normative

Justices need not come from the judiciary

Supreme Court justices should mostly or entirely be lawyers, but they need not come straight from judging; experience from politics, academia, or other forms of lawyering is valuable because the Supreme Court's role differs—cases are closer, less bound by precedent, and frequently decide serious political and moral questions.

normativepending

Speaker

Jamal Greene

Evidence Quote

“Elena Kagan didn’t come from judging, and she’s a terrific Supreme Court justice. Hugo Black didn’t come from judging.”

Source

Jamal Greene— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:24:33 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...