neutral rate
Theoretical interest rate level at which monetary policy is neither stimulating nor restrictive the economy; different from the 'natural rate' and difficult to measure or observe; the Fed uses it as a reference point for policy guidance despite uncertainty about where it actually is
As defined in The "Profound" Impact of Rate Cuts Have BEGUN
Other definitions
The theoretical interest rate at which monetary policy is neither stimulative nor restrictive; Schvitz argues it has become unknowable because risk has migrated outside the system.
Viktor Shvets The Twilight before the stormThe theoretical interest rate at which monetary policy is neither stimulative nor restrictive, presumed to be consistent with full employment and stable inflation; a key benchmark for Fed policy calibration.
The End of Neoliberalism and the Coming Storm | Viktor Shvets
Where it comes up · 7
- The Market Has Moved from Deflation to Debasement | Warren Pies2 claims
- Viktor Shvets The Twilight before the storm2 claims
- Why The 2023 Recession Never Happened | Neil Dutta1 claim
- The "Profound" Impact of Rate Cuts Have BEGUN1 claim
- Is the Banking System at Risk of Another Financial Crisis?!1 claim
- The End of Neoliberalism and the Coming Storm | Viktor Shvets1 claim
- The Fed’s Ticking Time Bomb Is About To Explode | Joseph Wang & Chris Whalen1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “neutral rate” →
- The Federal Reserve's intervention since 2008 prevented a 1930s-level depression (avoiding 30% unemployment and pension fund collapses) but created secular stagnation instead, requiring perpetual fiscal and monetary support because underlying productive potential has not recovered.The End of Neoliberalism and the Coming Storm | Viktor Shvets
- Central banks must be backward-looking ('data-dependent') because they cannot look forward. Neutral rates and risk premiums are being 'bombarded outside the system' by the same factors that create unpredictable geopolitical and polarization risk. Even current debates about whether the neutral real rate should be 0% vs 2% show this uncertainty is unresolvable.Viktor Shvets The Twilight before the storm
- The concept of a 'neutral rate' used by the Federal Reserve to justify policy is a made-up economic concept that the Fed is unsure about, and policymakers should use real-world inflationary/deflationary terminology instead of invented economic concepts.The Fed’s Ticking Time Bomb Is About To Explode | Joseph Wang & Chris Whalen
- The Fed does not actually know where the neutral rate is and probably no single neutral rate exists, yet the Fed operates as if it does by using a 'dart board' approach to guess at policy neutrality, which explains why Fed rate decisions lack coherent logic.The "Profound" Impact of Rate Cuts Have BEGUN
- The Fed doesn't regret its 50-basis-point rate cut because their policy is still restrictive relative to neutral (which they estimate at 3.5%), and evidence of restriction remains visible in rate-sensitive sectors like housing, auto, and appliances; they expect to continue cutting toward 3.5% unless unemployment drops below 4.0%.Is the Banking System at Risk of Another Financial Crisis?!
- The neutral rate (the rate where policy is neither restrictive nor stimulative) is probably higher than the Fed believes it to be (Fed thinks ~2.5%); this implies the Fed can keep rates higher without crushing the economy, reducing recession risk from extended tightening.Why The 2023 Recession Never Happened | Neil Dutta
- Risk has not disappeared but migrated outside the economic and capital-market system into polarization, electoral outcomes, geopolitics, climate and healthcare—domains that portfolio managers and central banks have zero ability to assess, forcing central banks to be backward-looking ('data dependent') because they cannot locate the neutral rate or risk premium.Viktor Shvets The Twilight before the storm
- The bond bear scenario requires data coming in hot, causing the market to rethink the neutral rate and conclude the Fed cannot cut as much; this would shift the entire yield curve in a bearish way, requiring a full reversal of all currently-priced cuts, which would need sustained strong growth and job data.The Market Has Moved from Deflation to Debasement | Warren Pies
- Bond bear scenarios requiring 10-year yields to surge to 5.5-6% would require a full reversal of all Fed cuts priced into the market, implying the neutral rate is higher than 4% on Fed funds; this would require a dramatic 'hot data' surprise showing the labor market and growth accelerating, against current evidence of softening.The Market Has Moved from Deflation to Debasement | Warren Pies