Geoffrey Moore - Building Gorilla Businesses - [Invest Like the Best, EP. 261]
What this covers
Patrick interviews Geoffrey Moore, author of Crossing the Chasm and venture partner at Wildcat Ventures. The conversation starts with his recent work on category-defining companies and then returns to the adoption framework that made his name. Moore separates a category (competitors addressing the same issue) from a market (customers who share use cases and talk to each other). He uses that distinction to explain why pragmatists decide by word of mouth, why the chasm opens between visionaries and the mainstream, and why a tornado follows once buyers realize others have adopted.
The range is wide. On architecture, Moore argues that open designs have mostly beaten closed ones over twenty years, but that the strongest position is a proprietary open architecture, where a gorilla controls the next release and its ecosystem conforms. He adds that the only thing worse than being locked in is not being locked in. On investing, he claims markets undervalue gorillas and overvalue chimps, a claim flagged as contested. He also explains why acquirers rarely unseat a gorilla. For founders, he covers spotting trapped value through "flashing red light" complaints. Crossing the chasm means committing to one use case, bringing a domain expert, and charging full price. He calls hiring a tornado-style sales force too early the commonest source of venture failure. He also describes funding rounds as quantum levels, with the "sucker round" as the mistake to avoid.
The last stretch turns to messaging, which shifts from inspiration to customer pain to features and price to retention and community. It also covers incumbents: Microsoft as a zone-defense player, the claim that zone offense tends to be founder-led, and Salesforce's V2MOM prioritization framework.
Moore argues that tech winners are set by category power and proprietary open architectures, so founders should find concentrated trapped value, win one use case to cross the chasm, and investors should concentrate on the emerging gorilla because markets misprice power-law returns.
- Category power, meaning the stage of the adoption life cycle a category sits in, is the strongest predictor of success, and returns follow a power law (gorilla gets the lion's share, number two gets about half, and so on).
- Startups cross the chasm by solving one concentrated, urgent use case for pragmatists in pain, then expand through adjacent use cases and segments.
- Incumbents must run zone defense or zone offense, and founder-led companies are the ones that can credibly reinvent themselves.
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The chasm is the gap between the early market of technology enthusiasts and visionaries, who buy the vision, and the pragmatists, who will not buy until they see others buy, creating a junior-high-dance standoff in which each side waits for the other.
“The chasm was just, "I'm waiting. You're waiting."”
A market segment should be defined as people who talk to each other, because pragmatists make decisions through word of mouth, and the tornado occurs when they talk to each other and realize others have already adopted.
“This is when it became so important to define a market segment as people who talk to each other, because the way these people make the decision is through word of mouth.”
Markets undervalue gorillas and overvalue chimps because investors apply an arithmetic, linear division of market share when they should use a logarithmic, power-law relationship, and most investors prefer lines over power laws.
“We overvalue the chimps and we undervalue the gorilla. It's the same high we just divided it wrong.”
To cross the chasm, a company must bring the complete whole product, a concept attributed to Theodore Levitt, to a pragmatist's specific problem, because pragmatists who are stuck will adopt only a complete solution, even though they do not share the visionary's belief.
“What you have to do is bring what a guy named Ted Levi called the whole product.”
In B2B, the free model is adapted through try-before-you-buy and consumption-based pricing, so a customer buys for 100 people and then extends, which led to the land-and-expand sales motion and to customer success.
“the notion of consumption based pricing so you can buy it for 100 people and then extend, so that it's led to something called the land and expand sales motion”
Once a category sorts into a pecking order, returns follow a power law: the gorilla gets the lion's share, the number two gets about half of what the gorilla gets, and the number three gets about half of what the chimp gets.
“The power law of returns from that pecking order is, the gorilla is going to get the lion share or the gorilla's share if you will.”
Over the last twenty years open architecture has generally beaten closed architecture, because closed architectures have a single point of failure so that if any part fails the product cannot ship, whereas in open architectures a failed component can be sourced from another vendor, though open architecture is harder to manage for quality.
“closed architectures always have a single point of failure. Meaning if any part of the closed architecture doesn't work, you can't ship.”
In the early market the only real salesperson is the CEO, who must be a buffalo-hunting pioneer, while crossing the chasm requires a vertically focused go-to-market engine, and hiring a tornado-style coverage sales force during the chasm is the single most common source of venture failure.
“hiring a tornado sales force when you're crossing the chasm, will cause you to lose your company.”
The hardest thing for an entrepreneur to realize is that pragmatists do not care about the company, so messaging across the chasm should begin with the customer's horrible problem and bring the solution in late in the dialogue.
“The second set of messaging is the pragmatists don't care about you. That's the hardest thing for the entrepreneur to realize.”
A category is defined by a set of competitors offering products that address the same issue, while a market is defined by a set of customers who have the same use cases and talk to each other, so a doctor in Japan and a doctor in the United States are not in the same market.
“a category is defined by a set of competitors. And a market is defined by a set of customers.”
Messaging must change across four stages: in the early market it is about amazing breakthroughs and inspiration, across the chasm it is about the customer's pain rather than features, in the tornado it is about features, price and coverage, and in mainstream it is about retention, expansion and community best practices.
“the foundation for messaging in each of those four stages is radically different”
Although customers dislike lock-in, the only thing worse than being locked in is not being locked in, because lock-in creates predictability, much like a tyrannical system whose trains run on time, so customers eventually feel it is too hard not to stay with the platform.
“the only thing worse than lock in is probably not being locked in. Because what lock in creates, is it creates predictability.”
Proprietary versus non-proprietary is about who controls the next release, since open source involves no lock-in while proprietary control creates locking, and the most powerful position is a proprietary open architecture where the gorilla controls an ecosystem of partners who must eventually conform to its standard.
“the most powerful idea was proprietary open architectures, where you had proprietary control of an ecosystem that involved other companies”
When companies acquire a gorilla or chimp, they think they can compete with the gorilla using their large customer access, but this fails because many other companies build businesses on the gorilla and will not invest in a second standard enough to make the return work.
“When people acquire a gorilla or a chimp, they're thinking that they're going to be able to compete against the gorilla”
Each venture funding round should be designed to reach a new valuation level, like quantum levels in an atom, because a round that fails to reach the next level forces another raise that dilutes existing investors, and the sucker round is the mistake of raising a round that only painfully dilutes.
“every round in funding is intended to get you to a new value valuation level”
Good pragmatists in pain are found through use-case dialogue with customers, looking for flashing red light complaints that signal urgency and contained trapped value, then validating whether the pain is idiosyncratic or endemic to the use case.
“you want it to be contained trap value. It's not a big reservoir, but it's not shared oil.”
During the chasm, marketing must commit to one use case and target a specific job title, such as the process owner, and sales must bring a domain expert who has lived the use case, while charging full price rather than discounting because failure is not an option.
“you actually are targeting a job title in that segment, the process owner who owns the NDA submission”
A company that stays over-specialized in a niche forever, which Moore calls bowling alley forever, can earn strong returns and create millionaires, but not billionaires, since it is not a tornado outcome and risks commoditization.
“Bowling alley forever companies can get a really good return. They create millionaires. They don't create billionaires.”
Zone offense, where a company voluntarily puts its own business in play, tends to be founder-led, because professional managers answerable to boards that hired them for shareholder value find it very hard to announce intentional value reduction.
“The zone offense tends to be founder led because only founders can voluntarily put their company in play.”
Salesforce's V2MOM framework (vision, values, methods, obstacles and measures) is valuable because it forces executives to stack-rank everything into a single order of priority, which removes the time that middle managers otherwise waste negotiating conflicting priorities.
“the key to it ultimately is prioritization. And a key point you use this system to stack rank everything you do in a single order of priority.”
Exceptional leaders galvanize organizations beyond their comfort zones through either customer-centric missions, where the company is letting customers down, or competitor-centric drive, where the company refuses to let rivals beat it, and leaders should pick one style rather than split 50/50.
“I think you got to kind pick one to be your style. I don't think you want to stay on 50/50.”
When evangelizing a new category, applications must reach the market before the enabling infrastructure because buyers will not purchase infrastructure until they see what it is for, though once applications scale they put enormous pressure on the infrastructure to be scaled and enhanced.
“it's important to get the applications out before the enabling infrastructure, because otherwise people won't buy into it.”
When a gorilla differentiates from its competitor, partners that conform to its standards become incompatible with the competitor's standards, so the gorilla's differentiation leaves rivals behind by pulling the ecosystem along with it.
“Every time I differentiate from my competitor, then you conform to my standards, you just made yourself incompatible with their standards.”
A category has a useful life until it becomes the value-trapping thing, as with enterprise resource planning and data centers, at which point customers want the new cloud category and the old category goes from hero to villain; before that moment disrupting the category is pointless because people cling to it.
“that category, which when it came to power, actually released trap value in our business”
Zone to Win applies Crossing the Chasm to public enterprises, because established franchises must take their organizations through the adoption life cycle when the next wave arrives, even though their core installed base can become trapped value and cause earnings J-curves that unsettle growth investors.
“Zone to Win is really Crossing the Chasm for public enterprises”
Microsoft has historically played zone defense by acquiring or catching up in categories rather than inventing them, such as adopting Netscape-era browsers after Netscape, and its strength is in playing catch-up, though it has been one of the best defensive players ever.
“Microsoft is playing zone defense. And by the way, Microsoft historically has been maybe the best zone defense player ever. They didn't invent any of their categories.”
New categories are created around trapped value, which is value locked up in a suboptimal state in an existing category, and as long as the world is not perfect, trapped value exists and remains attractive for entrepreneurs to release.
“as long as we're not at perfection, that means value is trapped somewhere, it's aways attractive.”
Incumbents do not need to leapfrog innovators, they only need to be good enough and fast enough, which is the perpetual race between incumbents getting innovation and startups getting distribution, though engineers rarely aim for good-enough.
“The thing that the incumbent has to realize is you don't have to leap frog the innovator. All you have to do is be good enough, fast enough.”
A company's power in a category is a function of its allies as well as its own enterprise, so total company power equals the company itself plus all the innovation that comes from its ecosystem.
“a company power is a function of your allies as well as of your own enterprise”
Trapped value must be concentrated, like a large oil reservoir that produces a gusher with a sense of release, because diffuse trapped value like the fragmented consumer health and diet market is slow and hard to extract, so it is a poor investment target.
“Trap value wants to be like those huge reservoirs of oil in the Gulf of Mexico, that's what you want, so you get a gusher.”
Investing in companies that have crossed the early market but not yet the chasm offers one of the best risk-reward plays in venture, because the reward is smaller than the gorilla in the tornado but the probability of success is higher once traction is proven.
“it's probably one of the best risk reward plays in all of venture. It's not the biggest reward. The biggest reward is to be the gorilla”
Crossing the chasm looks unnatural to venture capitalists, who want tornado-scale rewards, but it offers one of the best risk-reward profiles in venture because a company with a single funding round can dominate a use case in one market within about 18 to 24 months.
“with a single round of funding, you should be able to get cross the chasm and dominate a use case in a single market within probably 18 to 24 months”
Category power, which depends on where a category sits in the technology adoption life cycle, is the number one predictor of a company's future success for the next several years, which is why loss-making companies receive very high valuations when they sit in a hot category.
“that rising tide floats all boats, that is the number one predictor of your future success for the next several years”
Enabling infrastructure companies typically start with a problematic application use case that existing infrastructure cannot solve, such as Okta starting with single sign-on, and then expand outward from that point of entry into adjacent use cases and industries.
“enabling infrastructure always starts with a problematic application use case that you can't solve with existing infrastructure.”
Once a gorilla is established, an ecosystem forms around it and its de facto standards, which permanently instantiates the gorilla in its category, so it stays powerful even after the tornado ends, though it can still be mismanaged.
“the ecosystem forms around the gorilla, which instantiates the gorilla permanently in that category”
Open versus proprietary positioning emerges organically rather than being designed at founding, because lock-in develops only once a company creates differentiation that attracts customers and it can build outward from that differentiation.
“Where the lock in starts to develop, is when you start creating differentiation, however you create differentiation.”
Enabling technology companies are superior to application companies because enabling infrastructure scales as applications get expanded and enhanced, which puts pressure on infrastructure, and platforms become the power position in the tornado even though applications must come first in the chasm.
“once people start buying into the applications, then they want to start scaling them and they want to start enhancing them”
In the bowling alley phase a company expands from its first use case in its first industry to a second use case in the same industry or the same use case in a second industry, and once expansion is large enough the world recognizes the product as new infrastructure, which triggers the tornado.
“we called it the bowling alley phase of the technology adoption life cycle”
Once a gorilla sets the architecture, which determines the rules of the game like a country choosing left or right lane driving, the winner is very hard to disrupt for the rest of the category's existence unless a new category is created.
“it's very hard to disrupt the winner until there's a new category created”
The three variables for a new category are identifying where the trapped value is, identifying what is trapping it, and having a leader willing to take on a journey that is not for the faint of heart, which together let a founder declare themselves the global leader of the redefined space.
“The first is, where's the trapped value? ... The second thing then is what is trapping the value?”
The trapped value in developer tools is the combination of time, complexity and error in traditional tools, which hold back the digital transformation push to deploy software-enabled processes faster at scale, while the constant churn of new tools shortens their useful life.
“It's time plus complexity plus error. It's a productivity play.”
Software groups keep duplicating the same subroutines because building locally is productive in the short term, but this creates technology debt, and only later do companies centralize the duplicated work into a standard platform.
“What you do is, you do the heavy lifting in spite of the fact that it's long term unproductive, because in the short term it is productive.”
Platforming first creates a more productive internal workspace by doing the heavy lifting once, and once the platform is opened to customers and third parties, an ecosystem forms that lets a small company become a big one, which is the Gorilla Game.
“Platforming, the first goal of platforming is actually just to internally create a more productive workspace”
Strategic acts of generosity, where a company gives something away to build an addicted user base that it can later monetize, is how small companies become big, and Facebook and Google used the model, similar to a drug dealer.
“We call it strategic acts of generosity, where you essentially give away something.”
The shift from one-time sales to subscriptions turned customer support into customer success, because vendors now depend on continued usage, which makes the vendor-customer relationship more collaborative and gives customers more power than in the 1990s drive-by selling era.
“If you stop using my thing, my business model collapses. So customer support became customer success.”
A flagship customer is a known-brand customer that uses an early product with heavy vendor help to create competitive advantage, which validates the product and puts the vendor on the map, as Tesla did against the automobile industry.
“A flagship customer is a known brand name customer.”
Public companies undergoing a technology transition must expect a J-curve in which earnings get worse before they improve, which conflicts with investors who expect steadily improving earnings, so these firms may need private equity or specialized investors who understand the transition.
“if you're a publicly held company, your investors are used to having your earnings get better and better and better.”
Incumbents disrupted by digital transformation, such as General Motors facing Tesla, must carry their enduring strengths such as customer intimacy and operational excellence into the new paradigm, because customers stay with vendors that make this transition and leave those that cannot.
“They have to see if they can move their operational excellence from a combustion engine world to an EV world. If can, the customers will stay with them.”
An enabling technology company must be humble about first getting applications out in front of the market, because announcing itself as the next enabling infrastructure without a concrete application fails since buyers ask what it is for.
“if you just try to go out and say, we're the next enabling technology, it doesn't work.”
The Gorilla Game strategy is to buy a portfolio of companies that could win in a category entering tornado, then gradually exit the monkeys and chimps and concentrate money in the gorilla, holding it because the ecosystem permanently forms around it.
“you would buy a portfolio of companies that could win. As you saw who was winning, you would gradually exit the ones that are monkeys and chimps and put more and more money into your gorilla.”
Cisco's weekly commit cadence, which originated as a sales practice and spread through the organization, makes it impossible to fall more than a week behind without becoming visible, which prevents problems from being hidden and kicked down the road.
“you couldn't get more than a week behind without it becoming visible”
In relational databases, Oracle's row-level locking approach was chosen by independent software vendors over Sybase's, which left Sybase to compete in vertical market segments such as Wall Street financial services where it could win by supporting its own approach.
“They went with the Oracle approach to role level locking, which disenfranchised the Sybase one.”
Young entrepreneurs pursuing Fitbit-style approaches to health, diabetes or dieting are chasing trapped value that is too diffuse, so the approach is slow to extract, and cryptocurrency has not crossed the chasm because its only compelling use case so far is speculation.
“It turns out that that trap value is so diffuse. It's worse than Shell oil.”
Wildcat Ventures is raising a crossing-the-chasm fund that invests only in companies that have early market success but no winning position with pragmatists yet, with a single funding round expected to get a company across the chasm and dominating a use case in roughly 18 to 24 months.
“with a single round of funding, you should be able to get cross the chasm and dominate a use case in a single market within probably 18 to 24 months”
The technology adoption life cycle, from Regis McKenna's book The Regis Touch, describes five customer groups (technology enthusiasts, visionaries, pragmatists, conservatives and skeptics) that adopt a disruptive technology in sequence.
“there are these five strategies for adopting technology that evolve linearly”
Two examples show that innovations diffuse through networks: scurvy took about 200 years from discovery to mandated protection, and William Dawes rode with Paul Revere but did not have the town network nodes to spread the warning.
“But it took 200 years from that discovery to when it actually became a mandated protection”
Uber found trapped value in the dispatch system for taxicabs and Airbnb found trapped value in unused spare bedrooms, and both used essentially the same mobile overlay strategy, where trapped value meets disruptive technology.
“Travis said, well, it's the dispatch system for taxi cabs. Brian said, it's the hotel reservation system for travelers.”
The urgency of trapped value matters as well as its size, and the mRNA vaccine approach illustrates it because vaccine development had taken 15 years, a delay that represented enormous trapped value in lives.
“mRNA vaccine approach to building vaccines, was built on the fact that it was taking us 15 years to build a vaccine.”
The venture model is built on reaching a tornado, which requires a company with disruptive trapped value to cross the chasm between early market and mainstream demand, because it is at the chasm that most ventures stall.
“the problem is between the early market and the tornado, you have to cross the chasm.”
Companies adopted ERP systems such as SAP for twenty years to re-engineer inefficient business processes, but eventually the on-premise data centers, unique applications, and duplicated IT departments became the trapped value that cloud computing could release.
“We're all trapped in data centers. We all have to have our own data centers. We're all trapped in these applications that are unique and very hard to maintain.”
In the client-server relational database market Oracle emerged as the gorilla, while Informix became a chimp and was acquired by IBM after recognizing it was not the gorilla and needed to join a bigger consortium.
“Gradually Oracle emerges as a gorilla, and even Informix were chimps. And so what happened was Informix got acquired by IBM.”
Cryptocurrency has not crossed the chasm because it lacks a compelling use case beyond speculation, though it might serve as a store of value in hyperinflationary economies or as a placeholder for gold.
“I think cryptocurrency is still hasn't crossed the chasm, because I don't think there's been a compelling use case other than speculation”
Crossing the chasm looks unnatural to the venture capital community, which thinks in horizontal terms, but is natural to entrepreneurs, and the Macintosh story shows it: Jobs was furious when it was used in corporate art departments for desktop publishing, yet that was how it originally crossed the chasm.
“Crossing the chasm looks a very unnatural act to the venture capital community”
The kindest thing anyone did for Moore was when Don Purr hired him as a training director at a software company despite his lack of software experience, seeing someone he could mentor.
“I think he just saw somebody he thought he could mentor. And he did.”
The valuation difference between companies with traction and those without is called the traction gap, and the chasm and traction gap are virtually synonymous, since companies that are the gorilla of a niche while growing in a small market can capture the valuation premium.
“we sometimes call it the traction gap, the chasm and the traction gap for virtually synonymous”
In tornado markets the long tail of competitors can only clone the gorilla, which is a commoditization play, while chimps are systematically disenfranchised because they are squeezed between the gorilla and the commodity tail.
“All the long tail can do is clone the gorilla. That is a play, but it's a commoditization play.”
Google and Facebook founders used two-tier stock structures to preserve their ability to make long-term bets, but Moore thinks this is not healthy, and that large platforms eventually must acknowledge they are citizens of the world rather than private franchises.
“I'm not sure it's healthy. I think Facebook's now in a very unhealthy position, actually.”
Dropbox succeeded by targeting a pragmatist pain point left by Microsoft SharePoint, which was secure but hard to use, offering a secure, easy-to-use file sharing product for business users who depend on sharing documents.
“SharePoint was great. But it was hard to use. So then this guy Drew Houston did Dropbox.”
Founders motivated only by becoming billionaires are a bad motive, because changing the world can produce a billionaire as a byproduct, whereas trying to change the world in order to become a billionaire does not work.
“to change the world to become a billionaire, it doesn't work.”
After crossing the chasm, sales can grow 200 to 300 percent through a double-triple then triple-double sequence, such as 3x, 3x, 2x, 2x, 2x, as word of mouth spreads within a segment, bringing a company to roughly 35 to 70 million dollars in revenue.
“you can grow 200%, 300%. We often call it a double triple and then a triple double. So you go 3X, 3X, 2X, 2X, 2X.”
The tornado phase lasts roughly three to six years, depending on how fast diffusion occurs, which is a long time but not forever.
“Tornadoes might last anywhere from, depending on how fast the diffusion, from say three to six years”
A gorilla company is the market share leader in a powerful category, and the Hierarchy of Powers framework was developed to analyze how much competitive advantage a company has relative to alternative investments.
“The simplest definition is a market share leader in a powerful category.”