rational choice
The framework treating rationality as picking among pre-given options with fixed information and fixed desires, asking only which option best satisfies those desires.
As defined in Agnes Callard on Aspiration
Where it comes up · 4
- Agnes Callard on Aspiration3 claims
- 217 | Margaret Levi on Moral Political Economy3 claims
- Fareed Zakaria1 claim
- Will Davies on the Economics, Economists, and the Limits of Neoliberalism1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “rational choice” →
- Nudge (choice architecture)—altering how choices are presented to help people choose better outcomes—is not a radical departure from the Chicago School's rational-choice model but an attempt to rescue the status quo: it merely tweaks the model and shares responsibility for economic optimization across a wider range of human and non-human agents (like smartphones), allowing the neoliberal utopia of universal calculation and optimization to spread even further into our lives.Will Davies on the Economics, Economists, and the Limits of Neoliberalism
- In both World Wars, Anglophone Canadians volunteered and supported conscription at high rates while Francophone Canadians did not, despite Francophones being poorer (and thus, by narrow economic logic, more likely to take military pay during a depression)—showing people act rationally given different ethical and identity 'maximands' rooted in culture and perceived fair treatment by central government, not just material self-interest.217 | Margaret Levi on Moral Political Economy
- Zakaria left academia partly because political science was shifting away from a broad discipline rooted in history and the humanities toward rational choice and game theory, driven by an 'economist envy' paralleling economists' 'math envy.'Fareed Zakaria
- Rational choice political economy is valuable for being parsimonious, rigorous, and falsifiable, but its assumptions of narrow material self-interest, individualism, and (initially) institution-free analysis are unrealistic; the Kahneman-Tversky research program on cognitive biases showed our rationality and the sources of our beliefs are more complex, so explaining behavior requires bringing in context, institutions, and group biases beyond what rational choice provides.217 | Margaret Levi on Moral Political Economy
- The economic model of choice—fixed preferences, income, and prices yielding utility maximization—reduces life to an engineering problem; this is too sterile because the real challenge, both for individuals and for firms, is discovering what is on the shelf and which market or values to pursue, not merely optimizing quantities among known options.Agnes Callard on Aspiration
- Large transformations in people's lives are rational, but their rationality is not captured by the framework of decision-making; rather than picking among fixed pre-articulated options with fixed information and desires, the aspirant undergoes a temporally-extended learning process in which information, desires, and the mode of evaluation are all changing, so its rationality can only be seen across a stretch of time, not at an instant.Agnes Callard on Aspiration
- There are two distinct forms of rationality that must not be conflated: reasoning from value (the legitimate economic mode of choosing among options given fixed preferences and information) and reasoning toward value (the aspirational mode of moving toward acquiring preferences one does not yet have); the latter is a learning process and cannot be understood as a special case of the former.Agnes Callard on Aspiration
- Rational choice theory became counterintuitively identified with neoliberalism and 'public choice,' carrying a perceived conservative, individualist bias that many believe is intrinsic but Levi argues need not be—she adopted it as arguably the most radical person in her department, showing the framework can serve progressive normative commitments.217 | Margaret Levi on Moral Political Economy