Kenneth T. Jackson - Robert Moses, Hero of New York?
What this covers
Kenneth Jackson argues against the now-canonical critique of Robert Moses mounted by Robert Caro's The Power Broker. Rather than a bulldozer who destroyed neighborhoods for ego, Jackson presents Moses as the builder whose infrastructure—highways, bridges, parks, the UN, Lincoln Center, and two World's Fairs—kept New York prosperous while Detroit, St. Louis, and Pittsburgh hollowed out. The conversation centers on whether Moses's methods, though antidemocratic and sometimes brutal, were necessary to accomplish public works at scale, and whether the portrait in The Power Broker rests on factual errors and misreadings of urban history.
Jackson challenges Caro's specific claims with demographic evidence and comparative analysis. He argues that the Cross Bronx Expressway did not destroy a thriving neighborhood—Jews were already leaving East Tremont before construction, a pattern replicated in Bronx areas untouched by highways. He notes that Caro misunderstood New York's transit resilience; the real puzzle is not why Moses damaged it but why transit survived here when it collapsed in most American cities. On infrastructure placement, economic research cited by Dwarkesh Patel shows high rates of return on Moses's highway segments, suggesting deliberate strategy rather than impulse. Jackson also identifies what he sees as Caro's methodological flaw: relying on Moses's own records without investigating whether other cities—Chicago, Los Angeles, Kansas City—pursued similar road-building. He argues that NIMBYism and historic preservation now make such large-scale development impossible, and that this may itself be a problem for cities needing renewal. The exchange centers on whether breaking eggs to make an omelet—hurting some people through displacement to build public goods—remains justified or whether modern vetocracy reflects genuine moral progress.
Jackson argues that Robert Moses, far from being the destroyer of New York that Caro's Power Broker portrays, was the indispensable builder who saved the city from the decline that hollowed out other Northeastern and Midwestern cities, and that his bullying, antidemocratic methods—while flawed—accomplished public works that are impossible to build under today's NIMBYism.
- Without Moses's highways, bridges and public works, New York would have declined like Detroit, St. Louis and Cleveland
- Caro's Power Broker is a great book riddled with errors and an outsider's misreading of the neighborhoods and counterfactuals
- Today's litigious, preservation-minded culture makes the scale of building Moses achieved impossible
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The greatest irony is that Moses, the biggest builder of the greatest city in the world, did not like cities—he thought everyone should live in suburbs with houses, garages and cars, never himself drove a car, and could not foresee that people with options would choose high-rise urban living over single-family houses.
“the biggest builder of cities in the 20th century, the builder of the greatest city in the world, didn't like it. That's incredible. He didn't actually like the place he was designing.”
Moses engineered his power through the Triborough Bridge and Tunnel Authority by drafting bond contracts that made the chairman removable only for cause and that recycled toll revenue into new projects rather than retiring the debt, creating a legally protected, self-perpetuating pot of money that governors and mayors could not touch.
“he said he was somewhere down in paragraph 13, Section G, say, “And the chairman can only be removed for cause.””
Cincinnati built a complete subway tunnel system through the city about 80 years ago that never opened because by the time it was finished people had stopped riding trains, illustrating how betting on transit at the wrong historical moment could fail just as Moses's road-building reflected the actual demand of his era.
“Cincinnati built a subway system, a tunnel all through the city. It never has opened. They built it.”
Had Robert Moses not built what he did, New York would have followed the decline trajectory of Detroit, St. Louis, Cincinnati and Pittsburgh; instead New York alone among Northeastern and Midwestern cities did not decline and now has more people than ever, making the subtitle 'the rise of New York' more accurate than Caro's 'fall of New York.'
“Argument that had Robert Moses not lived, not done what he did, New York would have followed the trail of maybe Detroit and St. Louis and Cincinnati and Pittsburgh and most cities in the Northeast and Midwest, which declined.”
The interstate highway system begun in 1954-56, totaling 40,000 miles, was built by Moses's men—engineers who had worked on the parkways and expressways around New York City and were therefore ready to execute it nationally.
“those were built by Moses' men, people who had in their young life had worked with the parkways and expressways in and around New York City. So they were ready to go.”
By any standard Robert Moses was the greatest builder in American history with no one in second place—he built essentially all the big roads, bridges, parks, the UN, Lincoln Center, and the 1939 and 1964 World's Fairs, while in power for roughly half a century and spending vast sums.
“clearly, by any standard, he's the greatest builder in American history. There's nobody really in second place.”
What Moses was after was not sex or money but power—he worked for a dollar a year, died with less than he started with, and Caro himself admits this, which makes him a categorically different figure from corrupt officials who used projects to enrich themselves.
“what Moses was after in the end was not sex and not money, it was Power. He wanted power. And boy, did he get it.”
New York cannot solve circulation by adding more roads or car tunnels because there is nowhere to put more cars—building enough parking garages for additional cars would cover the whole city—so the city only works through underground public transportation that moves people without taking up surface space.
“if you build more roads, what are you going to do with the cars? Right now, the problem is there are so many cars in the city, there's nothing to do.”
New York is by far the most energy-efficient place in the United States because people live in tall buildings where they heat the floors above and below each other, have few outside walls, and walk or take transit, making New Yorkers thinner and their lifestyle healthier and greener.
“And New York, by far, is the most energy efficient place in the United States. Mainly because you live in tall buildings, you have hot floors.”
Economic analysis (an NBER digest by Morgan Foy) found that seven of the ten highest-rate-of-return highway segments in America are in the New York City area, with two segments near NYC having welfare benefits exceeding $500 million a year and the Long Island Expressway expansion valued at $719 million, suggesting Moses's placement decisions involved real intelligent deliberation rather than impulse.
“He says, “Of the top 10 segments with the highest rate of return, 7 are in the New York City area.””
Moses saw the city as a giant traffic problem to be solved with bridges, highways and tunnels and did not see or love people or neighborhoods, in direct contrast to Jane Jacobs who saw the intricate web of stores, residents and eyes on the street; this blindness was both his strength and his weakness.
“Moses didn't see that at all. He saw the city as a traffic problem. How do we tear this down and build something big and get people the hell out of here?”
Caro wrongly blamed Moses for the decline of public transit in New York; the real puzzle is why transit survived in New York when it collapsed elsewhere—in New York even rich people ride the subway because it is the most efficient way to get around, whereas in most American cities only the poor, old and disabled use transit.
“Actually what you need to explain in New York is why public transit survived in New York, wherein most other American cities, the only people who use public transit are the losers.”
Caro's claim that the Cross Bronx Expressway destroyed a thriving Jewish East Tremont neighborhood is contradicted by census tracts and HOLC residential security maps showing the Jews were already leaving; Bronx neighborhoods not touched by the expressway also emptied out, following the same Detroit-Baltimore-Cleveland pattern, so the highway was not the cause.
“If you look at the census tracts or the residential security maps of S.H.A, you know it's not true. The Jews were leaving and had nothing to do with the thing.”
Moses argued that the advantage of not being democratically elected is the ability to build projects that may not be the favorite of people alive now but will benefit the city for generations and centuries—a longtermist justification that gains force from the fact that his bridges and highways still stand and are in wide use.
“the advantage of me not being democratically elected is that I can build projects that might not be the favorite thing for the people alive now, but will benefit the city for generations and centuries to come.”
Opposition to development rests on a misunderstanding of supply and demand—building any housing, even super-luxury housing, puts downward pressure on prices, just as more vendors selling popsicles lowers the price of popsicles, but most Americans oppose change believing it only means gentrification.
“if you build any housing, it'll put downward pressure on prices, even at super luxury. But anyway, most Americans don't understand that.”
In the long run the pandemic will not permanently reduce the appeal of cities because humans are fundamentally social animals who want to be near each other—as shown by young people crowding into a single alley in Seoul despite the danger—and roughly 25% of people will always want the urbanity and mixing that places like New York offer.
“I think in the long run, we are social animals. We want to be with each other. We need each other”
Moses's roughly 8,000-word response to the Power Broker, published in the New Yorker around 1975, was rambling, ad hominem and non-specific—documenting only minor errors rather than the major ones about his public works—and thereby vindicated Caro's portrayal of his grudge-holding personality and need for capable advisors.
“I think his response was rambling, wordy, not particular. I think he probably could have taken Caro apart, but he didn't.”
Society has swung too far toward the ability to obstruct change—we can demonstrate and stop anything—but houses, roads and sewers deteriorate and we must build into our system the ability to improve them rather than only responding to emergencies like water-main breaks while a hundred other pipes leak unnoticed.
“I think that in some ways we've gone too far in the ability to obstruct change, to stop it. And we need change.”
Moses's defense and Jackson's partial endorsement is that to build great public works you must hurt some people—to make an omelet you have to break eggs—and a city or country cannot be run on the modern principle of not wanting to hurt anybody, or nothing will ever change.
“as he would say himself, in order to make an omelet, you have to break eggs. No other way to do it.”
Moses built highways and cars rather than transit because he was swimming with the tide of history—the auto industry was booming, the public wanted roads, and rail was considered obsolete; what New York did was the same as Los Angeles, Chicago, Kansas City and Memphis, just bigger and faster, so blaming Moses uniquely is unfair.
“People thought any kind of rail transit was obsolete and on the way out anyway so let's just build roads. That's what the public wanted. He built what the public wanted.”
The Economist predicts London and New York will still be world capitals in 2100 because, unlike Shanghai or Hong Kong, they offer a system within the rule of law where dissent does not make you disappear, personal safety is sacred, and they are open to newcomers of every ethnicity who can find a community there.
“What London and New York both offer, which Shanghai doesn't or Hong Kong doesn't at the moment, is a system where if you disagree, you're not going to disappear.”
A major difference between Moses's era and today is that historic preservation was barely known then; the prevailing faith was that new buildings and roads led to a better world, whereas today we have lost faith in the future and prefer to keep things as they are, which makes building far harder.
“We don't have the same kind of faith in the future that they did. We kind of like it like it is. Let's just sit on it.”
Moses preferred building bridges over tunnels because he wanted people to see what he built; according to the Power Broker he resisted the Brooklyn Battery Tunnel in favor of a visible bridge, though Jackson believes Moses was first and foremost a builder who would have built tunnels if paid to.
“He wouldn't have loved it as much as he loved bridges because he wanted you to see what he built.”
The Power Broker fails because Caro relied on Moses's own records and did not investigate other cities; he implies New York got more federal money and that LA wasn't building freeways, both untrue, since Chicago got more money per person and LA was building freeways too.
“You would not know from the power broker that Los Angeles was building freeways too. Or he says that New York had more federal money. Well, not true.”
Even with all his talents, Moses could not do in the 21st century what he did in the mid-20th century because people are more litigious and his bullying methods would not work as easily today, yet a Moses-like figure to overcome NIMBYism is still needed.
“I don't think he could do in the 21st century what he did in the middle of the 20th century... I don’t think his bullying methods would work quite as easy today.”
Caro had an outsider's view and did not know the Bronx neighborhoods he wrote about; he portrayed them as so dangerous you'd need a wagon train, but Jackson has taken students there dozens of times and found old ladies eating on benches with nobody mugging them.
“Caro wouldn't know those neighborhoods if he landed there by parachute. They're much better than he ever said they were.”
There has been a generational shift in which a big percentage of young Americans are skipping getting a driver's license and don't care about cars, whereas teenagers once wanted a driver's license more than they wanted sex—signaling a move back toward walking and cities.
“Now a big percentage of young Americans are skipping the driver's license. They don't care as much. We're moving into a different time.”
If climate change is taken seriously, the megaproject New York needs is infrastructure to prevent rising ocean water from sinking the city—potentially a land bridge from Brooklyn to Manhattan—though such projects, like flooding parts of Mississippi to save New Orleans, usually carry a downside somewhere.
“probably to build some sort of infrastructure to prevent rising water from sinking the city. It's doable.”
Moses built major public works like the Whitestone Bridge on time and under budget without financial or sexual scandal, which is something that essentially never happens with large public works projects today.
“It was finished in the late 1930s on time and under budget, actually a little earlier. There's no such thing as that now.”
One of Moses's effective strategies was making the people building a beach or wall feel they were building a cathedral—getting them to think of the job as something great worth doing well—while also paying good union wages, which is itself a real management trick.
“He made people building a beach or a building feel like they’re building a cathedral.”
The Power Broker achieved cultural prominence because Moses represents a lost era when we built bridges and superhighways that we no longer build, because Caro is a terrific writer who built a single understandable argument running through the whole book, and because the book is so big and intimidating that other authors are afraid to tackle Moses.
“Robert Moses represented a past, you know, a time when we wanted to build bridges and super highways. We're not building superhighways now.”
New York is twice as dense as any other place in the United States and full of neighborhoods that function like little cities resistant to change, which makes building there uniquely difficult and makes Moses's achievements in the face of that opposition all the more remarkable.
“It's very, very dense. Twice as dense as any place in the United States and full of neighborhoods that feel like and are little cities that don't want change”