
A Flawed Trade System in Europe || Peter Zeihan
What this covers
This is a three-minute monologue by Peter Zeihan, built around the EU's pending trade deal with Australia. He uses that deal as a test case for whether Europe could replace the US-anchored trading order with one of its own. The case rests on three structural problems: naval reach, agriculture, and the slowness of approval. He starts with the Navy. Europeans cannot project power much beyond their own front yard, so any trade that goes past Turkey, Russia, or North Africa still depends on US protection.
The rest of the piece concerns the mechanics of EU deal-making. Zeihan describes a decentralized ratification process. The EU as a whole must sign, and so must each member government. Some members require a plebiscite, and others require approval from regional legislatures. He points to Belgium as the real sticking point that held up the Canada agreement, which was negotiated in the early 2010s and took 11 years to get through. He also cites the Mercosur block deal, negotiated around 2001 and only now finished.
Agriculture is where he gets most pointed. Europe is aggressively protectionist on farm goods, and he says most deals of the past 30 years either left agriculture out or went nowhere. Australia, a major agricultural exporter, has reasonably insisted that access to its raw materials come with access for its beef, lamb, and wheat. The deal was negotiated in under a year, but Zeihan notes that European farm groups and the French already say it cannot be ratified. His forecast is that if it does clear every hurdle, large-scale Australian goods might reach Europe around 2040, a date he says he won't be working long enough to see.
European attempts to build non-US alternatives to the international order face three fundamental structural obstacles: dependence on US Navy for maritime security, protectionist agricultural policies that block trade negotiations, and a ratification process so cumbersome that trade deals take decades to finalize.
- Europe lacks naval capacity to project power beyond its region and therefore cannot secure its own trade routes without US Navy protection
- European agricultural protectionism is incompatible with modern trade deals, causing negotiations to either exclude agriculture or stall indefinitely
- The EU's decentralized ratification system requiring member state and sometimes regional approval, plus occasional plebiscites, makes trade deals take 20-40 years from negotiation to implementation
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
If Europeans want to trade beyond their immediate region (past Turkey, Russia, or North Africa), they really do need the security that the US Navy grants.
“if they want to trade with Turkey or Russia or North Africa, sure, but anything beyond that they really do need the security that the US Navy grants.”
There is no international trade without the US Navy because the Europeans absolutely do not have the capacity to project naval power very far past their own front yard.
“there is no international trade without the US Navy. The Europeans absolutely do not have the capacity to project naval power very far past their own front yard.”
The EU ratification process is decentralized: not only must the European Union as a whole sign, seal, and deliver the treaty, but each member government must also sign off, and some member governments require plebiscites while others require regional legislatures to approve.
“The issue is not only does the European Union have to sign, seal, and deliver the treaty, each of the member governments then has to sign off and some of those member governments require plebiscites. Some of them require regional legislatures uh signing off.”
Europeans are aggressively protectionist, particularly when it comes to agriculture, and most trade deals negotiated in the last 30 years have found a way to leave agriculture out of the equation, which means they haven't really negotiated many trade deals in the last 30 years.
“the Europeans are aggressively protectionist, particularly when it comes to agriculture. And most trade deals that have been negotiated in the last 30 years have found a way to kind of leave that out of the equation, um which is a way of saying that they really haven't negotiated many trade deals in the last 30 years”
Australia is a massive agricultural producer and exporter and has insisted, reasonably, that any trade deal accessing raw materials must also allow access for their trade goods (beef, lamb, wheat, etc.).
“Australia is a massive agricultural producer and exporter and they have insisted, reasonably, that any trade deal that is going to access the raw materials also has to allow access for their trade goods, whether it's beef or lamb or wheat or whatnot.”
Europeans are so technical and so detail-oriented and so emotional about the details, combined with a complex ratification process, that they can't do anything quickly.
“the Europeans are so technical and so detail-oriented and so emotional about the details. And then there's a ratification process that we'll get into here in a minute. Uh that they can't do anything quickly.”
Farmers across the European Union, including trade associations and the French, are already saying the Australia deal has no chance of getting ratified.
“we already have farmers across the European Union, including the trade associations and of course the French, saying that this deal has no chance uh of getting ratified.”
The EU-Australia trade deal was negotiated in record time of less than one year, but the ratification process is a whole different question.
“we now have a trade deal that has been negotiated with the Australians and that was done in record time, less than a year. That that's really, really good. Uh but the ratification process is a whole different question.”
Belgium was the 'real sticker' that blocked the Canada free trade agreement ratification.
“In the case of Canada, it was Belgium was the real sticker.”
The EU-Mercosur trade deal was negotiated around 2001 but only now finished, demonstrating extreme slowness in EU ratification processes.
“the deal that was recently ratified uh with the Brazilians, the Argentinians, you know, the Mercosur block, that was negotiated back around the year 2001 and they only now finished it.”
The Canada-EU free trade agreement was negotiated in the early 2010s and took 11 years to get through.
“We had a Canada free trade agreement that was negotiated in the early 2010s. That took 11 years to get through.”
Europe's inability to quickly complete trade deals, combined with its naval power limitations and agricultural protectionism, makes it impossible for Europe to build non-US alternatives to the international order.
“there is no international trade without the US Navy... the Europeans are aggressively protectionist, particularly when it comes to agriculture... the Europeans are so technical and so detail-oriented and so emotional about the details... that they can't do anything quickly.”
If the Australia trade deal goes through the entire ratification process successfully, the first large-scale transfer of Australian goods to the European market could occur in the year 2040.
“if in the ideal situation everyone ultimately lines up and tees are crossed and i's are dotted and noses are counted and it goes through, we can look forward to the first large-scale transfer of Australian goods to the European market in the year 2040.”
Zeihan states he will not be doing this work long enough to see the 2040 implementation date of the Australia trade deal.
“Um I am not going to be doing this long enough for that to matter.”