Matt Mullenweg – The Past, Present, and Future of the Internet – [Founder’s Field Guide, EP.20]
What this covers
Matt Mullenweg, co-founder of WordPress and CEO of Automattic, talks with the show's host about the internet from its early blogging days to now. He recalls what the web felt like when WordPress began and how permissionless publishing and open source shaped it. He then asks where the pendulum sits between centralization and decentralization. His examples include Gmail, which sits on open SMTP but has effectively forked email, and Facebook's limits on organic reach, which pushed creators toward direct relationships with audiences. He ties that to Kevin Kelly's 1,000 true fans, as updated by Li Jin. Current threats to openness include Apple's control of app distribution and "internet nationalism," illustrated by Chinese pressure on Disney and the NBA. He also argues that phones did not kill long-form reading.
The middle of the conversation turns to organizations. Mullenweg describes employing people across 77 countries, a five-level ladder of distributed autonomy, and the claim that geographic hiring filters exclude about 99% of the world's population. He also says remote teams must invest deliberately in trust, including periodic in-person time. He draws on Amazon's API mandate as a way to cut the "coordination tax." Several claims are contested: that attackers always hold the advantage in security, that crypto is in its "Nokia and Blackberry" phase, and that a thousand subscribers beat a hundred thousand followers.
The last stretch covers company building. Mullenweg describes firms as worlds with rituals and communities that outlast their founders, and he cites Microsoft's ecosystem ratio and the MySQL lesson that hiring every contributor means writing nearly all the code yourself. He also covers Automattic's creed on the offer letter and his decision to keep its enterprise business alive against a board's wishes.
Mullenweg argues that internet openness and proprietary control follow a recurring symbiotic cycle, and that durable companies win by building open 'worlds' and platforms that deliberately capture only a small share of the ecosystem's value.
- Success of open systems invites parasitic capture, which provokes a counter-movement toward openness, and the cycle repeats across technology, religion, and governance
- Platform creators sustainably capture roughly 5% of ecosystem value; capturing much more starves the ecosystem and capturing much less invites a tragedy of the commons
- Distributed, asynchronous work and open internal interfaces can outperform office-based coordination if designed deliberately
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Amazon's mandate that every service be decoupled, communicate only over public protocols, and be designed for external consumption removes private coordination and reduces the 'coordination tax' that grows as companies scale and teams block each other.
“every service must be decoupled. You can have no private communication. It must all be over public protocol and it must be designed to be externally consumable as a way to stop that coordination tax of when companies get larger.”
Akismet's anti-spam approach works because a centralized service aggregating data across millions of sites and using machine learning can adapt faster than individual blogs, turning the community into a collective defense against spammers who use many IP addresses.
“The way to address it was creating a SaaS service, use machine learning to adapt really quickly.”
Automattic puts its creed on the offer letter below the legalese so employees sign their name next to it, a practice inspired by Dan Ariely's research showing that signing makes people take commitments more seriously.
“We actually put the creed on the offer letter. So after all the legalese, there's then the creed, and then you sign your name.”
Where leaders disagree, the conflict usually stems from short-term versus long-term thinking, since almost any CEO can boost revenue this year at the cost of customer loyalty and partner relationships, and the best leaders are long-term thinkers.
“Where I find there's conflicts there or differences of opinion, it is a difference of thinking short-term versus long-term.”
Every technology has a stronger capacity for offense than defense, so in computer security attackers have the advantage, and even the most sophisticated government cannot fully protect against threats such as nuclear weapons.
“Every technology typically has a stronger capacity for offense than defense, literally every technology.”
The prediction that phones would kill long-form reading was wrong; people read and write thousands of words on phones, and Automattic's long-form publication Atavist shows steady demand for in-depth content.
“turned out that not only would people read really long things on their phone. What was shocking to me is they also write really long things on their phones.”
Gmail was built on the open SMTP email standard but has effectively forked email by routing messages into categories and adding its own spam filtering and rate limiting, closing what had been a fully open format.
“It was Gmail. It's built on a completely open email infrastructure, SMTP, to create something different.”
Facebook began limiting organic reach to page followers, so creators who had built audiences had to pay to reach people they already had, which pushed many toward networks where they owned a direct relationship with their audience.
“Facebook started to pull the rug off people who built up followings on the pages.”
Internet nationalism, in which countries assert sovereignty over what content is allowed, is a major challenge to the open internet, and it extends beyond borders through economic pressure, as shown when China's pressure on Disney, the NBA, and a Saudi-linked documentary led to blocking by major studios.
“essentially applying its own rules, trying to extend them to the rest of the world. So that I think is a pretty big challenge.”
Kevin Kelly's 1,000 true fans idea, updated by Li Jin to roughly 1,000 blog or newsletter subscribers, is worth more than 100,000 Twitter followers because direct relationships are far more valuable than passive audiences.
“It's much more valuable to have, I think, a thousand people who follow your blog or subscribe to your newsletter than it is to have 100,000 followers on Twitter.”
Distributed teams must deliberately invest in trust and camaraderie, because shared meals and in-person time activate a primal social response that does not carry over to video, so companies should bring people together periodically.
“Because there is something at the very base, like lizard brain, that when we sit across a table and break bread or share a beverage, there's just something that gets activated.”
The most successful companies build a world, with mythology, rituals, communities, and fan participation, that continues after the founder, as creative works do, and companies like Salesforce do this through training, events, and community interaction.
“The best creators and creative works also then create worlds that happen after them. ... You can do that with companies. And my favorite companies do that.”
Apple's growing centralization of app distribution on the devices used by billions of people is among the biggest current challenges to an open internet, driven by Apple feeling like an underdog that increasingly closes its ecosystem.
“I say the biggest threat right now is Apple feeling like an underdog. They have this mentality where everything is getting more and more closed”
Cryptocurrency is still in its early 'Nokia and Blackberry' phase, where the price is a real distraction, and its truly disruptive use will be daily use rather than speculation, with on-ramps like Coinbase being positive for that.
“We're still in the Nokia and Blackberry age of it. There's obviously a lot of cool stuff happening.”
Successful platforms show a consistent ratio in which the platform creator captures about 5% of ecosystem value, roughly 1 to 19 or 1 to 20, as seen in Intel's x86 ecosystem and Microsoft's Windows, where Microsoft said $20 was made in the ecosystem for every $1 from Windows.
“every truly successful platform, there tends to be a ratio of the platform creator capturing about 5% of the ecosystem. So that kind of one to 19, one to 20 ratio is very, very consistent.”
The hardest decision is whether a struggling initiative is 'on the right path but misunderstood' and worth patience, or stubbornly wrong and needing change, as shown by Automattic's enterprise business, which a board wanted to shut down but he kept alive.
“The hardest thing is when to say, 'You're on the right path but misunderstood, and you should be comfortable being misunderstood for a very long period of time.' versus 'you're being stubborn”
Usage is oxygen for ideas: internal products forced on employees without the test of real use never mature, so internal teams should be allowed to compete with external alternatives such as public cloud providers.
“I like to say, usage is oxygen for ideas. Without it, you don't really know whether the idea is valid”
Companies claim to hire the best but apply geographic filters that exclude about 99% of the world's population, which implies either that those people are less valuable or that talent is equally distributed while opportunity is not.
“Your companies say they hire the best, but they then add this geographic filter of people who are in or removed from mountain view”
A useful test for any decision is to imagine repeating it for 10 or 50 years, which in open source means that if you hire every contributor, you end up writing nearly all the code, as with MySQL where 98% of contributions came from its own employees.
“Look at every decision you're doing and saying, 'If I iterated on this decision, repeated it for 10 years, for 50 years, what would be the outcome?'”
If an open source project hires every contributor, employees end up supplying nearly all contributions, as with MySQL, where 98 percent of contributions came from employees when it sold for a billion dollars, so the better strategy is to seed contributors across other companies.
“MySQL, when it sold for a billion dollars, 98% of the contributions were coming from employees in MySQL.”
Successful open systems create the conditions for closed actors to thrive parasitically, capturing more value than they contribute; once the closed winner grows too large, the rest of the market teams up to build something open against it, producing a recurring supercycle.
“the success of one creates the conditions for the other to thrive, almost like symbiotic species”
Every open system has a permission layer somewhere in its stack, and the success of open systems creates conditions for closed systems to thrive, and vice versa, like symbiotic species where one population's growth allows the other to enter.
“the success of one creates the conditions for the other to thrive, almost like symbiotic species.”
Work is asynchronous wherever possible, so distributed teams can cover 24 hours without night shifts, and early Automattic with 10 to 12 people completed about 15 days of work in a five-day week, outpacing competitors with more than 200 people.
“We had a particularly good version of this early on Automattic, where we were 10-12 people. Our competitors were 200 plus people, but we essentially had three shifts of coding going on. So we would get 15 days of work done in a five day work week.”
Automattic aims to keep its share of the WordPress ecosystem near 5%, because capturing more would suck oxygen from the ecosystem while capturing too little invites a tragedy of the commons in which free-riders starve the open-source core.
“Where we can keep our portion of the WordPress ecosystem around 5%? Because if we got too far beyond that, we'd start to take the oxygen out of the room.”
Spam is a bigger threat to open systems than hate speech because it can overwhelm a system like an algae bloom, and superior spam control was an underappreciated reason for Facebook's and Gmail's success.
“I think of spam as a much bigger issue than hate speech”
Consumers do need curation as open abundance raises search costs, but Mullenweg argues that claims of consumer fatigue are often a fig leaf used by bundlers and unbundlers to justify their business models, since people handle far more than they think.
“Now, I think some of that is used as a fig leaf by the bundlers and unbundlers to justify their business models.”
Employing people in 77 countries means something disruptive like a coup, hyperinflation, or account freezing is always happening somewhere, and being connected to colleagues there gives an early indicator of events that may spread elsewhere.
“Just being empathetic, connected to your colleagues gives you a lot of early indicator of things that can or will happen elsewhere.”
No company makes more than about 5% of the WordPress ecosystem's revenue, and multiple companies in the ecosystem have reached more than 100 million dollars in annual recurring revenue, which Mullenweg considers healthier for the platform's longevity.
“No one company makes more than probably 5% of the revenue in the ecosystem.”
Wix captures roughly 98% of the value in its ecosystem, while Shopify captures high single digits, and Wix's aggressive practice of not letting users export their content is a lock-in tactic that creates the seeds of its own demise.
“Wix probably captures 98% of the value in its ecosystem. Shopify is probably capturing high single digit.”
Mullenweg's goal is not to be the number two or three player but to reach an 85 to 90% natural monopoly by making WordPress the de facto and de jure open standard for the web, as Linux did for the kernel.
“my goal was not the number two or three in the market. It's the 85 or 90% natural monopoly that can happen in technology when a truly open system becomes the de facto de jure standard”
Each step in communication speed, from newspapers to smartphones, increases the clock speed of humanity's collective intelligence and interaction, and the internet may culminate in connecting every human, with cross-disciplinary collaboration on COVID-19 an example.
“For every step function in communication speed, we essentially are increasing the clock speed of humanity's intelligence, interacting with each other, and getting better.”
Open source works as a hack for getting competitors to cooperate, and WordPress shows this: no company makes more than about 5 percent of ecosystem revenue, yet multiple companies have built 100 million dollar ARR businesses on it.
“No one company makes more than probably 5% of the revenue in the ecosystem.”
The fifth level of distributed autonomy is a state where people work in environments tailored to them, measured by results rather than presence, and organized around personal rhythms, so a distributed team can outperform any office team.
“The fifth level of distributed autonomy is where you and your team are doing better work than any team in an office could.”
Mullenweg's most successful angel investments among more than 100 have been companies that had trouble getting funding, so neglected entrepreneurs can be the best investment opportunities.
“the most successful ones have been things that had a little bit more trouble getting funding.”
In the 1990s companies put AOL keywords on billboards, and by the 2010s they put Twitter handles and Facebook addresses there, showing that brands had moved their direct relationships onto platforms they did not own, a shift that is now reversing.
“What are people putting on billboards? In the nineties, people would put AOL keywords on billboards.”
Automattic structures itself so that each level, from a 20-person team to a 200-person division, resembles the early company, with division CEOs managing the P&L as investors would, granted resources to grow and reallocating people across divisions without treating headcount as a cost.
“they really just manage the P, they don't manage the L. We try to get them as much resources as possible to grow in a smart way, the same way an investor would.”
Articulating near-term business goals in terms of humanity's long-term goals, as Elon Musk does with sustainable energy and becoming multiplanetary, creates inspiring work that employees value beyond their paycheck.
“particularly when you're able to connect the near term business goals with the long-term goals of humanity, that can be really, really powerful.”
Following Geoffrey West, companies tend to die while cities persist, because large organisms tend to max out their growth, so organizations face a structural limit that cities avoid.
“Geoffrey West has an amazing book where he talks about how companies tend to die, but cities tend to live.”
In the early 2000s, people believed search had been solved and there was nothing left to build on the web, an impression Mullenweg now sees as very wrong because the field was early in development.
“A few years before, search had been written off.”
In asynchronous, results-based management, managers face higher latency in learning when someone is struggling, so they must set a check-in cadence and watch early signals of personal or professional trouble.
“you can have a higher lag time or latency to knowing when someone's having trouble.”
Amazon turned a cost center into a profit center by productizing infrastructure it built to solve its own peak-demand and capacity problems, a winner Mullenweg did not predict, expecting Yahoo or Google instead.
“Well, famously, Amazon made a cost center into a profit center.”
Centralized finance created the need for decentralized finance and cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin and Ethereum, making them examples of a proprietary system generating its own alternative.
“Bitcoin, Ethereum being most interesting as a great example of the success of the proprietary system is creating the need for the alternative.”
Open-source communities survive when participation is fun and inspiring, so leaders should ask how to make the contributor experience more enjoyable, because people want to join worlds that are exciting, not boring or draining.
“The fun question is such a good one. 'Is it fun?' And, 'How can I make this 10% more fun?' are really valuable.”
The best lessons for building cohesive organizations come from outside business, such as religions, cults, politics, democracy, and cities, and from behavioral economics and long-term incentive structures, rather than from companies alone.
“I think that the best learnings here come from studying things outside of companies and business.”
Missions and visions that any company would agree with are useless; a distinctive identity, such as preferring to be the pirates rather than the Navy, is what makes a worldview cohesive.
“Too many, when I read visions or missions, there's nothing that another company wouldn't agree with.”
Martin Luther's push to translate the Bible and disintermediate the Catholic Church was an open-source movement, and the Gutenberg Bible shows the same open-versus-proprietary cycle recurring across centuries.
“Martin Luther wanted to disintermediate that. He was the open source”
Incentives determine outcomes, a principle Charlie Munger expressed and Mullenweg endorses, so understanding long-term incentive structures is central to predicting how systems behave.
“Yeah. Show me a place where that doesn't happen.”
WordPress core has about 65 full-time employees, but a typical release involves 600 to 700 contributors, with Automattic providing about 10% of contributions.
“Typically, I said we have 65 people working full time, WordPress core. A typical release will have six or 700 contributors. We've managed to be like... We're probably 10% of the contributions”
When WordPress started, blogging felt saturated because AOL, Yahoo, Google, and Microsoft each had their own blogging platforms, and Blogger had already been sold to Google.
“Microsoft had one called Spaces. AOL had Journals. Yahoo had 360 and then Google had Blogger.”
Scientists who had never worked together collaborated across disciplines on COVID-19 at unprecedented speed, which Mullenweg sees as evidence that connected networks enable humanity to tackle shared problems.
“the cross-discipline approach that we've taken to tackling COVID 19 and the fact that scientists who have never worked together are now working together.”
Encryption, cryptography, decentralized protocols, blockchains, and open source are both opening the internet for direct users and forcing competitors to open up in order to compete.
“All of these things are both making the internet more open for its direct users and forcing the competitors to open up to compete.”
Bill Gates defined a platform as creating more value on top than it captures, and said Facebook's platform was not a true platform, a judgment Mullenweg believes has since been borne out.
“He did say that. It's funny because he actually said that in the context of, I think the Facebook platform, saying it wasn't a true platform.”
Early Automattic handed work across time zones, with Mullenweg working about 14 hours a day and passing off at midnight, a method that was possible at small scale but relied in part on overworking.
“And some of that was also probably some overworking. The fact that early on, I was probably on the computer 14 hours a day.”
Mullenweg is an optimist who believes humans are fundamentally good, so that when people are connected, the positive majority can overwhelm bad actors.
“But on the whole, I'm an optimist about humanity. I believe humans are fundamentally good.”
Every company should have an editorial team, because Automattic's small editorial group found strong demand for long-form content.
“which is actually something I think every company should have, an editorial team.”
In the early 2000s, a big exit was roughly a 20 to 25 million dollar acquisition by a company like Yahoo, which felt like a lottery, and Om Malik's advice was to start a company, get on a board, and be acquired in a couple of years.
“A big exit at the time was like 20 million. If Yahoo bought your company for 20 or 25, that was like a lottery.”
Automattic polled employees on whether they wanted to receive salary in USDC, a dollar-pegged stablecoin, and found interest across full dollar salaries, partial, and other crypto, with many early adopters.
“Who wants to receive their salary in USBC, which is a stable coin tied to the dollar?”
Web 2.0 in the early 2000s was an attempt to correct the excesses of Web 1.0 by making everything open, connected, standards-based, and integrated across services.
“Web 2.0 was trying to correct the excesses of Web 1.0, so everything was open. It was connected.”
A stranger in a pickup truck stopped traffic on a Houston highway so Mullenweg's disabled car could reach the shoulder after a tire blowout, an example of unexpected kindness.
“he starts stopping traffic across this 12 lane highway so that my car can limp to the right side onto the shoulder”
The pendulum between centralization and decentralization hit its low point around 2013, consistent with a roughly 20-year cycle, a judgment Mullenweg tests with the billboard heuristic.
“I think the nadir was probably 2013, which was roughly a 20 year cycle.”
After speculative carpetbaggers left San Francisco during the bust, the people who remained were true believers passionate about the web, which made it a productive environment.
“Carpetbaggers who were just to make a quick buck had kind of moved on to something else.”
Trillions of dollars of economic activity are not yet digitized, and even digitized processes often remain like a Dell box in a closet, so the opportunity ahead is almost unbounded.
“It is shocking, the trillions of dollars of the economy that is not yet digitized.”
Automattic ran on about 11 million dollars of outside capital from 2005 to 2014, which made it frugal and disciplined about allocation, and it has since raised over a billion dollars.
“The first 2005 to like 2014 was on a total of $11 million of outside capital.”