To genuinely establish whether government spending has a multiplier you would need a randomized experiment with a treated economy and a control economy, which is essentially impossible in macro; the closest natural experiment is wartime defense spending, but the World War II defense buildup tells us little about the effect of an Obama-style stimulus package because the situations differ so greatly.

causalpending

Speaker

Ed Leamer

Evidence Quote

“the same time kind of wonder whether the apparent impact of defense buildup in World War two tells us anything about the kinds of stimulus package that the Obama administration put together it doesn't seem to be having any relationship whatsoever”

Source

Ed Leamer on the State of Econometrics 05/10/2010— EconTalk
Created: 6/17/2026, 9:55:26 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...