
The Bible and Western Culture - Hume, Swift, and the Collapse of Deism
What this covers
This lecture by Michael Sugrue pairs two Enlightenment-era writers who, from opposite sides, undermined the effort to square Christian revelation with the new physics. It begins with deism, the attempt to extract a core of natural religion that reason can reach without scripture, and with the clockwork-universe form of the design argument. Jonathan Swift, the caustic Anglican clergyman, attacks it as diet Christianity), useful mainly to politicians and ambitious intellectuals. The lecture presents him as backward-looking but a sharp diagnostic mind, and it quotes his image of enthusiastic mastiffs amusing themselves with a stuffed sheepskin.
The longer middle section is on David Hume. It covers his 1748 essay on miracles, where laws of nature are accumulated regularities of experience and the burden of proof falls on the miraculous. It gives his test for accepting a report, and his challenge to Christians to explain why Hindu or Buddhist miracle reports deserve less credit. It then turns to the posthumous Dialogues, which argue that empiricism can only yield a nearly empty claim about a God analogous to an orderly mind. The lecturer also notes Hume's subtlety: his irony is easy to misread, and the distinction between "true religion" and superstition is, on this reading, insincere. Detours into scholasticism and Meister Eckhart on God's namelessness show Hume working on problems medieval thinkers had already faced.
The final stretch looks at consequences. Irony is proposed as a sign of a dying cultural tendency, and Candide serves as an example of the Enlightenment losing its confidence. With deism gone, the lecture says, thought splits into a binary choice between faith and reason. One path runs through William Blake, Edmund Burke, who blamed deism for the Terror, and Søren Kierkegaard. The other leads toward scientific rationalism. The lecturer calls this failure productive rather than merely destructive.
The Enlightenment's attempt to reconcile science and religion through deism ultimately failed, crushed between Jonathan Swift's religious fundamentalism and David Hume's empirical skepticism, forcing Western thought into the binary choice that launched Romanticism.
- Swift demonstrated deism was merely hollowed-out Christianity useful only for maintaining hierarchies and social control, not genuine faith
- Hume's empiricist critique showed that miracles cannot rationally be believed and theological discourse becomes bankrupt when subjected to empirical standards
- The failure of deism forced a cultural choice: either follow Hume toward scientific rationalism and utilitarianism, or follow Swift toward religious intuition and Romanticism
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The failure of deistic reconciliation forces the birth of Romanticism as a reaction to the dry, desiccated rationalism of the Enlightenment, with figures like William Blake rejecting scientific rationality to recover direct religious intuition and feeling.
“we will be forced into the age of romanticism when william blake for example comes and writes about the dark satanic mills when he paints his beautiful religious work and writes his religious poetry he is reacting to the dry desiccated deism of the enlightenment he says no i'm a romantic i am going to tell you from the depths of my soul what my religious intuitions are like he thinks he gets direct influence from the divinity and because of that he is going to offer us an entirely new approach to religion which forsakes rationality forsakes the age of science forsakes scientific enlightenment rationality”
Hume's 1748 'Essay on Miracles' became one of the stock ideas of contemporary life by establishing skepticism about miracles, showing that the laws of nature are accumulations of regularities in human experience and that miracles as violations of those laws start with the burden of proof against them.
“in 1748 he published a short essay on miracles and oh my it is most unpleasant and it not only is it most unpleasant it's probably right and it's become what i would call one of the stock ideas in contemporary life in other words it is hard to get most people most of the time in the world around us now to believe that a miracle happened yesterday or happened recently in other words we are quite skeptical about miracles”
If one accepts miracles indiscriminately from all religious traditions, one must take every claim seriously (including a child claiming a monster in the closet), making life impossible; conversely, if one rejects miracles, Christian revelation (which depends on miracles) also fails—leaving no rational middle ground.
“the problem that emerges there is that you're essentially playing tennis with the net down that means that every account of miracles are plausible to you so when your six-year-old comes in and and says mommy there's a monster in the closet you have to take that proposition seriously and go see if there is a monster there there are too many accounts which are miraculous which are violations of our understanding of the world for us to actually live like that so hume is calling the bluff of those who would believe in miracles and say look take them all or don't take any of them if you want to just take the ones that happen to reinforce your religion isn't that intellectually dishonest aren't you dealing to yourself from the bottom of the deck”
Hume demonstrates through the Dialogues that we cannot prove God's existence a priori (through deductive logic like mathematics) because God is not contingent upon axiomatic systems and such proof would be mechanistic and implausible.
“it would seem that we can't prove god's existence to find out about god a priori... hume says that's one of the true kinds of knowledge but it doesn't seem to apply to theology we don't approve god's existence or find out about god's properties by driving him from axioms he is surely not contingent upon our axiomatic systems and that seems like a plausible argument um i can't imagine anything more mechanistic or implausible than to say qed god exists here are my axioms here's the proof”
Medieval scholastic philosophers and theologians addressed logical problems (like the problem of God's inscrutability) that Hume also engages with, despite being an Enlightenment empiricist seemingly opposed to scholasticism.
“it's also remarkable that he engages in certain logical problems which had been the concern strangely enough of medieval theologians and we wouldn't expect an enlightenment thinker particularly in a thinker who is part of the tradition of english empiricism to find much utility or interest in the problems that have been dealt with by certain scholastic and non-scholastic philosophers but in fact hume since he is treading somewhat the same ground cannot at least ask some of the same questions if his answers are different”
Hume argues empirically that we can only infer that God is 'roughly analogous to the kind of thing that would make the world that we have,' which is an empty tautology: if there is a God who made the world, then God will be like an orderly mind, but this tells us nearly nothing about God.
“hume says he wants to take it from an empirical standpoint and look at the world and say what generalizations can we make about god based upon the world as we see it he says yes there is a generalization we can make it turns out that god is roughly analogous to the kind of thing that would make the world that we have that's pretty much all you can find out about god in other words it's an empty tautology all you're going to find out is that if there is a god who made the world then it will be roughly analogous to an orderly mind but it will be analogous in a way that is not clear since there's only one example of god what are we talking about exactly”
Hume challenges Christians by asking: if they believe Christian miracles based on historical reports, why don't they believe Hindu or Buddhist miracles reported with equal historical documentation, since the evidence quality is equivalent—forcing a choice between consistent skepticism about all miracles or special pleading for one's own religion.
“he pulls out his ace and the whole he says particularly you devout christians and perhaps he was thinking of swift or if people like swift and he says you devout christians when you hear of reports say of miracles in the hindu religion or the buddhist religion or of any of the religions of any other part of the world do you believe in those miracles as well and if not why not and now the christian is faced with a dilemma between a rock and a hard place if the evidence and the accounts given of miracles within the tradition of christian of christianity are plausible and valid do you have any less evidence to believe that the miracles of the buddha or the miracles within the hindu tradition are not valid and if indeed you want to say that you don't believe in hindu miracles but you do believe in christian miracles is this anything other than the most obvious and implausible kind of special pleading”
Edmund Burke, as a Romantic religious and political thinker, criticized the Enlightenment tradition of deism because he believed it caused the Terror of the French Revolution by severing social bonds from their religious and traditional moorings.
“those that follow swift and think that science is hubristic and want to bring us back to our biblical heritage they are likely to go with blake and also with someone like burke who is a romantic religious and political thinker that wants to criticize the tradition of enlightenment deism he thinks that it causes the terror of the french revolution”
Jonathan Swift was a caustic and harsh Anglican clergyman who wrote the most caustic satire since Roman times, remarkable for how a man committed to Christian charity wrote some of the most biting Juvenalian satires in Western tradition.
“in the other corner opposed to david hume our frivolous and jolly scotsman we have a caustic and harsh cannon he's a uh he's a member of the anglican church and he's a clergyman and this is jonathan swift jonathan swift wrote the most caustic satire since roman times and it is remarkable that a man who is committed to christian charity and mercy and kindheartedness writes some of the most biting juvenalian caustic satires in the western tradition”
Hume published 'Dialogues on Natural Religion' posthumously because publishing it in his lifetime would have made him perilously close to charges of heresy, as it systematically undermines rational religion by showing that empirical examination of the natural world yields no meaningful theological knowledge.
“the first and most important of his works on religion is called dialogues on natural religion and there's a reason why hume published this book posthumously he would have got him i mean he always was getting in trouble with the ecclesiastical authorities because of his religious posture he could never get a job he was blackballed from university work but had he published this although england no longer burned people for heresy he would have been perilously close towards moving towards that”
Deism was the Enlightenment attempt to reconcile Christian revelation with the new physical understanding from the Copernican revolution by extracting a logical core of natural religion accessible to all humans through reason, independent of scriptural heritage.
“deism is the attempt by thinkers of the enlightenment to reconcile what they can of christian revelation with the new understanding of the physical universe that comes with copernican revolution and in particular they are trying to winnow out the false and fraudulent and merely poetic elements from religion from some sort of logical core that is accessible to all human beings independent of their of their scriptural heritage in other words they're looking for something like natural religion the religion that appeals strictly to the human mind and religion which can be justified on the basis of natural reason”
By the middle of the 18th century, the Enlightenment was running out of steam and losing the optimistic expectation that it would solve all philosophical problems, as exemplified by caustic ironic works like 'Candide' that rejected the reconciliation of reason and revelation.
“this in some ways is an ex is exemplary of the fact that the enlightenment at this time this is written uh this essay on miracles is written in 1748 that by the middle of the 18th century the enlightenment is beginning to run out of steam you will see the same sort of caustic rejection of religious approaches to the world in contemporary books like candide the enlightenment has started to lose its expectation that it will be able to solve all philosophical problems the optimistic hope that we could reconcile reason and revelation is beginning to wane”
The argument from design—that the universe is ordered like a clockwork and therefore requires a great mathematician (God) as a prime mover—is a deist favorite that Hume addresses through empirical analysis rather than dismissing it.
“this leads to one of the favorite arguments of the deist the argument from design we look at the world as a giant clockwork and we say no clock exists without a clock maker and the universe around us now that has been disclosed by newtonian mechanics is orderly like a clockwork and perfectly mathematical like a clockwork there must be some great mathematician behind it who has ordered all things from the word go and they still need in other words the idea of a prime mover which is held over from scholasticism”
Søren Kierkegaard, the greatest of Romantic theologians, is the historical response to the Enlightenment's failed attempt to reconcile faith and reason, as his 'Either/Or' philosophy embraces the choice between faith and reason rather than attempting synthesis.
“when we are forced by the splitting of this wishbone to decide that we can't have our cake and eat it too that we must go one way or the other we are setting up the work of sauron kierkegaard sora kierkegaard the greatest of the romantic theologians who is a great apostle of either or which is his greatest philosophical work soren kierkegaard's work will be a response to the fact that the enlightenment program of reconciling science and religion has failed”
Hume is a more subtle author than Swift: unlike Swift's crushing sarcasm, Hume's irony is so deft that 'if you don't read it carefully you will sometimes get exactly the wrong inference on what he is saying,' requiring alert readers to catch his true meaning.
“hume on the other hand is very deaf you wouldn't if you don't read it carefully you will sometimes get exactly the wrong inference on what he is saying”
Swift argues in 'Argument Against the Abolition of Christianity' that enlightenment deism represents 'diet Christianity'—Christianity with the calories taken out—that destroys genuine religious faith by leaving only a hollow shell of myths useful to politicians and ambitious intellectuals.
“the implication here of course is that the enlightenment deism the whole project of reconciling science and free rationality with religious faith is something like diet christianity it's christianity with the calories taken out with any of the the things that make christianity christianity right left in it all we have is the shell the husk the the set of myths which could have been any set of myths from the perspective of the enlightenment”
Hume distinguishes between 'philosophical or true religion' (rational deism) and 'superstitious idolatry' with heavy irony, but the distinction is insincerely presented because true empiricism would render all religion irrational by definition, making the distinction a logical impossibility.
“he spends page after page insisting on a distinction between philosophical or true religion which one assumes is deism one assumes it's the rational religion of the enlightenment and mere superstitious idolatry but the ironic insincerity of this distinction is palpable how will you know what rational religion is if your conception of knowledge is based upon empiricism if you are going to take that conception of knowledge seriously irrational religion is an occimaron it's a contradiction in terms”
Meister Eckhart, a medieval theologian, argues that 'God has no name' because God is a unique being unlike anything in human experience, so no predicates can apply to God—every predicate requires its opposite negation, which logically constrains the thing being described.
“think about meister eckhart for example who is about as far removed from hume as any human being could possibly be but meister eckhart makes the very fine point when he says that god has no name what he says what he's implying is this god is a unique kind of a thing there's nothing like him and he's not remotely like anything else that you've ever experienced that entails the idea that no predicates apply to god think about it you say that this that this podium is made of wood it entails the idea that this podium is not made of steel and it's not made of glass if i were to say that this studio is warm it implies that this studio is not frigidly cold in other words every predicate is a limitation”
Swift was remarkably prescient in predicting that religion would become merely a scarecrow or distraction for dangerous people ('enthusiastic mastiffs may amuse themselves with a sheepskin stuffed with hay'), prefiguring Gibbon's later view that all religions are useful to politicians.
“swift was remarkably prescient if you uh he said when discussing religion that one of the utilities of it is that quote enthusiastic mastiffs may amuse themselves with a quote sheepskin stuffed with hay in other words religion is now just a scarecrow but we still have dangerous dogs among our people and it would be much better to give them something to tear apart and play with so long as it's not real”
Irony as a cultural phenomenon always signals that a cultural tendency is dying: sincere, straightforward speech characterizes intellectual movements on the upside of their curve, but when movements decline past their midpoint, irony becomes the dominant mode of expression.
“may i suggest not just for the enlightenment but the whole history of the west irony always means that a cultural tendency is dying a sincere speech straightforward speech is when we're on the upside of the curve when an intellectual movement is taking off after it's reached that midpoint and we're on the downside of the bell curve that's when a culture becomes ironic about itself”
The failure of the Enlightenment's deistic reconciliation of science and religion is productive and auspicious, not merely destructive, because it forces Western thought to stop trying to 'have it both ways' and to make genuine choices about which commitments to prioritize.
“i'd like to take the idea that the enlightenment project of reconciling science and religion the failure of that as being fruitful and as being auspicious as well as being negative by showing that reason and revelation are never completely in accord by showing that we can't quite do all the or satisfy our desire for logical rigor and our desire for religious certainty if we can't have both at the same time we will be forced into a set of choices in which we don't split the difference”
Swift was a backward-looking thinker but an exceptionally intelligent and caustic critic who accurately diagnosed the implications of Enlightenment philosophy and tried to save Western civilization from those consequences, even though his alternative may not be acceptable to moderns.
“although in some respects he may seem to be an intellectual luddite somebody that is destroying the machinery of rationality because he's afraid of the consequences on the other hand he does accurately see what those consequences are so if his alternative may or may not be acceptable to us his diagnosis of the problem of the enlightenment does not fall far short of the money he is a remarkably accurate critic”
Hume's empirical philosophy assumes that knowledge comes from sense perception of spatial-temporal things, making theological discussion of celestial mystical experiences and realms outside space-time objects of his reductive scientific scorn.
“if you just stop before we go into the text and think about what an empiric an empirical philosopher someone who believes that you find out about the world by your sense perceptions that things that are spatial templar are real imagine what his religion is going to look like it's not going to be very far from tables and chairs and celestial mystical experiences other realms outside of space and time are going to be the object of his scorn and are going to be the object of his reductive scientific inquiry”
Hume would only rationally accept a miracle if not believing the authorities reporting it would require positing an even greater miracle—for instance, if everyone in London reported the city had floated into the air, one might accept the city floating as more plausible than mass hallucination.
“he says if i am to take miracles seriously and i am to be continuous and i'm to be rational at the same time i am only allowed to accept the miracle and he does not rule out the possibility but he says i am only allowed to accept a miracle if by not believing in the authorities which give me this miracle i would be positing an even greater miracle in other words if someone comes to me who has been say delirious or drunk or asleep and perhaps dreaming and says i saw a water run uphill or i saw an island floating in the sky you might have good reason to say no you didn't you were delirious or you were drunk or you were dreaming that and the reason why you would have good grounds for skepticism there is because the tear in your network of belief would be far greater if you believe that water flows uphill or that islands float in the air then the terror that is involved in your belief in saying i think that this person is making a mistake”
Those following Hume's empirical skepticism move toward Bentham and utilitarianism (grounding morality and value in measurable outcomes), while those following Swift's critique of reason's hubris move toward Blake and Burke (grounding morality in religious tradition and intuition).
“those that follow the path of hume will go we'll move in the direction of bentham and utilitarianism those that follow swift and think that science is hubristic and want to bring us back to our biblical heritage they are likely to go with blake and also with someone like burke who is a romantic religious and political thinker that wants to criticize the tradition of enlightenment deism he thinks that it causes the terror of the french revolution”
Hume argues that keeping one's network of beliefs coherent requires adopting 'the assumption that the right answer in dubious questions will be the one that creates the smallest tear in the networks of our beliefs,' suggesting a coherence theory of truth.
“what hume is doing is trying to keep the network of our beliefs integral and he's essentially adopting the assumption that the right answer in dubious questions will be the one that creates the smallest tear in the networks of our beliefs i think this may well be a move in the direction of a coherence theory of truth”
Jonathan Swift and David Hume were near-contemporary 18th-century English thinkers who made such strenuous and persuasive critiques of deism from opposite perspectives that deism could not survive into the next century.
“in the case of the enlightenment and in the case of england two figures immediately suggest themselves england is a very felicitous land in this respect it has two people that are near contemporaries they're both 18th century thinkers and they're remarkable for the strenuous way in which they make their stands about deism and they pull theism apart they create such a persuasive critique of deism from different perspectives that ultimately deism cannot weather the storm it cannot survive into the next century”
Swift's temperament was remarkably different from Hume's: Swift was a caustic, enraged man outside his time who hated the secular Enlightenment, while Hume was a quiet, funny, contemplative religious skeptic—making Swift the believer who was furious and Hume the skeptic who was jolly.
“we have our religious skeptic turns out to be a man of great contemplative disposition but also quite a quiet and funny fellow on the other hand our christian believer who believes in the possibility of salvation and holds on tradition traditional moral ideas and religious ideas turns out to be a man outside of time enraged at the society that would generate anything as secular as the enlightenment”
In the 'Dialogues on Natural Religion,' Hume uses two main speakers, Philo and Cleanthes, to argue through the problem of natural religion, with Cleanthes initially claiming religion is practically useful for shoring up morals—an argument Hume agrees with pragmatically but that Swift made ironically.
“in the dialogues we see two arguers mainly they're actually a couple but the two main figures are philo and clianthes and swift goes through all the motions that or hume goes through all the motions that swift had said any enlightenment thinker would have to um for example there's a point at which uh cliente says religion is practically useful in shoring up morals that could be taken straight out of swift but hume doesn't mean it in any ironic way”
If the Resurrection did not happen, then Jesus did not raise Lazarus; without the Resurrection, there is no Christianity as traditionally understood—making Hume's essay on miracles functionally an argument against the core claim of Christian revelation.
“it will come as no surprise to you that hume got himself in an enormous amount of trouble for publishing a thing like this and this is generally thought of as being one of the seminal texts of the enlightenment because it undermines such an important element in the history of christianity if jesus did not really raise lazarus from the dead it is also equally possible nay it may well be completely logically necessary that jesus himself was not resurrected from the dead and if you don't get the resurrection you don't get christianity”
The point is that no matter how Hume is read, if taken to its logical conclusion, his thought 'abolishes all things that you can't see,' echoing Jesus' words to Thomas about faith without seeing being blessed—Hume offers the opposite: he does not believe without seeing.
“so the point then is that no matter how you read hume if you take it to the logical nth degree if you finish off the train of his thought what he is doing is abolishing all things that you can't see what is it that jesus says to thomas blessed is he is he who has believed without seeing after thomas puts his hand in jesus aside well it turns out that hume is not blessed in that sense he does not believe without seeing what he has done is offered the other bookend to swift”
Between Swift and Hume, or between the camps they represent, the optimistic hopes of deism have been turned into a wishbone and split, with both sides tugging in opposite directions, neither getting the majority part—the attempt to reconcile science and religion fails.
“what hume and swift have done have turned english deism and deism as a whole is also waning at the same time for much the same reasons they've turned deism into a kind of a wishbone and hume is tugging in one direction and swift is tugging in the other and they split the wishbone of enlightenment deism and neither of them gets the majority part it turns out that the attempt to reconcile science and religion to reconcile revelation and reason fails”
David Hume was perhaps the greatest Enlightenment skeptic, an empiricist who generated a powerful skeptical argument against causality and managed to play practical jokes on Western philosophy through his empirical methodology.
“hume in the first case was perhaps the greatest of the enlightenment skeptics he was an empiricist and he if i would be inclined to describe as the greatest philosophical joker of the enlightenment hume was a big fat jolly old scotsman that spent his entire intellectual career playing practical jokes on the tradition of western philosophy by being an empiricist for example he managed to generate what certainly appears to be a very powerful skeptical argument against causality”
Swift's Gulliver's Travels contains a critique of humanity through the Houyhnhnms episode, where horses are portrayed as much more moral than people, revealing Swift's censorious judgment of the people around him, paralleling the prophetic condemnation in the Old Testament book of Jeremiah.
“there are references to religion there and to our lack of piety into the fact that human beings do not measure up well compared to a world of horses if you know the end of gulliver's travels with the winnims right he goes to a land of horses and the horses are much more moral than the people right which tells you a great deal about how swift not feels about horses but rather feels about the people around him he is a censorious judgmental figure those of you that know the old testament when you read jonathan swift would be well served by going back to read the book of jeremiah because swift is constantly engaging in jeremiah's telling these wicked people that god will wreak his vengeance upon them”
Swift would rather have outright atheists in charge of government and theology than hypocrites who maintain religion only for pragmatic purposes, since 'we have let the camel into the tent, we have let the hawk into the chicken coop.'
“god forbid the worst kind of people to to be renewing our theology we have let the camel into the tent we have let the the hawk into the chicken coop the worst people that we could possibly put in charge of a government and a religion are the ones who only go through the motions of christianity in some ways better having outright atheists people who are really willing to say let's abolish christianity directly”
Empirical (a posteriori) knowledge works through observation and inductive generalization from repeated sensory experience, which is the foundation of modern natural science and the only legitimate way to understand the world of space and time.
“a posteriori means that it's inductive that we look at the world and make generalizations about it for example we know facts about the world of space and time by observing it and making it generalizations about our observations water runs downhill that's a fact about the world the way you find out that fact and all other facts about the world is by looking at the world we get some water in an inclined plane and we pour it and down it goes and down it goes and down it goes and we do it several times we watch what happens and then we make a generalization this is the kind of thinking about thinking that is characteristic of empiricism and also this empirical stance towards knowledge is the foundational stance of modern natural science”
The Enlightenment (roughly 1600-1800) was the most important age of scientific and philosophical development in the last 500 years, during which theology became a lesser subject compared to its status during the Reformation and Middle Ages.
“the enlightenment was probably the most important age of scientific and philosophical development in the last 500 years or so and if we roughly date the enlightenment from say 1600 to 1800 it's worth inquiring in the into the uneasy connection between science and philosophy on the one hand and religion and theology on the other because the enlightenments were so dynamic and so fruitful in its scientific and intellectual endeavors for in one of the few cases in western history theology became a lesser subject”