in that direction successful populism it always moves toward legitimizing the center of the culture never the fringes uh that's actually that was true even in the american revolution it was true in you know vietnam”

0.66

Eastern Europe represents nations that have been unleashed from the Austrian-Hungarian empire and are now expressing themselves in nationalist particularity, creating challenges to prevailing EU orthodoxy (Hungary, Poland), driven especially by younger voters, reflecting pre-crisis rather than post-crisis mood.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Neil Howe

“eastern europe was uh you know it's like the way we used to talk about the austrian-hungarian empire right a prisoner of nations right well these nations have been unleashed you know and then now they're expressing themselves right uh in their nationalistic particularity...it's interesting too that in most of these countries they're getting most of their support from younger voters...where you are in a a kind of pre-crisis as opposed to post-crisis mood”

0.66

Could social mood and its expression be managed differently in a planned/authoritarian economy compared to a democratic one, potentially dampening the social crisis expression of a Fourth Turning through top-down narrative control, social credit systems, or internet kill switches?

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· David McIlvaney

“could those social periods take on a different dimension under a planned economy where social mood or its expression where its expression is managed...if you don't like what's in the news shut up about it or you're going to get uh negative credits...the idea that you're sort of controlling the narrative...the most extreme version might be you know a kill switch for the internet”

0.65

The Silent generation grew up as heavily protected children with 'Shirley Temple' and 'Little Rascals' cultural ideals during the Great Depression and WWII, had long time horizons, played by rules, were conformists, asked about pensions in job interviews, and kept heads down during McCarthyism to protect their permanent records

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“those who came of age uh in the 50s uh very early 60s and that generation grew up as kids heavily protected it was dangerous during the great depression and world war ii they were looked over remember the image of child back then was sort of shirley temple the little rascals these were you know well-behaved kids with a tight envelope of parental and community protection and they were very well behaved coming of age and they had very long time horizons and they played by the rules and joe biden's generation absolutely did that you know they were absolute conformists a fortune magazine had a famous cover story in 1949 called the college class of 49 and the subtitle was taking no chances their first questions on job interviews was about their pension plan he could believe that and they actually got the name the silent generation because they kept their heads down during the mccarthy era they didn't want to raise any waves they didn't want anything to go on their permanent record”

0.64

By end of 2021, the CBO estimates publicly held national debt will reach 108% of GDP, higher than levels at the end of World War II, and this is only 'affordable' at near-zero interest rates; if rates rise again, the entire fiscal picture changes sharply

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Neil Howe

“the cbo now estimates at the end of 2021 we're going to be at something like 108 of gdp and a publicly held national debt that's higher than we were at the end of world war ii right and we never had a war well again that's affordable once interest rates are down near zero right but what happens if they start rising again suddenly everything begins to change”

0.64

Bipartisan sanctions against China have sailed through both House and Senate with nearly unanimous support; both Biden and Trump are attempting to 'out-hawk' each other on China, which is historically unusual and suggests the direction of geopolitical escalation is overdetermined

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Neil Howe

“these sanctions efforts and these you know punishment proposals against china have sailed through both the house and the senate with almost no opposition these are unanimous votes how often in america today do you find unanimous votes and both biden and trump are trying to out-hock each other right now on china i find that fascinating and ominous”

0.64

Evidence of inflation expectations acceleration is visible in falling dollar, accelerating commodity prices, and rising gold prices—signaling that markets are positioned for longer-term inflation rather than depression and deflation.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· David McIlvaney

“you see signs of it i mean this kind of continual fall in the dollar and acceleration and commodity prices um and you know you look at gold i mean you look at kind of all the obvious signposts right and you just see okay the market is expecting something they were getting ready for something longer term here and it's not a huge further leg down in depression and deflation”

0.62

Civic crises—periods of generational upheaval that redefine the nation—have occurred approximately every 80-90 years in American history, including the Glorious Revolution era, American Revolution (1773-1794), Civil War, and Great Depression/World War II (1929-1946), with generational drivers operating whether or not individuals directly experienced the event

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“these have occurred about every 80 or 90 years in american history going all the way back to the very late you know 17th century when are just colonists the the glorious revolution the the war of spanish succession and then a lifetime later we had the american revolution the american civil war the new deal and world war ii”

0.62

Federal Reserve policy is completely regressive in its first-order distributional consequences, benefiting asset owners and incumbents in the S&P 500 while preventing creative destruction that would benefit new entrants and younger generations.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“what you let's just print it i mean literally almost a helicopter money phenomenon has been in force uh you look at the income breakdown of the uh of the people who are receiving unemployment now it's actually amazing it's it's regressive we're just basically giving money to everyone right now and obviously what the fed is doing is completely regressive and who's benefiting from that policy who's first order uh benefiting from that policy and not not only in the short term for the long term because of course this ensconces and protects you know the s p 500 all the incumbents right uh and prevents you know prevents the creative destruction of capitalism”

0.61

The current incentive structure makes childlessness financially preferable to parenthood; non-parents receive payroll taxes from others' children while parents bear all costs of child-rearing, creating rational economic incentives against reproduction.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David McIlvany

“i mean you don't have any kids you're a free writer it's all the other kids are going to pay their payroll taxes to keep you you know with income when you're old and but if you have a kid you have to fund everything yourself where did we ever get that kind of balance”

0.61

America is somewhat more diverse than most democracies (as a nation of immigrants), but only a handful of democracies today practice high immigration and remain reasonably diverse—even these (New Zealand, Australia, Canada) are undertaking a shift toward ethnic nationalism.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Neil Howe

“typically you know in america we've been a somewhat much more diverse culture just by who we are a nation of immigrants they're they're only a handful of and i think most of them in the world today happen to be of anglo-saxon origin you know new zealand australia and so on not canada very high immigration rates uh reasonably diverse cultures but even they are undertake this shift”

0.59

Recent CPI and PPI readings higher than expected triggered a small but noticeable yield curve revolution from 10-year to 30-year treasuries, causing pain in bond markets and fixed income generally, signaling market concern about inflation

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Neil Howe

“we saw indication of that last week in the bond market as we get a higher than expected cpi and ppi read and there is a small revolution of the bond market very small but still across the yield curve 10-year to 30 it was painful to be in those safe havens treasuries and really anything in fixed income”

0.59

The pandemic has exposed America's civic vulnerabilities: lack of adherence to laws, distrust of leaders, absence of top-down federal power, and inability to practice successful containment like Australia and New Zealand, resulting in higher per capita death rates than other high-income nations

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Neil Howe

“one aspect of the pandemic that i think has been particularly demoralizing for americans is to realize what a dysfunctional country they've become relative to the rest of the world right it has exposed all of our civic vulnerabilities that we don't follow laws that we don't trust our leaders that we have no top-down federal power i mean you know i already have the image of this david but you want to look at deaths per capita going on now in in in australia or new zealand even new zealand right a new wave consisting of what six infected people in a population of 5 million trump was actually crowing about that the other day you know well looks like new zealand wasn't successful after all i think we have six new infections about every five minutes in this country my point is is that we do have areas which actually practice successful containment and that now have almost no mobility restrictions you've been going to new zealand no one's wearing face masks right a successfully practiced containment strategy can actually work but in america we don't have the capacity to do it we simply don't have the political trust we don't have the will we don't have the institutions in place and so we're sitting here with a higher current death per capita rate than any other high income nation in the world”

0.59

China will likely be the only major economy in the world with no year-over-year real GDP loss in 2020, demonstrating the effectiveness of its governance model, and this success (alongside its methods which Westerners view as oppressive) reinforces China's claim to superiority

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Neil Howe

“this year they're again they're showing their success china may be the only almost certainly will be the only major economy in the world with no year-over-year loss in real gdp oh my gosh you know look at where the european union the united states are going to come out on that so again and again i mean china shows that its methods which strike us clearly as oppressive authoritarian dictatorial completely unfair and abusive to minorities they'll just say what we have works”

0.56

Freedom House has documented 14 consecutive years of declining liberalism and democracy globally, because peoples are trying to energize around latent majoritarian ethnic worldviews during the current crisis period.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Neil Howe

“freedom house now has its 14th consecutive year of declining liberalism and democracy around the world it is because all of these peoples are trying to energize their latent energies around frankly kind of majoritarian ethnic worldviews”

0.55

If the current Fourth Turning does not result in clear American victory (as happened in previous crises), Americans will need to accommodate themselves to a 'diminished future' and loss of great-power status, which is psychologically difficult for a nation that has never experienced national defeat

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“let's say that the normal american pattern of crisis and victory is different this time maybe that reveals itself in the u.s bond market suffering the us dollar reserve status being set back what are the social dynamics you might expect if crisis leads not to victory but to failure and a loss well it's very different i mean it's accommodating ourselves to a diminished future uh it's as simple as that and we've you know my gosh americans are so privileged we've never been through that experience and it's also i think you see that privilege too and and sort of unrealism about americans when it comes to you know issues of nationality and whether their nation survives”

0.55

The post-millennial/homeland generation (first born in the shadow of Department of Homeland Security) is being raised during the early stages of the Fourth Turning crisis, primarily at home, heavily protected by Gen X parents, and will look to older generations for guidance while responding well to optimism about creating a better future

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“this post-millennial generation we often call them homeland generation the first of them were born in the shadow of the department of homeland security and and i will have to say david they're literally at home more than any other generation in our history i mean you know these are the the quarantines right you think of them right now so anyway there they are and i think one thing you will you will see is that this generation raised at a time of crisis first of all they will be carefully protected by gen x is basically raising them there i think one of the most amazing things and i think predictable things that we see historically is that this gen x kind of generation tends to be very protective as parents and and we predicted that originally and i think it's coming out to be true they're enormously you know they they keep tabs on these kids to make sure they're not doing anything dangerous”

0.55

The ultimate use of social media to foster and amplify social and political solidarity is absolutely in America's future, not just through social credit systems in China but globally—Google and Facebook are trying to avoid responsibility by pushing for government boards to manage content, shifting the role from private to public sector.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“i have no question that the ultimate use of social media to foster and amplify social solidarity political solidarity is absolutely in our future and not just in the social credit system in china all over the world which i think is why google and facebook are trying desperately to get rid of the responsibility for doing it i think ultimately they will want to set up government boards to do it so that they won't have to they can't possibly be the lightning rod for that”

0.55

Asset owners and workers alike became dependent on massive Fed intervention and federal stimulus to survive the pandemic, creating a constituency unlikely to support withdrawal of stimulus and making the continuation of loose monetary/fiscal policy politically essential

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“i can't think of an asset owner now who doesn't know that they would be toast had it not been for this massive fed intervention or workers who know that they counted on that federal unemployment bonus plus ppp to keep them where they are today”

0.53

When millennials take over midlife (post-crisis), America will have a much more homogeneous, sedate, cleaned-up political culture with less edginess, similar to how the GI generation (many of whom were radicals/communists) created a 'cleaned up happified' America in the 1950s-early 1960s under JFK

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Neil Howe

“ultimately when millennials take over in midlife we're going to have a much more homogeneous uh political culture it's going to be much more sedate uh cleaned up uh there's gonna be a lot less edginess to it and i have no doubt about that it's gonna be a little bit like the gi generation back in the 30s who obviously many of them became communists many of them became radicals uh but by the time they inherited america's culture in the 50s and early 60s took over the presidency with with jfk in 1961 it was it was kind of a um what they would have called a a cleaned up happified america”

0.52

The red zone/blue zone divide in America is characterized by mismatched approaches to governance: red zone believes in authority but lacks vision of community (Trump model); blue zone has vision of community but doesn't believe in authority, leaving neither able to execute ambitious policy coherently

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“each of them has a very um a kind of a one-sided dysfunctional approach to what's required civically and that is what's required to govern a country civically and that is the red zone believes in authority but has very little vision right now of community and that's pretty much trump and the blue zone has this great vision of community but doesn't believe in authority and that's a weird place to be in right now if i were the democrats and i believed i was going to believe in all these huge new taxes and income transfers and green new deals and enormous infrastructure i'm going to transfer a lot of income from the rich the poor i would think i better believe in authority how how else am i going to enforce any of that right”

0.52

If Democrats win the 2020 election and implement their policies (taxes, income transfers, Green New Deal), the red zone will likely test the blue zone through nullification or secession, refusing to obey regulations or pay taxes; secession by red states is more plausible than blue zone secession because red states have military/weapons capacity and blue zone would not enforce federal authority

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Neil Howe

“if the blue zone wins so to speak in november the red zone will test the blue zone will basically say well we're just not going to obey we're not going to pay that tax we're not going to obey that regulation and what are you going to do to stop us right what's your authority what are you gonna do now much as we like to think when the blue zone was in power you know the during the obama years and then when trump took over then we had our sanctuary cities and sanctuary states disagreeing on everything from you know marijuana to to uh to ice and you know undocumented immigrants i never thought that secession by the blue zone was ever a serious threat because i think the blue zone feels ultimately it sort of inherits or deserves you know national institutions national power i do think that's that's a greater threat by the red zone”

0.49

A complete adoption of a social credit system in the United States is unlikely; instead, the key conflict in upcoming US-China geopolitical competition will be posed as a choice: does America want to adopt China's surveillance/social credit model to compete, or maintain liberal values?

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Neil Howe

“i think the complete adoption of a social credit system in the united states i don't think will ever happen and in fact in any upcoming conflict with china i think that will be how the issue is posed right does america want to become and drawn into that kind of world so that's how it's going to come down”

0.48

The election of Donald Trump represented the most incredibly unlikely candidate in American history to win an election, signaling a profound shift in the American mood toward populism and dissatisfaction with existing institutions

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“i think we certainly saw with the election of donald trump i would say the most incredibly unlikely candidate in american history to win an election but it really said something about where the american mood is”

0.48

Crisis-era generations will respond well to optimism about creating a better future and believe that crisis is the price paid for a subsequent golden age; this psychological resilience comes from generational archetype patterns rather than individual personality.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“it will be a dangerous time right they will look to older people for clues for guidance they will be generally very well behaved and they will respond well to optimism about the future you get a bunch of exers and boomers together and they're often you know you know very uh kind of a lot of gallows humor about where the future is going to go i think this is a generation responds very well to optimism that through all this stuff that's going to happen we'll create a better world all right we've done so repeatedly in the past we will do it again and that this you know the these period of troubles is the price we pay for a golden age that's what you need to get there”

0.48

Homeland generation will have the leisure and luxury to improve on post-crisis order after crisis closes, taking America to higher levels of civilization without having to deal with horrible crisis management decisions themselves.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“they will be able to inherit that they will be able to improve it i mean they will be the ones who come in hopefully just after the crisis either is over or is closing and then have the leisure and luxury to improve things to take us up to an even higher level you know not to deal with the horrible things but to take us up and and you know enjoy even higher levels of civilization”

0.48

Homeland generation will be similarly careful about what goes on the internet and what gets recorded, echoing Silent generation's concern with 'permanent record', indicating continuity of archetype characteristics across generations despite different technologies.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Neil Howe

“and you can see that about kids today you know very careful about what goes on the internet what gets recorded right same thing and this will be i think like all generations the generation we need right now and a generation which will serve to take us where we need to go coming of age coming into adult careers beginning to come in at least young leadership roles once the crisis is over”

0.47

Xi Jinping's position on Hong Kong is inexorable and will inevitably lead to suppression of all movements, bringing Chinese power to bear; this will force U.S., UK, and EU response through sanctions, which could trigger corporate sanctions and nuclear financial options.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Neil Howe

“i believe that what's happening now in hong kong is actually has an almost inexorable logic it's a little bit like a slow-motion prequel to world war one where inevitably china basically xi jinping is absolutely adamant he is going to suppress all of these movements in hong kong and ultimately he's going to bring the entire power of china to bear on this and i think ultimately not just the united states but the uk and the eu are going to have to respond to this and ultimately that means sanctions and they're already being placed on individuals once those sanctions are are in place on actual corporations and that involves the banks that becomes kind of like a nuclear option financially and in terms of trade”

0.45

A critical near-term uncertainty (within ~18 months) is whether stimulus will be interrupted or reconfirmed; if interrupted, a Biden victory and continuation of stimulus could accelerate inflation expectations, creating a complete 'game changer' that forces the Fed to reverse course and abandon its commitment to holding rates near zero

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Neil Howe

“the threat that stimulus may stop for a while and as you know i think everyone in american economics is really trying to track that interruption of stimulus plus the coming back of copenhagen infections they're running about you know deaths nationwide on a seven-day average or about double where they were a month ago used to be around 500 now they're over a thousand”

0.45

The survival industry (safe rooms, armed security, arms sales) collapsed when Trump won in 2016 because red-zone voters viewed Trump as strength/security, but has recovered as Biden looks likely to win, showing that the market for red-zone security concerns is counter-cyclical to red-zone electoral power.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Neil Howe

“the whole survival industry you know everything from uh you know all of the the safe rooms and and the arms sales and all that hugely tanked when surprisingly trump won the presidency in 2016 the bottom went out of that industry right so all of this all of the equity value those republic you know collapsed they're coming back up again by the way as a prospect of abiding presidents so that's an industry that's almost completely counter-cyclical to uh red zone being in power”

0.45

The Democratic Party has moved ideologically faster in recent years than at any other point, with policy proposals including doubling the federal minimum wage, free college for all or most, large-scale infrastructure and Green New Deal programs, and major tax structure changes, reflecting a rapid leftward shift across the party

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Neil Howe

“we've seen the democratic party move ideologically uh faster than i've ever seen it move my lifetime we have a candidate who's clearly and moderate in his party seeking to portray i think we've actually seen now in the convention that's taking place the online incredible online convention that we now have a reasonably moderate face of the party but there's no question that this party is moving very rapidly you know to things that we wouldn't really have imagined a doubling of the federal minimum wage uh you know uh government provision of higher education for everyone some form of higher education you know free college for all or free college for most perhaps and then a large infrastructure and new new deal or green new deal program”

0.45

In Fourth Turnings, a possibility of the nation galvanizing around a total all-important civic project is highly likely, and typically in American history it has been a total war—this is something to look for as a potential crisis catalyst.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Neil Howe

“we have a number of things as you recall from the chapter we wrote on the fourth turning that you can look for obviously the possibility of the nation galvanizing around some total all-important civic project right with a particular end is highly likely and typically in our history it's it's been a war usually a total war right and that's i think also something you should look for hopefully we can avoid the tragedy and destruction but it needs to be something of urgency for the nation to actually to execute in some way”

0.44

Millennials show stronger support than older generations (~20 percentage points higher) for strict containment and national top-down COVID policy, which is contrary to their self-interest since they are most likely to lose work/income and least likely to die from COVID, suggesting they sense a civic vacuum and are responding to institutional dysfunction

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Neil Howe

“millennials the younger generation is most in favor of strict containment and a national top-down policy which is interesting dave wouldn't think about it because from a and by the way this is true with about 20 percentage points older people most want voluntary containment you know no one tells me what to do right i mean i can go if i don't want to wear a mask i won't wear them i'm an individual all of this stuff those are your early way of exers and boomers who are saying that millennials want a strict containment policy and it's interesting when you look at it from a self-interest point of view that's exactly opposite to their self-interest i should say contrary to this self-interest millennials are the most likely to lose work and lose income with strict containment and they're the least likely to get sick or die from this disease right so if millennials were acting in their own self-interests they would be most in favor of no containment at all but i do think the reason why you're seeing millennials do that is they sense just an awesome civic vacuum in this country and they're trying to respond to that”

0.26

The 2020 election represents a pre-crisis moment where political leadership will be tested and gradually discredited; as crises express themselves (via rolling blackouts like 2021 California, financial stress, or other catalysts), confidence in institutions deteriorates

forecastspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· David McAlvany

“i think of the rolling blackouts in california years ago they've returned this summer the crisis dynamics seemed to be sort of rolling as well that i'm thinking specifically in terms of financial markets but the tech crash in 2000 2001 followed by massive monetary and fiscal interventions that gave us the real estate bubble crash of 2008 and 9”

0.19

The Fourth Turning model, published in the mid-1990s, has remained useful for nearly two decades despite being a model, and continues to serve as a talking point (now approaching cliché) for understanding contemporary events, though its predictive power should be continually tested against new information

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· David McAlvany

“this is a book that was written in the early 1990s and came out i think it was in the mid 90s and it's still being used now in fact not only is it a model in a way it's a talking point you'll hear people say well we're in a fourth turning well that's a cliche at this point”

0.19

Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell has committed to keeping the yield curve nailed to the floor for two years regardless of inflation pressures, signaling the Fed's determination to maintain near-zero rates and prevent inflation expectations from driving policy normalization

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Neil Howe

“it's worth to keep in mind although um you know jerome powell denies it he says you know the yield curve is is nailed to the floor for two years you know nothing's going to change his mind i mean he wants to do everything possible to to keep expectations firmly rooted there”

0.19

The failure to pass a stimulus extension before the 2020 election was surprising and rendered additional macro uncertainty; the speaker expected Trump to support stimulus for electoral reasons and was surprised when neither Trump nor conservative Republicans backed a sufficiently large extension

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· David McAlvany

“i think the failure to sign on to an extension of stimulus just renders even more uncertainty right now on the outlook i think most people were certainly we were expecting that to that was too important for trump not to sign on uh and i think i was surprised at everyone else that they failed to come to an agreement”

0.19

The reasons for stimulus negotiation failure included: on the conservative/Trump side, Trump's resistance to funding the postal service and conservative Republican opposition to funding state and local governments.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· David McIlvaney

“i think on the conservative side and on the trump side i think you know trump the whole idea of the postal service seemed to stick in his craw and i think for the conservative republicans i mean this whole thing doesn't taste very good to them i think neither of them wanted to give all that much money to just to state local governments”

0.13

A new book by Howe is due in early 2022 that continues the Fourth Turning analysis, suggesting ongoing development and updating of the generational framework.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Neil Howe

“yes better yet read the book a new book by the way is going to be due probably in early 2022 so you know it's not over uh in terms of what i'm writing about it”