ontological argument
Anselm's argument that since we can conceive of a most perfect being, and existence is more perfect than non-existence, such a being must necessarily exist.
As defined in 9 | Solo -- Why Is There Something Rather than Nothing?
Where it comes up · 9
- A History of Philosophy | 54 Kant on Metaphysics7 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 22 Early Medieval Philosophy4 claims
- 105 - Richard Dawkins Sam Harris And Matt Dillahunty2 claims
- Great Minds - Aquinas' Summa Theologica: The Thomist Synthesis and its Political and Social Content2 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 38 Spinoza (continued), Leibniz1 claim
- 9 | Solo -- Why Is There Something Rather than Nothing?1 claim
- A History of Philosophy | 25 Aquinas on God1 claim
- A History of Philosophy | 34 Descartes on God and Nature1 claim
and 1 more
Most important claims · 10 of 20Search all claims for “ontological argument” →
- Aquinas rejects a priori arguments for God's existence (like Anselm's ontological argument) in favor of a posteriori arguments from effects to cause, because he is too much the empiricist in the Aristotelian tradition to accept rationalist a priori arguments as the Platonists did.A History of Philosophy | 25 Aquinas on God
- In medieval scholasticism, the doctrine that general terms really refer to real entities (Platonic forms) that exist outside space and time is called 'realism,' which is different from modern realism and is associated with the early Augustinian tradition in Christianity, with Saint Anselm being its most profound exponent through his ontological argument.Great Minds - Aquinas' Summa Theologica: The Thomist Synthesis and its Political and Social Content
- The ontological argument claims God necessarily exists, but Kant argues that 'exists' is not a logical predicate—it does not ascribe a property like other predicates, so 'God necessarily exists' involves an a priori concept of necessity/modality, making the argument depend on the very thing it claims to proveA History of Philosophy | 54 Kant on Metaphysics
- Anselm's ontological argument works as follows: I have the idea of a perfect being than which nothing more perfect could be conceived; such a being must exist because the idea of a perfect being that lacks existence would be the idea of a perfect being lacking one perfection (existence), which is self-contradictory; therefore, a perfect being must necessarily exist both in understanding and in reality.A History of Philosophy | 22 Early Medieval Philosophy
- The supreme monad (God) possesses full consciousness (omniscience/all-knowing), complete clarity and distinctness of thought, absolute power (boundless appetite/drive/impetus), and necessary being (existence is essential to God's nature, not contingent), which is open to ontological arguments for God's existence.A History of Philosophy | 38 Spinoza (continued), Leibniz
- All three traditional arguments for God's existence form a hierarchy of dependency: the teleological argument depends on the cosmological argument, which depends on the ontological argument; since the ontological argument fails, all three arguments failA History of Philosophy | 54 Kant on Metaphysics
- The cosmological argument depends on the ontological argument because it assumes the contingency of the cosmos and infers a necessary being, but the very concept of necessity/contingency is a priori and unjustified, and it presupposes the conclusion of the ontological argumentA History of Philosophy | 54 Kant on Metaphysics
- Saint Anselm developed the ontological argument asserting that God is 'that which nothing greater can be conceived,' and attempts to show that the very idea of God is unavoidable and logically necessary, representing a self-contained idealist form of thinking that bootstraps from thought itself to positive theology in a characteristically Platonic manner.Great Minds - Aquinas' Summa Theologica: The Thomist Synthesis and its Political and Social Content
- Carroll's preferred refutation of Anselm's ontological argument is that we cannot actually conceive of the most perfect being, just as we cannot conceive of the largest prime number or a squared circle; the concept is not well-defined (perfect being's gender, color, whether it talks to us are all undefined), so we only fool ourselves into thinking we can conceive of it.9 | Solo -- Why Is There Something Rather than Nothing?
- Gaunilo's objection to Anselm's ontological argument—that one could equally conceive of a perfect island and prove its existence—fails because a perfect island is a finite limited being with limits, not perfect being, and therefore the argument's premise does not apply to it.A History of Philosophy | 22 Early Medieval Philosophy