A Historic Market Bubble
What this covers
Patrick interviews Jeremy Grantham on the state of the market in early 2021, and the conversation ranges well beyond it. Grantham ranks his bubble evidence. Valuation is the weakest timing tool, since Japan's P/E went from never above 25 to 65 in the late 1980s. The best signal, and the hardest to quantify, is crazy behavior, visible when GameStop and Tesla reach the evening news. He notes that Tesla's price rose about eightfold while sales rose 25%. He sets this against the Nifty Fifty, 1929, and his own 1968-69 experience with speculative small stocks like American Raceways. He also explains why large institutions stay conventional, through Career Risk vs Individual Risk, and why he thinks the Fed's support after 2000 kept the S&P from overshooting downward.
The second half turns to demographics and the economy. Grantham cites US labor force growth falling from about 1.5% a year to roughly zero, and fertility rates such as South Korea's 0.85 and China's near 1.6. He argues that pensions are paid from each year's output, so what counts is Real Wealth vs Paper Claims. The contested claims come here. He says rising debt and falling rates, from 16% on the long bond in 1982 to about 1.5%, show no link to growth. He argues banks are less central than believed under a Double-Entry Debt View, and that the money standard barely matters.
There are also detours. One is the Haber-Bosch process, on which half of humanity's existence depends. Another is Japan's heavy use of robots as a response to a shrinking workforce.
Grantham argues the current US equity market is a historic bubble, driven mainly by retail speculation and extrapolated profits and cheap Fed money, and that slowing demographics and productivity will drag on long-run returns and make overpriced assets a burden on society.
- Value, acceleration, and crazy-behavior indicators now exceed 2000 levels, with value the weakest timing tool
- Bubble is mainly individual rather than institutional, and the economy is damaged, so the market depends entirely on continued Fed and government support
- Falling workforce growth and productivity, plus overpriced assets, lower the compounding of societal wealth
Human irrationality drives market volatility far beyond fundamentals, and speculative bubbles usually collapse to zero.
- Grantham's own 1968-69 experience with speculative small stocks such as American Raceways showed that tiny-stock bubbles go to zero for most issues, so the retail gains were fleeting and the losses severe.
“Almost all of them did what American Raceways did and that is went to zero.”
- The market is about 17 times more volatile than the flow of dividends and earnings can justify, because irrational humans behave rationally about 80% of the time and then swing to extremes for the other 20%.
“The market is 17 times more volatile than is justified by the flow of dividends and earnings.”
Fed support and large stimulus inflate markets short term while undercutting later infrastructure and resources.
- After 2000 the S&P did not overshoot to the downside, which was historically unusual; Fed easing and buying support halted the decline at the 50% drop, and the trend break only came later with the housing bust.
“because of the Fed throwing the kitchen sink at everything, the S&P minus 50% had enough buying support to stop a trend and bounce back”
- Writing large checks risks using up resources, undercutting later infrastructure spending, and overstimulating consumers and the stock market in the short term, which Grantham believes the first stimulus already did to a considerable degree.
“writing big checks will use up too much of the resource going to individuals, and will then undercut the ability to spend much money on infrastructure.”
Real wealth lies in workforce quality and productive assets, not paper financial claims.
- Half the people alive exist because of Haber-Bosch nitrogen fertilizer, which is energy intensive and originated in World War I explosives production, and a microbe that fixes nitrogen could reduce that dependence.
“Half of the people on the planet exist because of Haber-Bosch nitrogen.”
- Real economic wealth is the quality and quantity of the workforce, including how motivated, skilled, and retrainable it is, plus the quantity and quality of assets per worker, while paper financial claims only facilitate transactions.
“Reality is the quality and quantity of your workforce. How motivated, how happy, how well organized they are, how well-trained they are”