precedent
A prior judicial decision whose articulated principle is treated as binding or persuasive authority for deciding later analogous cases.
As defined in The Underrated Bruno Leoni (with Michael Munger)
Other definitions
An earlier ruling whose principle is used to guide decisions in later, similar cases.
Jimmy Wales on Wikipedia 03/09/2009
Where it comes up · 6
- Context Graphs: AI's Next Big Idea6 claims
- The Underrated Bruno Leoni (with Michael Munger)2 claims
- Jimmy Wales on Wikipedia 03/09/20091 claim
- Jamal Greene1 claim
- Skyrocketing Debt and Inflated Energy Prices Threaten to Break the System: Luke Gromen1 claim
- 149 | Lee Smolin on Time, Philosophy, and the Nature of Reality1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “precedent” →
- Common law is judge-made law in which a judge renders a decision and articulates a principle, and that principle becomes precedent only if other judges over time find it useful for adjudicating analogous cases; legal reasoning proceeds by analogy, with adversarial disputants arguing over which precedent applies.The Underrated Bruno Leoni (with Michael Munger)
- The arbitration committee is the last stop in Wikipedia's dispute resolution process and functions somewhat like a Supreme Court. It is very aware of precedent, and the principles in its findings are later cited by editors to resolve disputes without escalating to the committee.Jimmy Wales on Wikipedia 03/09/2009
- Leoni's ideal judge needs no training in jurisprudence or memorization of legislation; the judge's job is literally to decide the right outcome in this case by discovering what was expected at the time of a contract by people like the disputants in similar settings—a role better suited to a social scientist or field researcher than to a traditional legal expert.The Underrated Bruno Leoni (with Michael Munger)
- Another category of missing decision traces is precedent from past decisions—for example, 'we structured a similar deal for company X last quarter, we should be consistent'—which is common organizational knowledge that lives in conversations rather than queryable databases.Context Graphs: AI's Next Big Idea
- Supreme Court justices should mostly or entirely be lawyers, but they need not come straight from judging; experience from politics, academia, or other forms of lawyering is valuable because the Supreme Court's role differs—cases are closer, less bound by precedent, and frequently decide serious political and moral questions.Jamal Greene
- With context graphs, companies can audit and debug autonomy at a level previously impossible, turn exceptions into precedent instead of relearning the same edge cases in Slack every quarter, and capture feedback loops where decision traces become searchable precedent and every automated decision adds another trace to the graph, creating compound value.Context Graphs: AI's Next Big Idea
- As humans and agent workers negotiate their relationship, much of the remaining human roles are likely to be in areas of judgment—making decisions that cannot be reduced to rules or precedent.Context Graphs: AI's Next Big Idea
- Agents need access to decision traces that show how rules were applied in the past, where exceptions were granted, how conflicts were resolved, who approved what, and which precedents actually govern organizational reality.Context Graphs: AI's Next Big Idea
- A context graph is the sum total of decision traces stitched across entities in time—a living record of decision traces that makes precedent searchable over time and becomes the real source of truth for autonomy by explaining not just what happened but why it was allowed to happen.Context Graphs: AI's Next Big Idea
- Context graphs represent an entire missing category of information: the decision traces, exceptions, overrides, precedents, and cross-system context that currently lives in Slack threads, deal conversations, escalation calls, and people's heads, which Ball's framing assumes already exists somewhere but actually doesn't.Context Graphs: AI's Next Big Idea