plebiscite
A direct popular vote on a single political question, contrasted by Luce with representative decision-making.
As defined in Ed Luce
Other definitions
A direct public vote on a proposal, such as a referendum on whether a city should host an event.
Olympic Games: The Price of Glory
Where it comes up · 4
- Olympic Games: The Price of Glory2 claims
- Ed Luce1 claim
- 57 - An Evening With Richard Dawkins And Sam Harris 11 claim
- A Flawed Trade System in Europe || Peter Zeihan1 claim
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “plebiscite” →
- Denver, which the IOC had awarded the 1976 Winter Olympics, held a referendum in which voters rejected hosting because they judged it too expensive and environmentally unsound.Olympic Games: The Price of Glory
- The EU ratification process is decentralized: not only must the European Union as a whole sign, seal, and deliver the treaty, but each member government must also sign off, and some member governments require plebiscites while others require regional legislatures to approve.A Flawed Trade System in Europe || Peter Zeihan
- As costs became clear, cities turned against hosting through referenda, city council votes, and petition drives, reducing the field of bidders from five to eight cities down to one to three.Olympic Games: The Price of Glory
- Following Edmund Burke's defense of representative over plebiscitary democracy during the French Revolution, complex ethical, legal, societal, and international decisions cannot be decided by plebiscite—even online—and require delegating authority to full-time representatives who can be fired at the next election; the only alternatives are Robespierre-style instant democracy or a Singapore-style rule of experts, and nothing beats representative democracy.Ed Luce
- Major, irreversible, far-reaching decisions like leaving the EU are too complex and sophisticated to be decided by referendum; representative democracy exists precisely because such questions—requiring expertise akin to a PhD in economics—should not be settled by a bare 50% majority on a day when fluctuating public opinion happens to spike, especially without a two-thirds supermajority safeguard.57 - An Evening With Richard Dawkins And Sam Harris 1