moral constructivism
The view that moral rules are not derived from facts but constructed by people postulating guidelines based on what they want to be true, refined through coherence and dialogue.
As defined in AMA | April 2022
Where it comes up · 10
- 53 | Solo -- On Morality and Rationality5 claims
- AMA | August 20212 claims
- 258 | Solo: AI Thinks Different1 claim
- 49 | Nicholas Christakis on Humanity, Biology, and What Makes Us Good1 claim
- AMA | April 20221 claim
- AMA | April 20261 claim
- AMA | August 20221 claim
- AMA | June 20211 claim
and 2 more
Most important claims · 10 of 15Search all claims for “moral constructivism” →
- Moral constructivism can in principle supply the resolve needed for great sacrifice—asceticism, giving up what one loves, even dying for ideals—because the strength of moral commitment derives from how deeply one holds and acts on constructed values, not from believing morality is externally certain or that competing moralities are objectively invalid.AMA | April 2026
- Moral constructivism holds that ethical principles are made up by human beings—not arbitrarily, since there may be good reasons to choose some over others—as judgments arising from within us, rather than being objective principles existing out in the world or derivable from pure logic.53 | Solo -- On Morality and Rationality
- Moral constructivism can be framed as: it is true that almost all humans have moral inclinations even if specific intuitions are not universal, so we ought to make our inclinations as coherent and consistent as possible; the questioner wonders whether this fully bridges the is-ought gap or whether a formal step is missing.AMA | November 2023
- Carroll distinguishes meta-morality (the foundations giving morality its warrant) from object-level morality (which specific morals we adopt), arguing that while biology and our social goals shape what we count as moral, the foundation of morality does not follow from those facts; one can always choose differently without being 'wrong' as one could be about science or logic, so we should accept that morality lacks an absolute foundation and instead construct shared ways to live from our shared concerns and desires (moral constructivism rather than moral realism).49 | Nicholas Christakis on Humanity, Biology, and What Makes Us Good
- Constructivism is not too wishy-washy because it simply describes what actually happens: people come up with moral rules, disagree, sometimes persuade each other and sometimes hit irreconcilable differences—unlike the realist fantasy that objective rules would let you always convince an opponent over coffee through pure reason.53 | Solo -- On Morality and Rationality
- Once naturalism removes the old religious basis for the special value of human life, the right question is not why it's acceptable to kill cows but why it's wrong to kill humans; a constructivist answers that killing humans is wrong because humans generally have the intuition against it and don't want to be killed, so we agree to a rule prohibiting it and punish violators.53 | Solo -- On Morality and Rationality
- Moral constructivism differs from moral relativism: a relativist takes morality as valid only relative to a society and holds a quietist view where outsiders cannot judge, whereas a constructivist recognizes humans construct moral rules but, once constructed for good reasons, can and does apply and enforce them on others who disagree.53 | Solo -- On Morality and Rationality
- You cannot derive an ought from an is as a simple matter of logic: no set of purely factual premises entails a normative conclusion unless you smuggle an ought into the premises or equivocate on word meanings; there is no moral realism and no objective fact about what ought to be done, so oughts are not derived but postulated on the basis of what you want to be true, which is what moral constructivism describes and what people actually do.AMA | April 2022
- The utilitarian project of summing experiences into a single 'total utility' number to maximize is misguided and leads to the repugnant conclusion (that it is always better to add more people no matter how miserable); Carroll argues there is no coherent way to add up and compare experiences across beings (such as a cow's and a human's), so the whole enterprise is not merely difficult but not a sensible thing to attempt.AMA | May 2021
- Under moral constructivism, values are constructed by biological creatures with feelings and preferences as systematizations of underlying moral intuitions; since LLMs have no such intuitions, instructing an AI (e.g., to make paperclips) is not giving it a value, and calling AI safety work 'value alignment' mistakes the concept at step zero.258 | Solo: AI Thinks Different