regulatory capture
The phenomenon where regulators come to serve the interests of the industries they are meant to regulate, often through information control rather than only a revolving door.
As defined in et_608
Other definitions
When special interests gain control over the regulatory process so that policies protect incumbents and block disruptive innovation; invoked to explain Europe banning Uber.
Bruno MaçãesSituation in which a regulatory agency or regulation serves the interests of the industry it is supposed to oversee, often through proximity, lobbying, and revolving relationships.
Bill Gurley & Michael Mauboussin - Putting Theory into Practice - [Invest Like the Best, EP.370]
Where it comes up · 65
- #61 Malcom McLean: The Box: How the Shipping Container Made the World Smaller and the World Economy Bigger6 claims
- Legendary Investor Bill Gurley on Investing Rules, Insights from Jeff Bezos, Must-Read Books, & More5 claims
- Bill Gurley & Michael Mauboussin - Putting Theory into Practice - [Invest Like the Best, EP.370]5 claims
- Yochai Benkler on Net Neutrality, Competition, and the Future of the Internet 04/05/20104 claims
- Inside the Mind of A Famous Investor | Marc Andreessen3 claims
- All Things Business and Investing3 claims
- #54 The Epic Life of Cornelius Vanderbilt3 claims
- Daniel Carpenter3 claims
and 57 more
Most important claims · 10 of 117Search all claims for “regulatory capture” →
- The early American market contained two waves that crashed together: an individualistic, anti-aristocratic impulse rooted in small farms, stores, and workshops, and an organizing impulse by commercially advanced wealthy men who built banks and corporations and sought to suppress competition.#54 The Epic Life of Cornelius Vanderbilt
- Regulatory agencies are constrained by equilibria among competing interests and idiosyncratic institutional features, so good economic ideas do not win on their merits, and scholars must understand that policy outcomes reflect who has more money and influence on each side.Thomas Hazlett on Telecommunications 11/24/2008
- Roberts argues, following George Stigler, that the 'Ralph Nader theory of regulation' (regulation fails because regulators are captured, so the fix is better regulators) is wrong, since the real problem is the incentives the regulator faces; Alan Greenspan's regulatory failures would have occurred with any occupant of the job.Patri Friedman on Seasteading 10/13/2008
- Regulators tend to design regulation in favor of the industry they regulate not because they are corrupt, but because they psychologically absorb the views of the people who provide them information and follow their decisions, and because they face career incentives to not burn bridges with an industry that can later employ them at much higher pay.Luigi Zingales on Incentives and the Potential Capture of Economists by Special Interests
- Wealthy organizers of the era owned politicians and had them structure legislation so that it appeared to regulate industry while actually creating barriers to entry and solidifying incumbents' positions, a mechanism of regulatory capture.#54 The Epic Life of Cornelius Vanderbilt
- Kreuger's lead Swedish banker Oscar Rydbeck persuaded regulators to issue advisory warnings without binding rules, because the banks were also Kreuger's largest shareholders and collected fat dividends from his companies.#348 The Financial Genius Behind A Century of Wall Street Scandals: Ivar Kreuger
- The ability of truth-seeking processes to find truth is now constrained by the extent to which the truth 'gores a billionaire's ox,' turning truth-seeking into an auction; this stems from monopoly concentration that captures regulators (the Boeing 737 MAX self-regulation, FCC chairs drawn from Comcast and Verizon), casting people into an epistemological void where they can die because they cannot know what is true.69 | Cory Doctorow on Technology, Monopoly, and the Future of the Internet
- 'Capture' is too seductive a term—thrown around whenever a pundit dislikes a regulatory decision—but it is orthogonal to whether an agency does a good or efficient job, and it is genuinely hard to prove because you need a counterfactual of an uncaptured agency ceteris paribus, while existing empirical studies suffer from omitted-variable bias.Daniel Carpenter
- Insull pushed for government-regulated utility monopolies, which he viewed as the best tool for expanding his customer base, and this push led to regulatory capture arguments, though it became the basis for modern utility regulation.#336 How To Lose A Few Billion Dollars: Samuel Insull
- Drawing on Schumpeter and Adam Smith, monopolies cannot last long under their own weight—Twitter is not a monopoly since bigger platforms exist and young people are abandoning Facebook—but they can endure when the state grants monopoly power through law; this is why incumbents like Zuckerberg beg for regulation, since compliance costs create barriers to entry that entrench them (corporatism / regulatory capture).296 - Repairing Our Country