Gaunilo's objection to Anselm's ontological argument—that one could equally conceive of a perfect island and prove its existence—fails because a perfect island is a finite limited being with limits, not perfect being, and therefore the argument's premise does not apply to it.

factualpending

Speaker

Philosophy Lecturer

Evidence Quote

“of course it doesn't because a perfect island is not perfect being it's a finite limited being it does not have every Perfection”

Source

A History of Philosophy | 22 Early Medieval Philosophy— wheatoncollege
Created: 8/10/2026, 11:16:18 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...