reductio ad absurdum
A method of argument that takes a premise to its logical extreme to show it yields an absurd or ridiculous conclusion.
As defined in Michael Munger on Desires, Morality, and Self-Interest
Other definitions
A logical technique in which a principle or idea is taken to its logical extreme to demonstrate that it has become unreasonable or untenable
We've Been Here Before: George Friedman on U.S. Cycles
Where it comes up · 16
- Permanent Capital Investing in Vertical SaaS1 claim
- Dr. Darren Staloff, Presocratics: Ionian Speculation and Eliatic Metaphysics1 claim
- Michael Munger on Desires, Morality, and Self-Interest1 claim
- 11 - Shouldering The Burden Of History1 claim
- 299 - Steps In The Right Direction1 claim
- 467 - Ea Ai And The End Of Work1 claim
- Ask Me Anything 151 claim
- 121 - White Power1 claim
and 8 more
Most important claims · 10 of 16Search all claims for “reductio ad absurdum” →
- Some people must be in the business of seriously reasoning through even weird-seeming ethical ideas, because history shows that moral progress consistently came from 'moral weirdos'—the early Quakers who opposed slavery, were vegetarian, and supported women's suffrage and pacifism were mocked as absurd, yet their then-fringe views became modern moral common sense; humanity has a long track record of getting morality badly wrong.467 - Ea Ai And The End Of Work
- Banning all imports would not raise total employment: domestic workers would shift to making goods that were imported, consumers would pay more, and the result would be a poorer, self-sufficient America, so self-sufficiency is the road to poverty and trade is a form of cooperation.Engerman on Slavery 11/21/2006
- Zeno of Elea developed reductio ad absurdum as a formal argumentative technique—proving a contradiction from the opponent's position—which Socrates would later use extensively, demonstrating the power of pure logical argumentDr. Darren Staloff, Presocratics: Ionian Speculation and Eliatic Metaphysics
- Standard economics has no coherent theory of preferences over preferences—a hypothetical 'preference store' where one could buy preference orderings is incoherent in the usual framing—because economists treat preferences as subjectively whatever they are rather than as something one can rationally evaluate as better or worse.Michael Munger on Desires, Morality, and Self-Interest
- Even if AI could generate software from prompts, a vertical system such as an aviation MRO ERP would still require deep knowledge of how the industry works, such as inventory and parts handling, so industry insight remains the moat.Permanent Capital Investing in Vertical SaaS
- A revised consequentialism can capture everything we want to say about moral truth, because purported non-consequentialist objections (like the deontological organ-harvesting trolley case) actually rely on an incomplete tally of consequences—the doctor-vivisection example is rejected precisely because of the terror and paranoia of living in a society where such killings are normal, which is itself a consequence.299 - Steps In The Right Direction
- Kant's proof procedure for the antinomies uses reductio ad absurdum: assume the thesis is false, derive consequences, show those consequences are themselves false, therefore the thesis must be true—but he shows this procedure equally 'proves' both thesis and antithesis, revealing the method itself is flawedA History of Philosophy | 54 Kant on Metaphysics
- The reductio ad absurdum of these anti-intervention concerns is pacifism—an unwillingness ever to use force even when one has the power to do so—which allows the thugs of the world to inherit the earth and create immense human misery generation after generation; the world needs some way to respond to malignant despotism, so the real question is how difficult that project is, not whether it should exist.11 - Shouldering The Burden Of History
- Pacifism is an absurd and morally obscene position because it presupposes a non-pacifist world able to rise to the victims' defense; Gandhi's advice that Jews willingly go to their deaths to scandalize the world's conscience would, in practice, merely have simplified the Nazis' logistical problems.354 - Is Moral Progress A Fantasy
- Most people, however deranged their beliefs, feel some burden not to be self-contradictory, so if a conversation runs long enough an honest interlocutor can put them in positions where two cherished beliefs conflict—a reductio ad absurdum that is the most effective challenge to a worldview, even though the on-stage opponent rarely changes while the listening audience often does.121 - White Power