lock-in
A situation where switching away from a product or platform is costly or impractical, trapping users with one provider.
As defined in Bruce Schneier on Power, the Internet, and Security
Other definitions
Making it costly or impossible for customers to leave a product, such as by blocking data export.
Matt Mullenweg – The Past, Present, and Future of the Internet – [Founder’s Field Guide, EP.20]
Where it comes up · 17
- Will MacAskill - Longtermism, Altruism, History, & Technology5 claims
- Geoffrey Moore - Building Gorilla Businesses - [Invest Like the Best, EP. 261]3 claims
- Dwarkesh Patel Podcast - 8 Predictions for the Era of Continual Learning2 claims
- Holden Karnofsky — History's most important century2 claims
- Bruce Schneier on Power, the Internet, and Security2 claims
- 305 - Moral Knowledge2 claims
- Legendary Investor Bill Gurley on Investing Rules, Insights from Jeff Bezos, Must-Read Books, & More2 claims
- Alex Sacerdote - How to Invest Through Technology Cycles - [Invest Like the Best, EP.477]2 claims
and 9 more
Most important claims · 10 of 29Search all claims for “lock-in” →
- Facebook created the Open Compute Foundation to define open standards for how hardware equipment (networking, storage, computers) works in their data centers so that if suppliers want to be on their purchasing list, they must be compatible with the standard, which commoditizes equipment and prevents suppliers from holding Facebook hostage through proprietary lock-in.Legendary Investor Bill Gurley on Investing Rules, Insights from Jeff Bezos, Must-Read Books, & More
- Network effects and lock-in make the ability to leave platforms like Facebook more illusory than real: you cannot take your data with you, and the social penalty—losing invitations and friends—is enormous, which companies deliberately cultivate by becoming so big that being on the platform is too valuable to abandon.Bruce Schneier on Power, the Internet, and Security
- A society can sustain ongoing change and fluctuation for extraordinary timescales only if its exploration never bounces into irrecoverable lock-in states like extinction or a self-perpetuating dictatorship that programs AI police to enforce itself forever—because once it hits such a stable attractor it stops changing, so preserving liberal flexibility for a billion years requires excluding those states from the range of things tried.Carl Shulman (Pt 2) — AI Takeover, bio & cyber attacks, detecting deception, & humanity's far future
- The current era is an unusual moment of plasticity because the world is historically unified with instantaneous communication and great moral diversity, yet this plasticity could end soon—especially if AI makes the world's rulers digital and immortal, enabling a single global ideology with no competition to persist indefinitely.Will MacAskill - Longtermism, Altruism, History, & Technology
- It is hard to appropriately value small-probability events with massive potential outcomes, and ordinary expected-value calculations become irrational or paralyzing; in long-termism this lets one prioritize trillions of hypothetical future lives over all present concerns, which the EA movement itself recognizes as the problem of 'fanaticism.'305 - Moral Knowledge
- As people move their email, photos, documents, and contacts into the cloud and onto locked-down devices like iPhones and Kindles (where software and updates are controlled by the vendor), they become vassals or serfs of companies like Google, Apple, Microsoft and Facebook—a feudal relationship in which the lords have rights but no responsibilities and the user, often the product rather than the customer, cannot easily leave.Bruce Schneier on Power, the Internet, and Security
- Better technology lets a ruling ideology cement and persist itself, so an alternate history where communism won the 20th-century war of ideas could have used anti-aging, genetic enhancement, cloning, or AI to build a world government that persists forever in accordance with that ideology.Will MacAskill - Longtermism, Altruism, History, & Technology
- Against the view that science is nearly complete (you get the fundamental laws and everything else is expensive but unimportant), there is a rival picture where discovery is ongoing and incomplete—even with basic laws, locating useful technologies at the macro scale remains a vast search problem—implying more diversity of tech across the universe, more ongoing churn and upheaval, and less civilizational lock-in; moreover full knowledge may be impossible because the knower is part of the system being modeled.Joe Carlsmith — Preventing an AI takeover
- There are moments of plasticity during the formation of a new institution where a set of norms gets locked in—as with the Christian church or the US Constitution, created in four months and lasting centuries—and this lock-in can be miraculously good or, as with the proposed constitutional right to slavery, extremely dangerous.Will MacAskill - Longtermism, Altruism, History, & Technology
- Facebook's lock-in for users came from collective action problem: because users' friends were scattered across the network and users had rare disease communities, emigrant communities, and family connections on Facebook, they faced high switching costs despite the platform degrading.We Didn’t Ask for This Internet | The Ezra Klein Show