If one attempts to give a utilitarian definition of 'right' or 'good'—such as 'X is productive of Y consequences'—this translates the ethical judgment into a sociological or psychological statement, not a moral statement, so utilitarianism does not capture the meaning of moral judgments and commits the naturalistic fallacy of defining the good in terms of natural properties.

causalpending

Speaker

University Lecturer (Unknown)

Evidence Quote

“What this translates is then X is is productive of Y consequences. That's a sociological statement, not a moral statement.”

Source

A History of Philosophy | 77 A.J. Ayer — Language, Truth and Logic— wheatoncollege
Created: 8/10/2026, 11:27:02 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...