performativity
A sociological concept that economics does not merely describe the world but actively shapes and brings it into being, functioning as a set of tools for decision, prediction, and management.
As defined in Will Davies on the Economics, Economists, and the Limits of Neoliberalism
Where it comes up · 3
- Jean-Francois Lyotard: The Post-modern Condition4 claims
- Conclusion: Political, Social and Cultural Criticism and Theory3 claims
- Will Davies on the Economics, Economists, and the Limits of Neoliberalism1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “performativity” →
- Speaker rejects Lyotard's critique as taken 'too far' and 'dangerously far': funding AIDS research via clinical trials rather than Ouija boards is not ideological bias but necessary selection based on actual efficacy; abandoning performativity would mean people die from preventable disease.Conclusion: Political, Social and Cultural Criticism and Theory
- Specific examples of grand narratives that Lyotard rejects as outmoded include Hegelianism (the idea of the geist organizing all human history), Marxist class conflict narratives, populist and national socialist folk narratives, the ideology of performativity in natural science, and Habermas's communicative linguistic ethics based on rational consensus.Jean-Francois Lyotard: The Post-modern Condition
- Lyotard argues that modern capitalism's demand for performativity in science skews truth and justice toward wealth; funding requirements force scientists to justify research via efficiency, meaning rich actors can 'buy truth' by funding desired research programs, making science ideologically tainted.Conclusion: Political, Social and Cultural Criticism and Theory
- Sociologists describe the 'performativity of economics': economics is not merely describing the world but is something you can do things with—a set of tools for taking decisions, making predictions, and managing situations—consistent with Milton Friedman's 1953 claim that the truth value of economics lies not in describing how things are but in its predictions, which means economists have never been innocent observers and were entangled in the financial crisis.Will Davies on the Economics, Economists, and the Limits of Neoliberalism
- Utilitarianism and efficiency arguments represent Anglo-American philosophical tradition friendly to capitalism and rational calculation of input-output; pragmatism represents muddle-through approach to the failure of positivism's reductive program.Conclusion: Political, Social and Cultural Criticism and Theory
- Performativity is the fundamental ideology of advanced capitalist society, defined as maximum output for minimum input, and is understood as intrinsically rational and self-justifying, but it is merely an ideological construct without legitimate grounds.Jean-Francois Lyotard: The Post-modern Condition
- Nicholas Luhmann's systems theory is a modernist totalizing metanarrative that presents a deterministic closed system and has a hidden agenda of legitimizing performativity as fundamental value.Jean-Francois Lyotard: The Post-modern Condition
- Lyotard proposes paralogy (counter-thought, counter-speech, alternative systems of thinking) as a solution to performativity, advocating for infinite plurality of perspectival stances none of which can claim superiority, thereby maximizing discursive diversity.Jean-Francois Lyotard: The Post-modern Condition