pay-as-you-go
A funding system in which current contributions are immediately used to pay current beneficiaries rather than being invested for the contributor
As defined in Michael Munger on Slavery and Racism
Where it comes up · 5
- John Cogan on Entitlements and the High Cost of Good Intentions4 claims
- Madhavan Ramanujam - How to Price Products - [Invest Like the Best, REPLAY]2 claims
- A Historic Market Bubble1 claim
- More on Repealing the Laws of Economics1 claim
- Michael Munger on Slavery and Racism1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “pay-as-you-go” →
- An earned-right or normal pension program collects money, sets it aside, and invests it to finance future benefits for current taxpayers; a tax-and-transfer program sets nothing aside and uses today's collected taxes to finance today's retirees' benefits—Social Security shifted from the former toward the latter by the 1950s-60s.John Cogan on Entitlements and the High Cost of Good Intentions
- Roosevelt's original design built a large reserve fund by setting taxes above benefit outlays, but concerns about misuse and regressivity led Congress to eliminate the surplus by expanding to survivor benefits, accelerating first-payment dates, and raising benefits—responding to surplus exactly as every prior Congress had since the Revolutionary War: by spending it.John Cogan on Entitlements and the High Cost of Good Intentions
- The common objection 'but I paid into Social Security' is mistaken: a retiree's payroll taxes paid their parents' benefits, not their own, just as taxes paid for defense, food stamps, and other programs they did not personally consume; the notion that one paid into a personal account was theater, since the money was spent on Vietnam, farm subsidies, and other unrelated programs.John Cogan on Entitlements and the High Cost of Good Intentions
- Pensions are paid from current-year GDP on a pay-as-you-go basis, so real wealth cannot be transferred across time, and the only real resources available each year are goods and services, so the workforce's quality and quantity plus assets per worker constitute real wealth.A Historic Market Bubble
- Today's retirees have paid for only about two-thirds of their Social Security retirement benefits; even granting that their payroll taxes were set aside and earned a 2-3% return, they would receive only two-thirds of the benefits they now get—the remainder being financed by their children and grandchildren in their 30s and 40s.John Cogan on Entitlements and the High Cost of Good Intentions
- Justifying Social Security privatization on the grounds that you would make more money is unacceptable because the current pay-as-you-go system is not actually invested—your contributions go out the door to pay current recipients—and it embeds a redistributive aspect that helps poor people, so reform advocates must use the veil of ignorance and argue for those who would lose, not pretend everyone would be better off; ideally the redistribution would be transparent rather than disguised as 'getting your money back.'Michael Munger on Slavery and Racism
- Pay-as-you-go pricing makes sense when usage and value delivery are episodic rather than ongoing, and when underlying costs scale with usage, because a subscription could leave heavy users as negative-margin customers.Madhavan Ramanujam - How to Price Products - [Invest Like the Best, REPLAY]
- The main pricing models are subscription (predictable recurring pricing), pay-as-you-go or usage-based, dynamic pricing (equilibrium between supply and demand), freemium, and hybrids combining subscription and usage; companies should pick the model that fits their situation rather than copy competitors.Madhavan Ramanujam - How to Price Products - [Invest Like the Best, REPLAY]
- Social Security was designed as a pay-as-you-go program where current tax payments are used to pay benefits to current retirees, and future retirees' benefits will come from taxes paid by future workers, not as a funded endowment like a pension fund.More on Repealing the Laws of Economics