
What this covers
This is a roughly hour-long panel on Eurodollar University with host Jeff Snider, labor-market analyst Eric Basmajian, and Mike Green. It starts from the summer's jobs data. The July report pushed unemployment up faster than consensus expected and set off a global market scare. The next two reports then brought the rate back from 4.3% to 4.1%, and equities recovered. The panel treats that reversal as a delay, not a refutation. Basmajian argues that yield curve inversion works through mechanical links, such as the later collapse in real bank lending, and that some of those links have not finished playing out.
The banking discussion takes up most of the middle. Snider and Basmajian describe total loan growth of about 2%, below inflation, and say it turns negative once lending to non-bank financial firms is stripped out. Banks are also buying government bonds heavily, which Snider reads as a defensive posture across the whole balance sheet. Snider also points to rising loan loss reserves at Citigroup and JP Morgan. Green looks back at the March 2023 BTFP), arguing the universal deposit guarantee mattered more than the facility. The host raises the possibility that its shutdown leaves banks without emergency funding, since they still avoid the discount window.
The rest covers labor, markets, and gold. Basmajian holds that hiring freezes and cut hours matter more than layoffs, and that losses in the goods economy) must lead any recession. Snider adds that bond yields rise after the first Fed cut, and he argues that the Yen carry trade unwind reflected macro risk and was no mere technicality, a claim marked as contested. Green argues that gold's rise reflects remonetization and buying by China and Russia, not a fourfold jump in the odds of sovereign collapse. He also attributes the falling copper-to-gold ratio to technology trends more than to weakness, and he and Basmajian discuss gold's long-run purchasing power.
Banking system stress, credit deterioration, and inverted yield curves signal economic weakness ahead despite recent economic data improvements; multiple structural signals align pointing to potential recession timing despite ongoing narrative confusion.
- Banks are defensive, refusing to lend to real economy while credit quality deteriorates across major institutions before widespread job losses
- Yield curve inversion, negative real lending growth, and manufacturing job losses are mechanical leading indicators that traditionally precede recessions
- Gold, bond markets, and swap markets all signal economic concern despite equity market resilience, creating a multi-angle corroborative signal
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
When people lose jobs and take lesser-paying gig work to make ends meet, aggregate income in the economy goes down, which affects spending and creates downstream economic weakness—this reflects the 'permanent income hypothesis' where consumers adjust spending based on expected long-term income, not just current income.
“if you're taking a lesser a lesser paying job aggregate income in the economy is going to is going to go down you know it's The Old Milton Freeman permanent income hypothesis right where you act differently where you're I'm on a temporary job but at least there's money coming in but it's not my full-time job but it's not the job I want so I'm G to be more cautious in what I do”
The most important aspect of labor market dynamics is the lack of hiring (companies not wanting to hire) rather than layoffs, which tend to come at the end of downturns; companies start cutting hours, reducing benefits, and taking defensive measures long before formal layoffs.
“the most important aspect of the unemployment rate and unemployment as a phenomenon is the lack of hiring um which is to me far more important than layoffs um layoffs tend to come at the end what really triggers a recession or at least the start of the recession process is that companies say we don't want to hire anybody”
Total loans and leases across the entire banking system are growing at about 2%, which is less than the rate of inflation, resulting in negative real bank lending growth—a condition that has persisted since the SVB crisis in March 2023 and generally coincides with economic downturns.
“if you look at total loans and leases across the entire banking system it's only growing at about 2% Which is less than the rate of inflation so we're in a situation where we have negative real Bank lending growth”
Smaller regional banks hold fewer held-to-maturity securities than larger banks and therefore their underwater assets are primarily commercial real estate assets on the mark-to-market basis, which constrains their willingness to extend credit despite not necessarily creating insolvency.
“the smaller Banks hold less Securities it's the commercial real estate assets that are certainly underwater um on the mark”
Record high gold prices are being driven primarily by China, Russia and others choosing gold as an alternative to treasuries both officially and within their populations seeking mechanisms for safety.
“what is going on right now is is largely a function of China Russia and others choosing to buy gold as an alternative both on an official on an alternative treasuries both on an official capacity as well as within those countries people are seeking mechanisms for safety”
Lending to non-depository financial institutions (private credit) has been growing like crazy at roughly 15% year-over-year, and when you strip out this non-bank lending, absolute loans and leases in the system are actually negative, indicating banks are deliberately avoiding lending to the real economy and instead financing private equity and investment funds.
“the one area of growth that's actually you know uh really robust and quite remarkable is is the lending to non-depository financial institutions is what it's referred to in other words private credit that's been growing like crazy and if you pull that out I think think the last growth was you know something like 15% year of a year if you pull that out the absolute number in terms of loans and leases is actually negative”
The Federal Reserve's Bank Term Funding Program solved a liquidity crisis on a short-term basis in March 2023, but the more important intervention was the universal guarantee of deposits which stemmed massive deposit outflows.
“the btfp solved a liquidity crisis um on a short-term basis but I think much more important was the universal guarantee of deposits that basically stem the massive outflows”
Gold's long-term behavior shows multi-year bull runs followed by bear periods of pessimism, driven by euphoria and fear, but the assertion that 'one ounce of gold buys one tailored men's suit' or similar long-term purchasing power parity relationships generally holds up over very long periods despite intermediate volatility.
“gold tends to be kind of gappy and then consolidates and then gapy and then consolidates um I'm not really a technician either so I probably shouldn't have used those terms uh but uh I think that we're experiencing a huge runup in gold and I'm not sure it's unrelated to or or or not a lagged effect of huge monetary uh inflation that we experienced in 2021 and 22 it just took a while to catch up and then there's always the you know Euphoria and stuff that comes along with any big bull run in an asset but I think over long periods of time there's um you know good isms with gold like you know one ounce of gold uh generally buys one tailored men's suit”
Goods economy (construction and manufacturing) job losses must lead any recession because service-sector jobs cannot fall without the self-reinforcing effect that comes from goods-sector layoffs creating consumer income loss.
“the goods economy of construction and Manufacturing never work from home right you can't work from home if you're in the goods economy there's never been and I don't think there ever will be a recession without the Lion Share of the job losses coming from that Goods economy of construction and Manufacturing so we really need to see the job losses accumulate there”
Once banks price in the risk premium required to profitably make a loan on top of what they could earn by simply buying short-term government paper at the front end of the curve (around 5%) and middle curve (around 4%), the resulting loan rates (9-11% for consumer-facing lending) exceed what borrowers are willing to pay, creating a demand-side constraint.
“with the front end at five and you know the middle part of the curve you know closer to four uh they have to price in a a healthy spread to make um you know returns above what they could make just buying the short-term paper and once they tack on that spread especially for the consumer facing stuff you know you're up there at 9 10 11% which is the kind of where the banks would be willing to make a loan and then when you get to the other side no one's willing to take money at that price”
The yield curve inverted at the end of 2022 and has historically been a powerful leading indicator because it foreshadows future bank lending conditions; at that time real bank lending was growing 8-10% annually and has now collapsed to negative, confirming the mechanical predictive link.
“the yield curve inverted in uh at the end of 20122 and why is the yield curve a powerful leading indicator it's because it generally foreshadows future Bank lending conditions um at the end of 2022 real Bank lending was growing basically double digits it was somewhere in between 8 to 10%”
Banks are displaying risk-averse behavior not just by avoiding real economy lending but also by aggressively buying government bonds—a pattern seen across both US and European banks—which signals defensive positioning on the entire balance sheet.
“they should be expanding their balance sheets in this type of environment and it comes back to some form of risk not only are they you know only lending to private equity and similar you know non-bank in non-bank investment opportunities they're also buying a crap ton of government bonds this is common not just to the United States but also European banks”
There is a lack of demand for borrowing in addition to constrained supply from banks, which is another concerning economic sign indicating that businesses and consumers lack confidence to take on debt.
“there isn't a whole lot of demand for borrowing either which is another concerning sign as well it's like U it's it's blazs from both angles”
The cost of holding treasury instruments is rising given increased volatility around elections and the pattern of yield moves, making it more difficult for traditional treasury buyers to justify positions and encouraging them to step to the side.
“the cost of holding treasure instruments is going up and given the pattern that we're talking about it's more difficult ult for buyers to buy and they don't want to buy anyway”
Recent decades show increasing labor retention compared to past decades, particularly in goods/manufacturing sectors where skilled labor is difficult to replace, making companies more reluctant to lay off workers.
“there's evidence more so in you know recent decades as opposed to in in past decades they're retaining this labor longer and longer and longer uh because it's been very difficult especially again in this Goods economy where it's a more technical type of of job especially like a manufacturing floor it's very difficult to find the labor that's willing to do the job so they're very very reluctant to uh get rid of this uh full-time labor”
Credit deterioration is already visible in bank loan books—Lily Financial and Citigroup reported deteriorating credit card numbers and rising loan loss reserves, JP Morgan is raising loan loss reserves and credit deterioration appears before widespread layoffs occur—indicating banks are pricing in recession risk even as headline unemployment data remains stable.
“we've already seen credits uh credit deteriorate quite substantially already I mean Li Financial um who was the other one there's a couple other banks that reported recently that their loan books are starting to look really ugly and some of their credit card numbers City Bank City Group um was another one JP Morgan they you know Rising loan loss reserves and Loan credit or credit deterioration in their books already when the economy hasn't experienced the M widespread layoffs”
The Federal Reserve's Bank Term Funding Program was shut down in 2024 because banks and hedge funds were exploiting the arbitrage opportunity it offered, and now the Fed is trying to force banks to use the discount window instead, but banks continue to avoid it, potentially setting up a collision course where the lack of emergency funding sources could create stress.
“they shut down the bank term funding program...trying to get the banking system and participants in the banking system to use the discount window but Banks don't want to use the discount window in fact they continue to avoid it”
Even though the yield curve inversion occurred in late 2022, we have not yet seen the recessionary event that normally follows—but this does not mean the leading indicators failed; rather, there are mechanical links between specific indicators and their lagging outcomes, and some of these follow-throughs have not yet manifested.
“we haven't had the uh recessionary event that normally follows a yield curve inversion I think there's a whole host of reasons why that haven't that hasn't happened yet uh but uh I think that it's important to recognize that these leading indicators are not you know magic in the sense that once they invert”
Bond yields always go up after the first Fed rate cut—this pattern has recurred consistently since 2007 when the Fed cut 50 basis points in September 2007 and bond yields went higher into October, despite the Fed immediately cutting another 25 basis points.
“bond yields always go up after the First Rate cut always every single time you go back to 2007 the FED cut by 50 basis points in September 2007 bond yields are going higher into into October”
The Yen carry trade was related to macro risk recognition; Japanese financials are highly exposed to US financial and economic conditions, so Yen carry traders unwinding represented recognition of developing macroeconomic risks, not a market technicality.
“the Yen carry trade that was also related to the macro situation because so much of what the Japanese financials are exposed to is itself exposed to the US Financial and economic situation so the Yen carry trade was really a another another factor of recognizing the macro risk that were developing at the time”
The copper-to-gold ratio decline is more explained by long-term technology trends (requiring less copper for equivalent utility through miniaturization) than by fundamental economic weakening.
“Industrial Metals are becoming more and more they're easier to obtain they're easier to recycle the the utility of a copper wire has shifted from a very thick four gauge wire to a ton of strands of infinitees small wires that makes it much easier to use lower quantities of copper”
The long-term rise in gold from $300-400 per ounce in the 1990s to $2,700 currently does not reflect 4x increase in sovereign collapse probability, but rather represents remonetization of an asset that had been depressed by central bank selling and 1990s belief that gold would never be needed again.
“to to your point about purchasing power right you know this the the old adage as you pointed out about you know finally you know a men's suit a tailored men's suit I I can tell you with 100% certainty I can go buy a finally tailored men suit in various places around the world including New York City for somewhere in the neighborhood of 11 to 1200 bucks so I compare gold against American housing it's significantly overvalued”
The unemployment rate subsequently moved from 4.3% down to 4.2% to 4.1% across the next two jobs reports, completely erasing the recession fears that spiked in August and causing equity markets to melt up again as the recession was delayed once more.
“in the subsequent two jobs reports the market was very braced for the unemployment rate to go up again from 43 to 44 and what happened is you know we had the the the riko from 43 to 42 to 41 and it completely erased those fears that the recession is here at this present moment”
The first bank failure since March 2023 banking stress has occurred recently (as of the recording date), indicating that the post-SVB stabilization from deposit guarantees and BTFP is beginning to erode as conditions deteriorate.
“we actually just had our first bank failure a couple of weeks ago a couple of days ago I'm sorry um since the events of of March 2023”
The July jobs report showed unemployment surprising consensus to the upside with the unemployment rate rising and the pace of increase accelerating in a pattern that normally precedes recessionary conditions, causing global markets to have a 'freakout moment' tied to realization that the long-awaited recession was happening.
“in August we received the July jobs report and we had an unemployment rate that surprised consensus to the upside and it very much looked like at that moment that the unemployment rate was not only Rising but the pace of the increase was beginning to accelerate in a fashion that normally um that that normally is at the onset of recessionary conditions”
Fed officials speaking publicly between meetings through speeches and media appearances—the 'unofficial speak'—is a disservice to the institution and causes markets to perceive Fed flip-flopping that would be less apparent if only Chairman Powell's highly calculated statements were considered.
“the fed's um I don't want to call it the fed's official forward guidance but in between meetings we have the uh you know the the list of board members that uh not not not the minute The Unofficial speak from all of the fomc members that do their private speeches their media appearances um and all of that commentary is uh I think a disservice to the institution”
The Fed doesn't regret its 50-basis-point rate cut because their policy is still restrictive relative to neutral (which they estimate at 3.5%), and evidence of restriction remains visible in rate-sensitive sectors like housing, auto, and appliances; they expect to continue cutting toward 3.5% unless unemployment drops below 4.0%.
“I don't think they regret it um I think that they very much do believe that their current policy is well above the quote unquote neutral rate which in their mind means that they're still restrictive...the evidence that they're still restrictive is still present in the economy particularly the slowdown in the cyclical sectors housing units under construction are coming down building permits remain soft...I don't think that they regret the move”
The IMF recently lowered its global growth forecast significantly with emphasis on emerging market weakness, indicating international economic stress beyond US conditions.
“the um the point that I'd make on gold is twofold one is is that as you point out the Industrial Metals and the industrial use Commodities relative to gold prices continue to decline which generally indicates weakness in the over all economic sector we actually saw the IMF uh lower their forecast for Global growth for next year fairly significantly in just the past couple of days with an emphasis on Emerging Markets”
Gold should be understood as a hedge against sovereign collapse (when governments lose taxing authority and continue spending) or paradigm shifts in monetary systems, not as an inflation hedge or end-of-world signal.
“gold is actually a hedge against effectively a collapse of a uh Sovereign entity right so when a when a government loses its taxing Authority in the attempt to continue to maintain control they will of course continue to spend even as they can no longer tax and that's really what gold is protecting against”
Return-to-office policies function as disguised layoffs—companies impose stricter RTO requirements to pressure workers to quit voluntarily rather than formally terminating them, avoiding the appearance and expense of layoffs.
“return to office policies many people have said and I think you might agree with it that return to office policies are layoffs in Disguise because companies don't want to be the bad guy laying off workers so they're imposing stricter and stricter return to office policies basically inviting their workers to leave on their own valtion rather than forcing them out it is another like you said leading indicator”
Multiple market signals (gold, bond yield curves, swap markets, Treasury cash markets, copper-gold ratio) are all pointing in the same direction—signaling economic weakness rather than inflation—but because the signal is obvious, many people reject it, preferring more complex narratives.
“it's up to us to kind of fill in those blanks but notice how everything that we've talked about in this Q&A kind of comes back to the same thing why is gold Rising why are interest rates falling why aren't Banks lending I mean there's only a short list of scenarios that would fit all of these different characteristics we keep coming back to that same thing and it seems like it's the most obvious explanation which is why I think a lot of people just reject it because it seems too obvious almost”
Fed communication patterns have become unprecedented in terms of politicization, attention-seeking positioning, and media proliferation, representing a dramatic change from historical norms where Fed speakers were carefully husbanded like 'an audience with the Pope.'
“this is unprecedented uh you know the politicization the positioning the need for attention Etc that is occurring from various fed Governors access to these guys used to be very carefully husbanded right it was like you know you you felt like you were getting an audience with the Pope”
The 16-to-24 age cohort is prohibited from driving for Uber in many states, limiting their access to gig economy alternatives when laid off, which creates different labor market dynamics than older cohorts that can easily transition to gig work.
“the gig economy effectively if I lose my job I have a choice I can file for unemployment or I can start taking the car that I was using to drive to work or to drive for my home to go to the groceries and I can use that to drive and the the because I've already paying for my car right it's a sunk cost because I've already got my insurance Etc it's basically a pure cash transfer that makes somewhere around $52,000 a year is the average income for an Uber driver they're depleting their asset they're lowering it Etc the one group for whom this is really is that 16 to 24 group for various reasons they're prohibited from driving for Uber in many states”
The gold market narrative in the US of dollar collapse and 'gold to the moon' is being driven by speculation, not by legitimate macro hedging, evidenced by elevated gold skew (people buying out-of-money calls on gold relative to spot gold purchases).
“unfortunately that's now manifesting itself in a narrative in the United States that you know we're going to see the end of the dollar it's going to be a collapse that there's going to be you know gold to the Moon all that sort of stuff and so far what I would argue we haven't really seen is highly levered positioning in gold in the traditional sense”
Fed officials and commentators have been saying the U.S. economy is 'just fine,' China is doing stimulus to help worldwide, and Europe is coming out of recession, but banks are exclusively lending to non-banks and investment funds rather than the real economy, which contradicts the optimistic macroeconomic narrative.
“you get constant macro assurances that the US economy is just fine the the rest of the overseas economy you know the China's doing stimulus that should Pi that should boost uh conditions worldwide Europe is supposedly coming out of its recession we see the same thing in Europe by the way too lending only lending exclusively to non-banks or you know investment funds right”
At present, we are in a period of heightened cyclical uncertainty due to being at a potential cyclical inflection point, and most people's understanding of these inflections comes from Fed speakers—so proliferation of Fed commentary actually makes the environment muddier and cloudier.
“the level of uncertainty at cyclical inflections or potential cyclical inflections is always heightened to begin with and most people get their information about these inflections as well as the economy from people like fed speakers so it actually doesn't help in that respect either because it simply just makes it even more muddy and cloudy”
Jay Powell's post-rate-cut press conference walk-back of urgency was motivated by Fed desire to prevent markets from believing the Fed was panicking, not because the Fed actually regrets the cut.
“it's also constructed by jpw from his ve from the very press conference following the rate cut announcement said yeah we we didn't we didn't really want to cut by 50 we just kind of did you know he was walking back the urgency and the Panic that was associated with doing a 50 basis point rate cut”
Interest rates were moving lower from the end of April 2024 through mid-year with a global bond rally, including lower rates in Europe since May, but reversed after the Fed's rate cut in September—a reversal that people attribute to Fed mistakes rather than normal market dynamics.
“interest rates were going lower since the end of April in the United States with treasury yields um we got interest rates that were moving lower through the middle part of the year uh Global Bond rally we got you know lower interest rates in Europe since May you know everybody the Fed was higher for longer then the ECB cut then the FED started to cut so the FED finally cuts it gets out of the way and interest rates go higher”