nimbyism
'Not In My Backyard'-ism—local opposition to nearby development, here associated with experimenting with minimum sizes in a bougie ward.
As defined in The Magic of Tokyo (with Joe McReynolds)
Other definitions
The phenomenon of residents opposing new development in their neighborhoods (Not In My Back Yard) despite supporting development in principle elsewhere, typically driven by aesthetic or property value concerns
The Perfect Country
Where it comes up · 12
- Kyla Scanlon3 claims
- Kenneth T. Jackson - Robert Moses, Hero of New York?2 claims
- Ezra Klein & Derek Thompson - Abundance Is the Key to Fixing America | Prof G Conversations1 claim
- Daniel Carpenter1 claim
- Conversations with Tyler - Roman Mars1 claim
- The real impact of growing budget deficits - Ruchir Sharma1 claim
- Tyler Cowen — Hayek, Keynes, & Smith on AI, animal spirits, anarchy, & growth1 claim
- The Magic of Tokyo (with Joe McReynolds)1 claim
and 4 more
Most important claims · 10 of 15Search all claims for “nimbyism” →
- The absence of minimum unit and lot sizes, combined with zoning that lets people use the ground floor of a multi-story row house for any public-facing micro-space, produces a near-endless supply of flexible micro-spaces; this is the single most important lesson and 'secret sauce' that other cities could adopt to recreate Tokyo's intimacy and dynamism.The Magic of Tokyo (with Joe McReynolds)
- Housing functions simultaneously as a place to live and a speculative asset, and because the bottom 50 percent of Americans hold nearly all their wealth in their homes, they resist building nearby that might reduce home values; this conflict, plus post-Great-Recession builder caution, high rates, and zoning restrictions, creates a perfect storm preventing adequate housing supply.Kyla Scanlon
- Land-use regulation that began sensibly (19th-century fire risk limits) has metastasized into unnecessary, counterproductive regulation captured by interest groups—suburban NIMBYism and ever-expanding historic preservation districts (15% of lower Manhattan excluding Central Park) that act as no-building zones—which makes cities far more expensive than necessary and creates income uniformity among those who can afford the housing.Edward Glaeser on Cities
- The scarce, valuable part of the energy system is the hard infrastructure that cannot be built en masse ad infinitum; surging demand from data centers and AI means countries that are non-NIMBY on energy (like the UAE, which also has abundant sun) gain a major and currently underrated geopolitical comparative advantage, while the US will be slow with nuclear.Kyla Scanlon
- High housing costs in some places are driven by co-location value rather than NIMBYism: cities like Seoul have built enormously and remain very expensive because being in the dominant economic, financial, and cultural center is worth a lot, whereas in places like Oakland the high cost is mostly attributable to NIMBY restrictions.Kyla Scanlon
- Opposition to development rests on a misunderstanding of supply and demand—building any housing, even super-luxury housing, puts downward pressure on prices, just as more vendors selling popsicles lowers the price of popsicles, but most Americans oppose change believing it only means gentrification.Kenneth T. Jackson - Robert Moses, Hero of New York?
- NIMBYism, which Hayek effectively predicted, exists across both democratic and most autocratic systems because interest groups always matter, public opinion always matters, and it's easy to do nothing on any given day; China is currently an exception but will likely slide into NIMBYism even while autocratic, especially given its shrinking, overbuilt population.Tyler Cowen — Hayek, Keynes, & Smith on AI, animal spirits, anarchy, & growth
- City council meetings are dominated by older, richer homeowners who feel they have something to lose due to loss aversion, so political courage requires officials to default to saying yes to housing by representing not just the visible circle of care at the meeting but the invisible 10,000 future residents who would benefit from lower housing costs.Derek Thompson
- NIMBY opposition to shelters and treatment centers can be overcome by keeping sites small (using a Dunbar-number-scale social community), prioritizing housing the neighborhood's own homeless, enforcing no-camping zones around sites, and guaranteeing neighborhoods enhanced services and enforcement so they are made better, not worse, off; San Jose's 23 sites have moved thousands indoors with over two-thirds remaining housed years later and reduced 911/311 calls.464 - The Politics Of Pragmatism And The Future Of California
- Even with all his talents, Moses could not do in the 21st century what he did in the mid-20th century because people are more litigious and his bullying methods would not work as easily today, yet a Moses-like figure to overcome NIMBYism is still needed.Kenneth T. Jackson - Robert Moses, Hero of New York?