irony
In Strauss's usage, the deliberate presentation of an inferior argument tailored to a particular audience, which the discerning reader must raise to the higher level the author actually intended.
As defined in Conversations with Tyler - Harvey Mansfield
Where it comes up · 5
- Great Authors - Neoclassical and Romantic Literature - Swift, Gulliver's Travels3 claims
- The Bible and Western Culture - Hume, Swift, and the Collapse of Deism3 claims
- Kierkegaard's Christian Existentialism2 claims
- Conversations with Tyler - Harvey Mansfield1 claim
- 163 - Ricky Gervais1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “irony” →
- Hume is a more subtle author than Swift: unlike Swift's crushing sarcasm, Hume's irony is so deft that 'if you don't read it carefully you will sometimes get exactly the wrong inference on what he is saying,' requiring alert readers to catch his true meaning.The Bible and Western Culture - Hume, Swift, and the Collapse of Deism
- Swift's famous tract 'A Modest Proposal' is so saturated with irony that some readers (the speaker cites the case of an 18-year-old student) cannot penetrate it and read it literally as a serious proposal to kill and eat babies—demonstrating that irony can be so strong and powerful that it defeats its own communicative purpose.Great Authors - Neoclassical and Romantic Literature - Swift, Gulliver's Travels
- The comparison between Swift and Voltaire is instructive: both are dissatisfied with their contemporary worlds, but while Voltaire counsels 'ironic cynical resignation' (cultivating one's gardens), Swift 'thunders' at humanity and cannot adopt the pose of detached irony.Great Authors - Neoclassical and Romantic Literature - Swift, Gulliver's Travels
- Hume distinguishes between 'philosophical or true religion' (rational deism) and 'superstitious idolatry' with heavy irony, but the distinction is insincerely presented because true empiricism would render all religion irrational by definition, making the distinction a logical impossibility.The Bible and Western Culture - Hume, Swift, and the Collapse of Deism
- Irony as a cultural phenomenon always signals that a cultural tendency is dying: sincere, straightforward speech characterizes intellectual movements on the upside of their curve, but when movements decline past their midpoint, irony becomes the dominant mode of expression.The Bible and Western Culture - Hume, Swift, and the Collapse of Deism
- Every great book, and especially every Platonic dialogue, deliberately contains inferior arguments because Socrates speaks down to interlocutors who don't understand well; the reader's task is to take the deliberately inferior argument and raise it to the level the author actually intended—this downward shift and required elevation is irony, and analytic philosophy fails precisely because it lacks irony and refutes the deliberately inferior argument.Conversations with Tyler - Harvey Mansfield
- The price for escaping aesthetic life (with its boredom and aimlessness) is absolute fidelity to God, which may require committing terrible acts and accepting gruesome suffering.Kierkegaard's Christian Existentialism
- Irony means saying something you don't mean for comic effect; if you water down the irony so much that everyone understands it as harmless, it ceases to be irony, leaving only applause-seeking statements like 'racism's wrong' which are agreeable but not funny.163 - Ricky Gervais
- Kierkegaard's decision to write his doctoral dissertation on Socratic irony, and his entire approach to philosophical writing, reflects his belief that irony is essential for communicating the paradoxes and absurdities of genuine faith—something that cannot be explained directly but must be experienced through ironic contrast.Kierkegaard's Christian Existentialism
- When one of Swift's contemporary critics read Gulliver's Travels and wrote a review saying the travels seemed 'most unlikely,' the critic was unable to recognize the satire, demonstrating that even contemporary readers sometimes couldn't penetrate Swift's irony—the 'mutton heads reading books' of that era couldn't engage with the satirical strategy.Great Authors - Neoclassical and Romantic Literature - Swift, Gulliver's Travels