naturalistic fallacy
The error of inferring that something is morally good or unavoidable from the fact that it is natural; O'Connor invokes it implicitly to deny moral weight to naturally-emerging inequity.
As defined in 113 | Cailin O'Connor on Game Theory, Evolution, and the Origins of Unfairness
Where it comes up · 7
- A History of Philosophy | 79 Ethics Since Logical Positivism2 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 77 A.J. Ayer — Language, Truth and Logic1 claim
- 32 - The Best Podcast Ever1 claim
- 156 - The Evolution Of Culture1 claim
- 37 - Thinking In Public1 claim
- Sam Harris & Jordan Peterson in Vancouver 2018 (with Bret Weinstein moderating) — Second Night1 claim
- 113 | Cailin O'Connor on Game Theory, Evolution, and the Origins of Unfairness1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “naturalistic fallacy” →
- When the analysis says inequity emerges 'naturally,' this means only that it is the outcome that arises naturally from the dynamics—it must not be given moral weight; the naturalistic fallacy of treating what is natural as good or as unavoidable should be explicitly resisted.113 | Cailin O'Connor on Game Theory, Evolution, and the Origins of Unfairness
- The fact that a trait is inherited and natural does not tell us whether it is good or bad—maternal mortality and tribal violence are perfectly natural yet awful—so we must evaluate traits by some other standard, and the strategy for moral progress is to deploy our good evolved inheritance (love, cooperation) against our bad evolved inheritance (tribal violence), avoiding the naturalistic fallacy.156 - The Evolution Of Culture
- William Frankena's key insight was that while one cannot logically deduce an 'ought' from an 'is' (Hume's law), if one adds an additional premise—such as a theological premise like 'God exists as a personal moral being'—then one can deduce an 'ought' from facts, because the theological premise introduces a source of moral obligation and value.A History of Philosophy | 79 Ethics Since Logical Positivism
- G.E. Moore's naturalistic fallacy argument claims that 'good' cannot be defined or reduced to any natural property (happiness, pleasure, utility, natural law, or anything empirically or metaphysically definable) and therefore good must be known through intuitive recognition rather than empirical definition.A History of Philosophy | 79 Ethics Since Logical Positivism
- Not all misreading is innocent misunderstanding; some is consciously malicious, where a misleading sentence is lifted out of context to spread a falsehood, so no matter how scrupulous a writer is, deep and provocative material cannot be fully bulletproofed against misleading quotation.37 - Thinking In Public
- With sufficient malice it is impossible to write anything that cannot be lifted out of context and weaponized; Harris illustrates with the naturalistic-fallacy example ('rape is natural') from Letter to a Christian Nation, which was used to falsely imply he defended rape, arguing that someone who plays by these rules has ended their intellectual credibility.32 - The Best Podcast Ever
- If one attempts to give a utilitarian definition of 'right' or 'good'—such as 'X is productive of Y consequences'—this translates the ethical judgment into a sociological or psychological statement, not a moral statement, so utilitarianism does not capture the meaning of moral judgments and commits the naturalistic fallacy of defining the good in terms of natural properties.A History of Philosophy | 77 A.J. Ayer — Language, Truth and Logic
- Harris argues that the utility of stories and religious narratives as behavioral motivators is not evidence that those narratives are true or should be preserved, and that we can achieve the same behavioral outcomes through different frameworks without the false supernatural claims.Sam Harris & Jordan Peterson in Vancouver 2018 (with Bret Weinstein moderating) — Second Night