proletariat
In Marxist theory, the working class who sell their labor, contrasted with the property-owning bourgeoisie.
As defined in Rick Spence
Where it comes up · 5
- Vejas Liulevicius4 claims
- Rick Spence2 claims
- Robert Service on Trotsky 07/26/20102 claims
- Conversations with Tyler - Julia Ioffe1 claim
- Can we Fix Capitalism? Yanis Varoufakis vs Gillian Tett1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “proletariat” →
- Although Trotsky did not physically sign many execution warrants (the Cheka under Dzerzhinsky did that), his role as architect of one of the most gruesome state terror dictatorships of the 20th century is obscured by his romantic reputation as a Garibaldi-like revolutionary; he formulated the rationale that reconciliation between proletarian and middle-class parties was impossible, so violence should be inflicted first and big.Robert Service on Trotsky 07/26/2010
- Marxism originated in Germany, which had the largest Marxist party and where Marx expected revolution to begin—40% of Germany's population were industrial workers versus only 5% in Russia—so Germany, not the unindustrialized Soviet Union, was the natural home for Marxism.Rick Spence
- Orthodox Marxists considered sorting people by anything other than class, including gender, anathema, because class was seen as trumping everything and gender was a red herring used by elites to divide the proletariat.Conversations with Tyler - Julia Ioffe
- Marx's key prediction of growing misery (Verelendung/immiseration)—that the working class condition would continuously worsen until a final revolutionary explosion—was already failing in his own lifetime in developed economies like Britain and Germany, where reform movements and unions carved out improved conditions, undermining the empirical core of his forecast.Vejas Liulevicius
- A frequent reality of communist movements is that the founding elites were not factory workers who experienced industrialization firsthand but intellectuals; Marx and Engels carved out a special role for exceptional individuals who could transcend their class origins to ally with the proletariat, a celebration of intellectuals as world-movers that is intrinsically appealing to intellectuals and produced a persistent gap between revolutionaries and the classes they claimed to represent.Vejas Liulevicius
- Marxism categorizes people by class (proletariat versus bourgeoisie), which to a nationalist appears to divide Germans against each other, whereas the Thule Society's mystical nationalism held that all Germans belong to a single racial family—two competing ways to influence the same population.Rick Spence
- Marx expected the revolution to occur in industrialized, developed Germany (also Britain, France, eventually the US), so it is a central irony that the first government claiming to realize his vision arose in the wreckage of the agrarian, under-industrialized Russian Empire; the Bolsheviks knew this was a gamble and staked their survival on a workers' revolution erupting in Germany to link up with theirs—which never came.Vejas Liulevicius
- Trotsky's reputation as a romantic figure (likened to Garibaldi or Bolívar) rests on his role inspiring the Red Army in the Civil War and the fact that he did not personally sign many death warrants (Dzerzhinsky ran the Cheka), but this overlooks his role as one of the architects of one of the most gruesome state-terror dictatorships of the 20th century, justified by his conviction that violent struggle between proletariat and middle classes was inevitable, so one should strike first and big.Robert Service on Trotsky 07/26/2010
- Capitalism has two defining characteristics throughout all its historical transformations: (1) profits are the fuel that drives it and get reinvested as new capital, and (2) markets are created through commodification of land and labor, creating the labor market following enclosuresCan we Fix Capitalism? Yanis Varoufakis vs Gillian Tett
- Marx and Engels formed one of the most important and influential intellectual partnerships in history despite being very different men: Marx an academic-turned-radical-journalist married to a baron's daughter, dynamic and determined to dominate arguments; Engels the son of an industrialist who owned factories—decidedly not a member of the proletariat they celebrated.Vejas Liulevicius