normative

Total-utility maximization leads to the repugnant conclusion

The utilitarian project of summing experiences into a single 'total utility' number to maximize is misguided and leads to the repugnant conclusion (that it is always better to add more people no matter how miserable); Carroll argues there is no coherent way to add up and compare experiences across beings (such as a cow's and a human's), so the whole enterprise is not merely difficult but not a sensible thing to attempt.

normativepending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“there's this formal argument called the repugnant conclusion, which argues that if you believe that kind of utilitarianism, you should believe that it is always better to have more people. No matter how miserable those people are... I don't know a way to add up the experiences that a cow has and the experiences that I have.”

Source

AMA | May 2021— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:36:54 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...