modus vivendi
Literally a 'way of living'; in political philosophy, a conception of liberalism as a peace-treaty-like arrangement enabling diverse people who disagree about the good to live together.
As defined in 327 | Cass Sunstein on Liberalism
Other definitions
A workable arrangement or way of living together despite fundamental disagreements; specifically in Gray's usage, the practical coexistence that tolerance enables among people who disapprove of each other's beliefs but agree to abstain from forcing uniformity
Is Liberalism Dead? Fukuyama vs Gray
Where it comes up · 8
- Anthony Gill on Religion2 claims
- 101 | David Baltimore on the Mysteries of Viruses2 claims
- Velina Tchakarova1 claim
- Sarah Paine — Why Japan lost WWII (lecture & interview)1 claim
- 327 | Cass Sunstein on Liberalism1 claim
- Grand Macro Strategy Behind Venezuela and Iran - Most Important Conflict in 50 years? Michael Every1 claim
- Is Liberalism Dead? Fukuyama vs Gray1 claim
- Stephen Kotkin: Russia’s Murky Future | Foreign Affairs Interview1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “modus vivendi” →
- Viruses fully dedicated to one species co-evolve into equilibrium with their host—the virus becomes 'not too greedy' so it doesn't kill the host, and the host evolves to limit viral replication; but a virus that jumps from another species into humans hasn't co-evolved with them and so can become voracious and dangerous, which is why cross-species viruses cause the most trouble.101 | David Baltimore on the Mysteries of Viruses
- Political liberalism can be understood either as a modus vivendi—an honorable peace treaty allowing diverse people to live together—but is better grounded in respect and humility: a person lives by their own conception of the good without forcing it on others, out of respect for others' dignity and humility about their own capacities; this respect-based account captures the core of political liberalism better and is more inspiring than the peace-treaty view.327 | Cass Sunstein on Liberalism
- The China-Russia relationship is best understood as the 'Dragonbear'—a modus vivendi and modus operandi enabling the two to coordinate without entering any formal strategic alliance—a concept that drew no interest when introduced in 2014 but is now validated by daily commentary on a China-Russia axis and decoupling.Velina Tchakarova
- After a rapid revolutionary change in leadership, the rational strategy would be to renegotiate the church-state deal, but whether rulers crush or co-opt a religion depends on whether the church can offer a credible commitment to support the new regime; the Russian Orthodox Church's tight bond to the Czars made Lenin distrust it, so crushing was easier, yet even Stalin reverted to the bargain during WWII to rally nationalism.Anthony Gill on Religion
- Because the Soviet Union's diverse religions (Russian Orthodox, Muslims in the south, Buddhists in the east, dispersed Jews) tended to be ethnically and geographically bounded with little competition among them, the state could cut separate co-optation deals with each on a 'don't challenge us' basis, though the dispersed Jewish population was a special and persistently worse-treated case.Anthony Gill on Religion
- By 1941 Japan had suffered 600,000 casualties in China, and the US minimum demand was that Japan get out of China — but no Japanese government could leave China and remain in power, putting the government itself on death ground, which is why no diplomatic compromise (even a hypothetical leaders' call) could have averted war.Sarah Paine — Why Japan lost WWII (lecture & interview)
- HIV is native to monkeys, in which it does not cause serious disease, but when it jumped to higher apes like chimpanzees and to humans it caused havoc because it had not developed a modus vivendi with these new hosts.101 | David Baltimore on the Mysteries of Viruses
- Russia's grand strategic mistake is repeatedly assuming it must be anti-Western to survive and maintain great power status, rather than figuring out how to be non-Western (culturally and institutionally distinct) while maintaining beneficial relations with the West.Stephen Kotkin: Russia’s Murky Future | Foreign Affairs Interview
- Tolerance is fundamentally a judgmental practice—you tolerate things you actually dislike or hate and think are pernicious, not things you love or respect, and unless tolerated things pass certain strong boundaries, you must put up with them as a condition of modus vivendi in diverse society.Is Liberalism Dead? Fukuyama vs Gray
- Trump's first presidency promoted peace (no wars started), but his current strategy requires military escalation, which contradicts his peace positioning—though Kolanovic argues this is compatible with Trump's underlying imperative to find a 'new modus vivendi' with China and Russia.Grand Macro Strategy Behind Venezuela and Iran - Most Important Conflict in 50 years? Michael Every