
What this covers
This is a conversation between Jeff Snider of Eurodollar University and Steve Van Metre, prompted by the September 2024 payroll report: 254,000 jobs added, a 430,000 household-survey gain, 4.1% unemployment and 7.7% underemployment. The two read the numbers against the earlier episodes the description points to, when the FOMC began cutting. Jeff walks through 2007 in detail. August payroll was first reported at -4,000, then a 50 basis point cut in September was followed by a +110,000 report, with August revised up to +89,000. They treat this as a recurring pattern, and they argue that a cut announced in advance cannot plausibly explain data already being collected.
The middle of the discussion is about what the headline hides. Steve explains the sequence in which businesses respond to rising demand: first more hours for existing staff, then temps, then permanent hires. On that logic, the average work week of 34.2 hours, a hourly index that fell 0.1% and has been flat since May, and falling temp employment all point away from a genuine upturn. They also note job gains in leisure, hospitality and government alongside losses in tech and manufacturing. The wage-growth headlines are called misleading because trimmed hours can leave total pay lower. Steve adds anecdotes from a vacation destination, including multiple-job hospitality workers and weaker tips and covers.
The conversation turns more contested on a few points. They argue that monthly payrolls are unreliable given wide confidence intervals and benchmark revisions. They say the Sahm Rule reached recession territory in September, and that Jerome Powell dismissed it as "not a rule." Steve claims the Fed doesn't know where the neutral rate is and that a strong report gives it a narrative of success. He also says business survey language has shifted from confidence to hope tied to the election and cuts.
Strong monthly payroll data in September 2024 reflects normal cyclical noise rather than evidence that Fed rate cuts are working or that economic fundamentals have genuinely improved; underlying indicators like flat hours worked, declining temp employment, and weak survey data reveal continued labor market weakness.
- Historical precedent (2007, 2001, 2000) shows positive payroll reports during Fed cutting cycles are routine and temporary, followed by renewed weakness
- Hours worked flat for four months and average work week at cycle lows despite headline job gains indicate companies still managing labor costs, not ramping production
- Temp worker declines and weak hiring in productive sectors (tech, manufacturing down; leisure/hospitality, government up) show structural weakness masked by headline numbers
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
When businesses expect demand increases, they first increase hours for existing employees (not hire new ones), then add temp workers if hours are maxed out, then hire permanent staff; the absence of increases in hours worked and declines in temp employment signal no meaningful demand increase.
“let's say all of a sudden you your fax machine goes were and you get a bunch of new orders in and you get excited because hey things are turning around the first thing you don't do is go out and hire somebody new you turn to your existing three employees and say hey guess what we got a bunch of work coming in I'm going to increase your hours and that's what shows up in the data that's one of the first things we see if you want to know what causes the unemployment rate to go down that's the first step and then if the fact machine keeps worrying then they'll say hey we need to hire someone because now my three workers are complaining about too much too many hours they're not seeing their family that's not about the money it's about time and then they go out and and then add employees”
Hours worked are a leading indicator more important than headline job additions; the average work week fell to 34.2 hours and the hourly index fell 0.1% in September, both at cycle lows for the last four months, indicating companies are managing labor costs downward despite headline job gains.
“whatever is going on in the number of employees we're still getting the same types of indications that regardless of what the payroll report looked looks like at the headline we still see this weakness underlying in various ways that suggest companies are struggling they're still managing their cost structure and the biggest CA continues to be labor and employees um which means that don't want to get too excited over a single payroll report especially at this part of a cycle”
Wage growth was highlighted in payroll reports and media headlines, but this is misleading because hours worked were cut; workers received raises on their base hourly rate but had their hours trimmed, resulting in lower total compensation.
“we talked about wage growth and this gets people very very excited but one thing at least from the headline news stories that they didn't talk about was hours worked and this is what I'm seeing from my friends yeah i've got my player gave me you know raise my base Outlet rate and then they cut my hours so we just don't have enough work for us to do so they're cut you know my ship by an hour or two and I'm out looking for a third job because you don't maybe Jeff you don't know this but a lot of bartenders and waitresses and waiters they have three jobs they have two primary jobs and then the third to Fillin job and they're all telling me my hours are getting cut”
Companies manage their cost structure primarily through labor controls (hiring/firing, hour reduction), indicating that the primary lever available to businesses when demand is uncertain is workforce adjustment rather than investment or price changes.
“they're still managing their cost structure and the biggest CA continues to be labor and employees um which means that don't want to get too excited over a single payroll report especially at this part of a cycle”
In 2007, August payroll data was negative (-4,000), then after the Fed cut 50 basis points in September, the October report showed +110,000 (for September employment), with revised August showing +89,000; this exact pattern of weak data followed by strong data after a Fed cut is now repeating in 2024.
“if you remember 2007 we had all sorts of trouble summertime August the global not financial crisis erupted payroll report was actually negative for for the month of August which was the which was the uh estimate that was announced just before the FED cut rates in September it was actually a minus 4,000 so things looked pretty Grim heading into September 2007 the FED cut by 50 basis points and guess what happened in October suddenly the payroll Reports look really good the October payroll report was plus 110,000 this is for the month of September 2007 so it went from minus 4,000 to plus 110,000 plus the BLS revised August which was minus 4,000 to plus 89,000”
Economic data cycles always show boom-bust patterns with noise; nothing moves in a straight line; both Fed policy cycles and market cycles go in unpredictable non-linear ways (50bp cuts, 25bp cuts, pauses, then series of 50bp cuts), which is why extrapolating from a single month is always misleading.
“we are going to get a blowout number you said you said it's going to happen just wait yeah well there you go...we always get in these Cycles a slow down everybody panics everybody reacts to the negative data that starts to show up and then seemingly out of nowhere things turn around the data looks much better”
Consumer spending has not strengthened despite strong payroll data, suggesting the employment gains are not translating into broad-based economic activity.
“stocks are up spending is going to Boom but we don't see it all transmit through what consumers are actually doing”
Hourly index fell by a tenth of a percentage point and has been flat for four months from May through September 2024, indicating companies are not increasing worker compensation despite tight labor market narrative.
“the hourly index fell by a tenth of a percentage point and is basically flat for the last four months going back to May which is not a good sign”
The Sahm Rule, which uses three consecutive months of unemployment rate rising above 0.5% to signal recession, reached recession-confirmation territory in September 2024 despite the strong payroll headline, indicating underlying weakness despite monthly volatility.
“the um economists have developed uh measures like the Som rule to look past the monthly variation to try to look at where the momentum is and even in the month of September though the unemployment rate declined the Som R was still right at 0.5 which is supposedly the recession confirmation which means you've got three consecutive months of the S rule which isn't really a rule but three consecutive months of the S rule being in recession territory”
Monthly payroll reports should not be trusted as reliable signals of economic direction because they contain large confidence intervals and have become less reliable due to QCW and regular benchmark revisions that alter results months after initial publication.
“the confidence interval and the level of certain over the payroll report is nowhere near what people think it is what they're basically saying is we're not really sure how many jobs there were in September it kind of looked pretty good in the in the data that we got but if we run the simulations a 100 times we expected 90 of them that maybe we'll get the same number”
The September 2024 payroll data variation is greater than variation in previous cycles, making interpretation even more speculative due to increased data collection challenges and methodological adjustments.
“and we also need to expect whether to really to get a handle on whether or not that variation is consistent with all of the underlying fundamentals that we would expect to see if there was any type of signal within that noise there's there's always been variation there's always been there's always been variation that's just part of what we go through here but this time there's there's always been revisions there's always Benchmark revisions that change the change the results uh down the road and when people look back and get more complete data but this time I mean we've been talking about this for how long now and everybody knows you know from the qcw to the regular revisions that these these the the mainstream payroll reports are less reliable than they've ever been”
Fed rate cuts announced in advance do not immediately drive the subsequent month's employment data; the causation narrative (rate cut → employment boost) is tenuous and unrealistic when the labor market data was already being collected before the cut took effect.
“the FED cut rates last month this was last month's pay pay report so the question I'm going to ask you is let's say the FED didn't cut last month or maybe the FED raise rates 100 basis points would this report have changed not nothing would have changed we know that I mean this is not about the rate Cuts”
The September 2024 payroll report showing 254,000 jobs added, 430,000 household survey gain, 4.1% unemployment, and 7.7% underemployment rate represents normal cyclical variation rather than evidence of economic improvement or successful Fed policy.
“the numbers we got for the month of September 2024 were pretty striking well above expectations in every respect the payroll number comes in at 254,000 which was well above every expectation even the household survey Rose by 430,000 which is the most since March the unemployment rate fell to 4.1% the lowest in several months even the underemployment rate retreated to 7.7%”
Strong September payroll data allows the Fed to establish a narrative that its rate cuts are working and the economy is not in trouble, which provides psychological confidence to markets and policymakers that enables them to declare success and reduce future stimulus.
“and you know what's great about this is it gives people all the confidence in the FED which is what the FED really wants is people to believe in them and believe in the bestique because all of a sudden you hear wow the FED cut rat and look the economy boomed and people hired that's what they were waiting for is the Fed to give them the confidence that rate Cuts will change their lives”
The Fed does not actually know where the neutral rate is and probably no single neutral rate exists, yet the Fed operates as if it does by using a 'dart board' approach to guess at policy neutrality, which explains why Fed rate decisions lack coherent logic.
“officials become more confident they start talking about do we even need rate height rate Cuts anymore and then again simul out of nowhere it all falls over”
Survey responses from businesses shifted from confident language ('as soon as rate cuts and elections happen, things will boom') to hopeful language ('we're hoping the election and rate cuts do something'), indicating declining business confidence despite headline employment strength.
“before it was well as soon as we get rate cuts and election things are booming now there's change their tune we're hoping that the election and rate Cuts do something you can almost tell there's a shift now in the response rate because people are starting to wonder if it actually is something much bigger here”
If hours worked were rising convincingly along with rising payroll numbers, and if job gains were appearing in cyclical sectors like manufacturing, and if temp worker employment were rising, then there would be a genuine signal of economic turnaround; the absence of these factors indicates the signal is noise rather than trend.
“if hours are rising and the payroll reports are going up and I don't just mean by a single month or two but the hours are convincingly Rising then that would suggest that there is a material turnaround we would see jobs growing in Industries where jobs are not growing temp workers temp workers continue to decline that's a big one”
Many hospitality workers hold three jobs: two primary jobs plus a third job to fill the gap; when all three jobs cut hours, total income declines despite wage rate increases, and workers' survival depends on finding replacement work.
“a lot of bartenders and waitresses and waiters they have three jobs they have two primary jobs and then the third to Fillin job and they're all telling me my hours are getting cut yeah that was the one part of the payroll report that kind of stuck out as the okay what about this over here and that's one of the more important ones”
Service industry workers (bartenders, waiters, waitresses) in a major vacation destination are experiencing reduced tips, foot traffic, and restaurant covers across the board, contradicting any narrative of economic boom despite headline employment gains.
“I live in a place that is known for Hospitality because it is the vacation destination of the world and I know lots of people that work in the service industry and you know what I'm not hearing from them is how things are booming what I'm hearing tips are down foot traffic is down restaurant you know tickets are down it's down across the board not one person is saying hey things are moving in a positive direction here where I'm getting optimistic and people are getting very very worried”
Fed Chair Powell downplayed the Sahm Rule during a recent press conference as 'not a rule' with no analytical value, which is noteworthy because the rule is actually historically reasonably accurate at predicting recessions.
“I remember during the recent press conference that that sure B was asked about the P Rule and he downplayed it as if it was nothing which I got a huge kick out of because well you and I look at and say hey this thing is relatively reasonably accurate here and does give us some reason able trend of what could happen and he said that's not a rule that's nothing we don't we don't look at that which I thought was quite interesting here”