right reason
In Ockham's ethics, reflection on our experience of contingent events and circumstances to determine what would be best or most reasonable in particular situations; an empirical approach to ethics rather than derivation from universal essences
As defined in A History of Philosophy | 28 Summing Up Ockham's Revolution
Where it comes up · 3
- A History of Philosophy | 30 Thomas Hobbes6 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 29 Francis Bacon3 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 28 Summing Up Ockham's Revolution2 claims
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “right reason” →
- Hobbes distinguishes between the natural state (a condition of conflict and power struggle with no natural right other than the desire to survive, and no natural law in the Aquinas sense) and natural law (which he redefines as the dictates of right reason—consequentialist thinking about the effects of actions).A History of Philosophy | 30 Thomas Hobbes
- John Calvin, trained as a lawyer, was influenced by Stoic jurisprudence and natural law theory; he saw natural law as invariable and unchanging (following Stoic metaphysics) rather than contextual and mutable (following Ockham's approach via right reason).A History of Philosophy | 28 Summing Up Ockham's Revolution
- Hobbes proposes that what a body politic needs is a covenant in which, out of right reason, citizens vest authority in an absolute ruler who has complete authority over them, except the ruler cannot destroy citizens because self-preservation takes precedence over any covenant.A History of Philosophy | 30 Thomas Hobbes
- Natural laws that right reason and prudence dictate for self-preservation are: first, seek peace; and second, keep covenant with others when you enter into an agreement or contract.A History of Philosophy | 30 Thomas Hobbes
- Dewey extends experimental thinking to ethics, whereas Bacon does not; Bacon's ethical framework appeals to 'right reason'—prudence influenced by classical conceptions and Renaissance Platonism—rather than extending his experimental methodology to moral questions.A History of Philosophy | 29 Francis Bacon
- Bacon explicitly states that 'knowledge is power,' and while this power must be controlled by appropriate ethics grounded in 'true religion and right reason,' he does not have a metaphysical basis for ethics from scholastic natural law tradition.A History of Philosophy | 29 Francis Bacon
- Ockham appeals to 'right reason'—reflection on our experience of contingent events in creation—as the basis for ethics rather than natural law, representing a kind of consequentialist approach where moral assessment depends on evaluating particular consequences rather than deriving from essential natures.A History of Philosophy | 28 Summing Up Ockham's Revolution
- Right reason is consequentialist thinking: one can reason correctly about consequences and can do right reasoning by understanding causal processes, making knowledge of causes essential to moral reasoning.A History of Philosophy | 30 Thomas Hobbes
- Bacon has some favorable view of Ockham, and a historian of science named Crombie has argued that Bacon's tables of presence, absence, and degree were anticipated in similar form by William of Ockham, and that Bacon's ethical appeals to true religion and right reason are essentially the same as Ockham's appeals.A History of Philosophy | 29 Francis Bacon
- The sovereign has authority over religious matters and interpretation, with God's laws binding through right reason, direct revelation, or the authority of rulers; the ruler's authoritative interpretation of divine commands settles religious disputes, implementing Hobbes's Erastian settlement.A History of Philosophy | 30 Thomas Hobbes