causal

Francophone vs Anglophone Conscription Behavior

In both World Wars, Anglophone Canadians volunteered and supported conscription at high rates while Francophone Canadians did not, despite Francophones being poorer (and thus, by narrow economic logic, more likely to take military pay during a depression)—showing people act rationally given different ethical and identity 'maximands' rooted in culture and perceived fair treatment by central government, not just material self-interest.

causalpending

Speaker

Margaret Levi

Evidence Quote

“that was a case where they were both acting rationally, given their preferences, but they had different ethical maximands as well as interest maximands.”

Source

217 | Margaret Levi on Moral Political Economy— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:10:31 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...