
A History of Philosophy | 22 Early Medieval Philosophy
What this covers
This is a lecture surveying early medieval philosophy, delivered by a lecturer (the transcript attributes parts to a second, unidentified voice). It treats the period as a meeting point of Plato, Aristotle, and Neoplatonism with three theistic religions. Christian, Jewish, and Muslim thinkers all faced the same questions about time and eternity, God and creation, and faith and philosophy. The lecture presents the period's lasting contribution as defining these issues rather than settling them, work later taken up by Aquinas, Bonaventure, Duns Scotus, and William of Ockham.
The range is wide. Boethius appears as translator of Aristotle, author of the Consolation of Philosophy, and, most importantly, the one who posed the problem of universals. Pseudo-Dionysius supplies a Neoplatonic ladder of emanation with positive and negative ways of speaking about God, and a line to later mystics such as Eckhart. The lecture contrasts emanation with creation out of nothing, and argues that Aristotle's God does not create because Aristotle does not place the forms in the divine mind. A related discussion of individuation holds that an individual embodies all of its possible qualities, not just a species form, so that God can know and create it. Augustine and Anselm stand for faith seeking understanding, with philosophizing treated as an act of praise. Averroes and Maimonides work on the Islamic and Jewish sides, and Averroes' twofold truth and denial of individual immortality are set against Bonaventure's return to Augustinian illumination.
The longest and most contested stretch is Anselm's ontological argument. It covers the painter analogy, Gaunilo's island objection and the reply that a perfect island is finite, and Immanuel Kant's claim that existence is not a predicate. The lecturer argues that Kant and Anselm differ over metaphysical frameworks, not logical validity, and that the argument shows how indispensable the God concept is within its own system. The lecturer also defends a priori reasoning about non-empirical objects, and treats the laws of logic as grounded in God's being. Both claims are contestable.
Early medieval philosophy primarily served a preparatory function for later medieval developments, establishing how Platonic, Aristotelian, and Neoplatonic traditions could be reconciled with Christian, Jewish, and Islamic theology, particularly through debates over faith and reason, the nature of creation versus emanation, and the problem of universals.
- Platonic and Aristotelian influences shaped all three major theistic religions, raising identical philosophical problems about the relationship between time and eternity, God and creation, and faith and philosophy
- The central achievement of early medieval philosophy was defining rather than solving these problems, creating frameworks that later figures like Aquinas, Bonaventure, Duns Scotus, and William of Ockham would refine
- The tension between faith-seeking-understanding (Augustine, Anselm) and twofold truth (Averroes, Siger of Brabant) established competing methodologies that drove later medieval philosophy forward
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Anselm's philosophical and theological treatises are punctuated throughout with spontaneous expressions of praise and prayer, reflecting the monastic method of reflection where philosophizing is understood as an activity of praise to God, not a religiously neutral secular inquiry.
“anel in his writings uh keeps that in mind um and combines two things that are implicit within it one is the metaphysical scheme and the other is the uh the religious devotion so that as you read anel his philosophical treaties treaties is uh you find that there runs through his philosophizing uh moments of outburst of Prayer or praise or whatever as the case may be um at first it struck me that um this was in the tradition of some of the Greek classic writers and Poets who would start what they were doing with an ode or praise to the gods but it becomes very evident as you read further in anel that this is the method of reflection that went on in the medieval Monastery you'll see so that the work was an activity of praise to God and if the work was philosophizing that was an activity of praise to God and so uh punctuated throughout with um spontaneous uh expressions of that praise uh the point being that Every Creature seeks to imitate and praise the good which is God”
Platonic and Aristotelian influences appear not only in Christian philosophy in the Middle Ages but also in Jewish and Muslim philosophy because all three are theistic religions with personal, transcendent Creator Gods facing identical philosophical problems about the relationship between time and eternity, God and creation, and the relationship between faith and philosophy.
“you will find platonic and Aristotelian influences not only in Christian philosophy in the Middle Ages but also in Jewish and Muslim philosophy now um understandably because uh those three faiths are the three major theistic religions that is to say religion with a personal Transcendent Creator God and um by virtue of that commonality across the three major theistic religions they faced many of the same philosophical problems how to explain the relationship between between Time and Eternity God and creation how does the theory of universals of forms fit within that uh what about the relationship between the faith and philosophy when the two appear to conflict or do they so many of the same philosophical issues arose in all three traditions”
Medieval philosophers, by contrast with Kant's position, understand existence and being as transcendental qualities characterizable in terms of unity (which gives something identity), truth (which embodies an intelligible nature), and goodness (which places something in the hierarchy of being)—such that there is no such thing as bare existence without these transcendental qualities, making existence a genuine perfection.
“and perhaps I can come at it best by saying how can't thinks of existence in the aftermath of the Scientific Revolution a world of bare physical facts you know the line can I take a thing so dead a world of be inert physical particles now in that sense um existence is a value free sort of thing value neutral um it's not a a quality thing it's not a quality one has but for the medievals being existence can be described in terms of unity that gives something identity nothing exists that doesn't have identity must have Unity therefore Unity uh truth that is to say it must embody some intelligible nature goodness yes because if it embodies a an intelligible nature it's somewhere in the hierarchy of being in other words the medi Evils are talking of transcendental qualities of all being there is no such thing as bare existence”
Pseudo-Dionysius the Areopagite (circa 500 AD) presents a hierarchy of beings emanating from the One (Neoplatonic framework) where positive and negative language about God both apply: positive ways speak of God's greater degrees of goodness, while negative ways say what God is not, establishing a Neoplatonic mystical path toward union with God that influenced later medieval mystical writers like Meister Eckhart.
“what he has is almost predictable in the light of what I've said a hierarchy of beings emanating from the one yeah that's the neoplatonic party line a hierarchy of beings emanating from the one with varying degrees of unity and Order and uh because then of the relationships of resemblance increasing as one goes up the hierarchy it's possible to talk of the one God in positive ways that is to say God to a much to Greater degree than us is good and also in negative ways saying that God is not because he is in degree vastly different from things below so you get the positive and the negative ways of speaking about God”
Bonaventure (13th century) rejects Aristotelian philosophy entirely, repudiating the Averroist synthesis in favor of returning to Augustine, Anselm, and the Platonic tradition, arguing that without the light of the logos (divine illumination) enlightening the human mind, it would be impossible for Aristotle to know the truth, a concept absent from Aristotelianism and Averroism.
“now the fact is that it was in response to this Latin of verism of seizure of rent and the storm around Aristotle interpreted by AO which led Bonaventure to reject all um thought of a christianized aristotelianism that Bon Aventure to go back to Augustine and Ansel and to the platonic tradition of earlier years you see one of the emphases that you get in Augustin and in Anselm as we saw last time is that the logos enlightens the mind and said Bon Avenger without the light of the logos it would be impossible for ARIS stle to know the truth you see without the light of the logos it would be impossible and aristotelianism and a Vera ways and seizure of reant didn't have any such concept of divine Illumination in the human mind that was left out and so Bon Avenger turned away from Aristotle”
Averroes reconciled the tensions between Aristotelian philosophy and Islamic faith by developing the doctrine of twofold truth: that religious discourse speaks allegorically and metaphorically for the benefit of the uneducated believer, while philosophy speaks with precision; thus philosophical truth (his interpretation of Aristotle as the pinnacle of philosophical achievement) should be preferred when tensions arise.
“now in order to handle that tension what a verway does and this introduces us to the problem of faith and reason what a verway does is to develop uh the notion of twofold Truth truths of Faith as distinct from truths of Reason theological truth is distinct from philosophical truth now the way in which he reconciled these if you can call it that was that the the faith religion speaks allegorically metaphorically using imagery that the um uneducated believer can appreciate and respond to it is philosophy that speaks with precision and so in the tension between the two he seems to prefer the philosophical way of saying it the philosophical way of saying it is his interpretation of Aristotle and Aristotle he was convinced represented the very Pinnacle of philosophical achievement forever”
Boethius (died 524) is known as a translator and commentator on Aristotle, and his most famous surviving work is the Consolation of Philosophy, written in prison, but his most historically significant contribution is his formulation of the problem of universals, posing key questions about the theory of forms.
“bethus Christian my monardes Jewish farway Muslim uh boethus died in 524 back uh around the time uh a little bit younger then but around the time of dionisius um is known to have been a translator uh of and common Tator on Aristotle and um the work of his which is best known and has best survived the consolation of philosophy incidentally written in prison the consolation of philosophy is one which um um is still available in um translation of course um but the most significant um contribution of buthus historically is his formulation of the problem of universals posing the key questions to do with the theory of forms”
In Anselm's theological framework, evil is a privation of the good, and the good for all creatures is that they should seek to fulfill their natural end by imitating God in His unchanging Perfection—with degrees of such imitation appropriate to each particular creature's place in the hierarchy of being and goodness.
“evil is a privation of the good and the good for things in creation is that they should seek to fulfill their natural end everything has its own god-given nature because of the theory of forms everything has its own God given nature which being in the same hierarchy of being and goodness you see its nature is not simply to achieve its goodness but to that degree to be like God so the imitation of God in that degree appropriate to every particular creature is the good for all creation to be like God in his unchanging Perfection”
Aristotle's God does not actively create because Aristotle does not hold that the forms (universals/ideas) are archetypal ideas existing in God's mind; if Aristotle had recognized the Platonic and Neoplatonic teaching that the forms are exemplars in God's mind, he would have understood that God is thinking about the exemplars and through that thinking can give rise to particular beings that embody those exemplars.
“why not because Aristotle's God is simply thinking on his own thinking Aristotle did not see that the forms are archetypal ideas in the mind of God if Aristotle had seen the platonic middle platonic neop platonic Christian platonic okay if Aristotle had seen the crystal platonic teaching that the forms are exemplars in the mind of God he would know that God wasn't just thinking on his own thinking it was thinking about the exemplars and in thinking about the exemplars could give his mind to particular beings who embody those exemplars”
Averroes (Muslim, 12th century, lived in Cordova Spain) developed an Aristotelian view with Platonic influence, positing a hierarchy of intermediary intelligences between God (pure actuality) and prime matter (pure potentiality), conceiving of the human soul as part of this hierarchy but arguing that at death individual souls unite with a cosmic rational soul, denying individual personal immortality.
“a verway uh developed his Aristotelian view if you like with a little bit of platonic influence uh because uh he had a hierarchy of intermediaries a hierarchy of intermediaries between the pure actuality which is God and the pure potentiality which is uh Prime matter Prime matter is Elemental matter without um form of any particular element or kind of thing so that in between God who is pure actuality and matter at the bottom of the hierarchy you have 100 intermediary intelligences that hierarchy of beings uh still at work um this is a an emanation kind of process and his view was that the um the human soul um is yes part of this uh but at death the individual human soul is united with a cosmic rational Soul so that there is no individual immortality there is no individual immortality”
The rationality of abstract a priori reasoning (as opposed to empirical methods) is warranted when applied to non-empirical objects not accessible to sense data, such as God, because different kinds of subject matter require different appropriate methods; reducing all valid reasoning to empiricism is a form of reductionism that illegitimately restricts the scope of valid inquiry.
“I think all I'll say is not that it indicates the superiority of it indicates that some kinds of thinking are appropriate to some subject matter and other kinds to other subject matter uh that is to say if you're trying to find out what's wrong with you physically I suggest you um submit yourself to the empirical findings of medical science uh where I think um empirical methods are very very valuable um if you're trying to get at some non-empirical object not accessible to sense data such as God you have to use some other method so it's uh in a way um I'm responding simply in terms of The Divided line that if you're wanting to deal with physical particulars all right use one approach but if you want to deal with the Eternal the invisible then obviously you need a different kind of approach um why should we universalize empirical methods for every kind of subject matter you see that's a kind of reductionism it's presupposing that everything that exists is of a particular nature and presumptively for some physical nature you see why presuppose that methodologically so that you shut out other Alternatives”
What makes an individual an individual (individuation) is not merely privation of form (Neoplatonic view) but rather the embodiment within the individual of not only the form of the species but of all possible qualities which the individual will develop; thus God by knowing the forms of species and all possible qualities that compose each individual can think of the particular combination of qualities that identify an individual and thereby act as efficient cause creating individuals.
“add to that this further consideration what is it that makes an individual an individual well uh privation of form that was the neoplatonic tradition saying that but not so says Bon Avenger and he goes beyond the platonic tradition what makes the IND individual the individual is that uh there is embodied in the individual the form not only of the species but of all possible qualities which the individual will develop and so God by knowing the forms of species and all possible qualities can think of on the particular combination of qualities which identify the individual God can know individuals and knowing individuals God could act as efficient cause and create an individual and so Bonaventure introduces a doctrine of individuality which makes it possible to talk of God creating individuals and individual immortality”
Anselm's ontological argument works as follows: I have the idea of a perfect being than which nothing more perfect could be conceived; such a being must exist because the idea of a perfect being that lacks existence would be the idea of a perfect being lacking one perfection (existence), which is self-contradictory; therefore, a perfect being must necessarily exist both in understanding and in reality.
“by virtue of the fact that we have degrees of being degrees of God goodness you see it follows that that which is the highest of all beings on the hierarchy is identical with that which is perfect goodness on the hierarchy so granted that framework his ontological argument goes like this I have the idea of a perfect being than which no more perfect could be conceived and that being necessarily exists now you see that Rider that conclusion on the end wouldn't make any sense apart from this framework because granted the conception of goodness you've got the conception of perfect being the necessary being of goodness is involved in the whole nature of existence everything involved with its nature and its ends you see so his ontological argument is simply an application of the metaphysical scheme”
The main lasting contribution of the early medieval period (up to approximately 1000 AD) is in defining and exploring philosophical issues having to do with the relationship between religious faith and classical philosophical traditions, with the value of these early explorations being primarily preparatory for the more concentrated and constructive treatments of such issues by later medieval thinkers like Aquinas, Bonaventure, Duns Scotus, and William of Ockham.
“the main contribution the main lasting contribution of this early medieval period say up to about about a th000 ad is in defining and exploring philosophical issues having to do with the relationship between religious faith and those philosophical traditions exploring and defining issues that therefore had to be more uh concentratedly constructively treated in the late Middle Ages”
Augustine represents a tradition in which faith seeks understanding (Credo ut intelligam: I believe in order that I may understand), meaning that faith is the starting position and understanding is the goal, with faith being understanding's initial step and understanding being faith's reward.
“go back to St Augustine and uh you have there a tradition which says that Faith seeks understanding or as anel puts it K UT intelligam I believe in order that I may understand and this seems to be the starting position for the medieval discussions what Augustine meant I think is pretty clear in the light of what we did with Augustine uh namely that um uh while faith is um understanding step because one must at least understand what one is believing in measure in order to believe it okay and certain kind of rational case can be made faith is understanding step yet understanding is Faith reward”
The basic distinction between Platonic and Christian metaphysics hinges on whether creation emanates from the very being of the Divine (Neoplatonic theory of emanation) as opposed to creation brought into being out of nothing (creatio ex nihilo), a distinction that took a long time to permeate the entire philosophical movement of the period.
“the basic distinction of course um turns out to be the distinction between a creation that emanates from the very being of the Divine the neoplatonic theory of emanation as distinct from a creation that is brought into being out of nothing creation X NE hello that basic distinction but it took a long time for The crucial nature of that distinction uh to pervade the whole philosophical movement of the period”
Gaunilo's objection to Anselm's ontological argument—that one could equally conceive of a perfect island and prove its existence—fails because a perfect island is a finite limited being with limits, not perfect being, and therefore the argument's premise does not apply to it.
“to that argument there was a monk who replied Man by the name of Galo who uh picked up um an anel's figure of speech and called himself Neo the fool and uh said I have an idea of a perfect Island that doesn't prove it exists to which enel replied very straightforwardly of course it doesn't because a perfect island is not perfect being it's a finite limited being it does not have every Perfection let see it has limits so your response G is irrelevant you miss the whole point of the argument”
Maimonides (Jewish, 12th century) wrote the Guide for the Perplexed attempting to reconcile Aristotelian philosophy with Jewish faith, just as Philo of Alexandria had attempted to reconcile middle Platonism with Judaism in the ancient world.
“um my monod Jewish writer best known for his work a guide for the perplexed in which um it said that he tries to do with Aristotle what pho of Alexandria had tried to do with Plato in relationship to the Jewish faith remember that Pho developed a kind of Jewish interpretation of middle platonism and Alexandria tries to develop a Jewish interpretation of Aristotelian philosophy my mod”
The laws of logic are not humanly devised but have to do with the structure of human thought because they have to do with the structure of thought on God's part and the structure of being as God has made it—the basic law of logic that 'A equals A and not non-A' is a law of God's being, for God is God and not non-good, and even God cannot be non-good.
“so in that sense um the laws of logic are not humanly devised they have to do with the structure of human thought because they have to do with the structure of thought on God's part and the structure of being as God has made it now you say if you say that is a very presumptuous assertion I respond no know the basic law of logic is that a equals a and not Nona and that is a law of God's being God is God and not non- good yes see and even God cannot be non good so the laws of logic apply to God”
Kant's main critique of the ontological argument is that existence is not a proper predicate—that is, existence is not another quality which one can predicate of God or any other thing, such that adding existence is not adding another perfection and saying God does not exist is not subtracting a perfection from the idea of perfection.
“K takes a different line at least the uh the main line that he takes um is his claim that existence is not a proper predicate um in his and we'll run into this when we get to K's critique of pure reason next semester um existence is not a proper predicate uh that is to say existence is not another quality which you can predicate of God now if that's the case then adding existence is not adding another Perfection saying God does not exist is not subtracting a Perfection from the idea of perfection”
The value of arguments like Anselm's ontological argument is not so much in proving from a neutral starting point the existence of God but rather in showing how necessary the God concept is within the systematic framework of thought that is dominant at that time—demonstrating that one cannot think metaphysically without the God concept.
“I think Arguments for anything else always have presuppositions of some sort you see but in Anselm it becomes particularly noticeable and um it uh it's this sort of thing which leads me to think that the value of the arguments is not so much in proving from a neutral starting point the existence of God as simply showing how necessary the god concept is in terms of the systematic framework of thought that is dominant at that time you see you cannot think metaphysically without the god concept seems to be what anel is saying”
Anselm distinguishes between an object being in the understanding and an object existing in reality, using the example of a painter who conceives of what he will make (having it in understanding) but has not yet understood it to exist until he actually makes it, after which the painter has it both in understanding and in existence.
“it is one thing for an object to be in the understanding and another uh to understand that the object exists and he illustrates a painter first conceives of what he will make having it in this understanding but doesn't yet understand it to exist because he hasn't yet made it but after he has made it he has it both in the understanding and in existence”
Kant contradicts Anselm not because Anselm commits a logical fallacy but because Kant operates from a different metaphysical framework with different presuppositions about the nature of being—the disagreement is fundamentally about metaphysical systems, not about formal logical validity.
“yeah so why can can't then contradict anel because he has a different metaphysical framework is he different presuppositions about the nature of being yeah so again it comes back to the metaphysical system do you follow okay”