multiplier
The Keynesian concept that an initial increase in government spending generates a larger total increase in economic activity (e.g., $1 generating $3)
As defined in cwt_adam-tooze
Other definitions
Keynesian concept that an increase in government spending raises total income by a multiple, as spending is re-spent through the economy.
Robert Higgs on the Great Depression 12/15/2008
Where it comes up · 12
- Michael Faye and Paul Niehaus on GiveDirectly4 claims
- Alberto Alesina on Fiscal Policy and Austerity3 claims
- Top China Economist’s Dire Warning: 15 Trillion To Stop Collapse | Taiwan Military Drills | Aging3 claims
- Joseph Stiglitz on Inequality2 claims
- Adam Ozimek on the Power of Econometrics and Data2 claims
- Robert Hall on Recession, Stagnation, and Monetary Policy2 claims
- Ed Leamer on the State of Econometrics 05/10/20102 claims
- Robert Higgs on the Great Depression 12/15/20081 claim
and 4 more
Most important claims · 10 of 23Search all claims for “multiplier” →
- GDP does not distinguish whether spending is for consumption today or investment for tomorrow—they count the same—so it cannot capture the tradeoff of using resources now versus investing for future consumption; this matters for any kind of sustainability (environmental, financial, or other) and has been confused in the macroeconomic debate of recent years.Diane Coyle on GDP
- The cash multiplier in Kenya differs from the domestic Keynesian multiplier because the money comes from outside the village rather than being taxed or printed locally; with US stimulus one must account for where the money came from, but in these studies the external injection means the village should clearly be better off, with the open question being whether nominal income rises more than the injection (true productivity gain) versus inflation offsetting it.Michael Faye and Paul Niehaus on GiveDirectly
- It is a mistake to ask whether the 2009 Stimulus Act as a whole worked, because it was not a discrete policy turned up like a dial but a bundle of a dozen different things—direct household transfers, green infrastructure spending, tax cuts, Cash for Clunkers—so the right approach is to evaluate the individual components rather than seek one aggregate multiplier.Adam Ozimek on the Power of Econometrics and Data
- The finding that a dollar of cash produces more than a dollar of benefit for recipients can be flipped: taxing that dollar from someone else would likely impose more than a dollar of cost — though with charitable dollars this concern doesn't apply, so the funding source matters for the welfare calculus.Michael Faye and Paul Niehaus on GiveDirectly
- Across episodes of austerity, spending-based fiscal consolidations have close to zero average output cost and have sometimes been expansionary, whereas tax-based consolidations have produced recessions of 2-3% of GDP lasting 2-3 years — a large and robust asymmetry that any unbiased observer would acknowledge.Alberto Alesina on Fiscal Policy and Austerity
- To genuinely establish whether government spending has a multiplier you would need a randomized experiment with a treated economy and a control economy, which is essentially impossible in macro; the closest natural experiment is wartime defense spending, but the World War II defense buildup tells us little about the effect of an Obama-style stimulus package because the situations differ so greatly.Ed Leamer on the State of Econometrics 05/10/2010
- Because the stimulus did not actually translate into increased government purchases—the funds went to debt paydown and tax rebates—it teaches nothing about the multiplier; you can only learn about the multiplier when government purchases actually change, which is exactly what failed to happen over the last decade.Robert Hall on Recession, Stagnation, and Monetary Policy
- The asymmetry arises because the simple Keynesian model is static: if people perceive spending cuts as permanent, they expect lower future taxes, so consumers consume more today and — more powerfully — entrepreneurs invest more for the future, because investment takes time to materialize and forward expectations matter greatly.Alberto Alesina on Fiscal Policy and Austerity
- The wide range of estimated fiscal multipliers before 2008 arose because the topic was a neglected backwater that few studied closely, and because the multiplier genuinely differs between full-employment and recession conditions while time-series data lacks enough degrees of freedom to identify those differences.Adam Ozimek on the Power of Econometrics and Data
- In the 2014 village-level study, cash inflows peaked at about 17% of local GDP, and by tracing revenue at local businesses and upward pressure on wages, the researchers estimated a fiscal multiplier of around 2.4 — meaning every dollar injected into the local economy raised output by about two and a half dollars.Michael Faye and Paul Niehaus on GiveDirectly