
Kierkegaard's Christian Existentialism
What this covers
This is a single-lecturer talk by Michael Sugrue on Søren Kierkegaard, framed as a reaction to Hegel's claim that philosophy had reached its endpoint. Kierkegaard is placed within the broader Romanticism that rebelled against Enlightenment rationality, and the lecture sets him against Immanuel Kant, whom it treats as the paradigm of rationalism. The old problem of connecting faith and reason runs back to Augustine, but Kierkegaard's answer undercuts reason itself, making him something like a modern Job. Reason here means David Hume's instrumental kind, a tool for satisfying desires, not a way of grasping ultimate reality.
The middle of the lecture works through the structure of Either/Or. The aesthetic life covers sensual and intellectual pleasures alike, and the lecture follows Kierkegaard's argument that its constant pursuit of novelty is hollow, hidden from view by distraction, and that boredom is the symptom. The ethical life is the pursuit of moral righteousness for its own sake, resembling Kantian duty but resting on passion. Between these lies criterionless choice: no neutral standard decides between them, and the lecture extends the point to the choice between naturalistic and metaphysical views of reality, which it admits is contested.
The sharpest contrast comes in the two readings of Abraham. Kant's footnote would test even a divine command against the categorical imperative, while Kierkegaard holds that Abraham is great precisely because sacrificing Isaac makes no moral sense. The lecture also covers the price of leaving aesthetic life, namely absolute fidelity to God and possibly terrible suffering. Further topics include Kierkegaard's use of irony, from his dissertation on Socrates onward, and his image of a clown warning of a burning theater to an audience that laughs. The lecture closes on the forlorn, anxious strain in his writing that anticipates twentieth-century existentialism, and on the claim that life's weightiest decisions have no algorithm behind them.
Kierkegaard's philosophy represents a radical rejection of Hegelian rationalism and presents an existential framework where individuals must make fundamental life choices (between aesthetic and ethical/religious life) without rational grounding, establishing the foundations of modern existentialism.
- Kierkegaard opposed Hegel's systematic reconciliation of reason and faith, insisting on an irreducible either-or choice between them
- The criterionless choice between the aesthetic life (pursuit of pleasure) and ethical/religious life (moral righteousness) has no rational decision procedure
- This framework prefigures 20th-century existentialism by emphasizing radical freedom, subjectivity, and the necessity of choice in the face of uncertainty
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Kierkegaard's distinctive contribution to philosophy is the view that there is no rational criterion or standard for making the fundamental choice between the aesthetic and ethical lives; the choice must be made without rational justification—what he calls 'criterionless choice'.
“what makes kierkegaard a precursor to existentialism is that he holds the view that there is no criterion for making this decision in other words he faces us with the grim the horrifying reality of criterionless choice”
The fundamental problem Kierkegaard addressed—connecting faith and reason—has ancient roots going back at least to Augustine, but Kierkegaard's solution involved undermining reason and the Greek element in Western intellectual tradition, positioning him as a modern Job whose faith takes absolute priority over rationality.
“kierkegaard is going to reformulate the problem that's been around since the time of augustine at least of connecting faith and reason but only at the cost of undermining reason undermining the greek element in the western intellectual tradition and becoming something like a modern job”
Every person, whether they recognize it or not, must make a fundamental choice between naturalistic ontologies (nature as the ultimate reality) and metaphysical ontologies (nature plus a transcendent realm), and this choice cannot be grounded in any neutral criteria that does not presuppose what it is trying to prove.
“we have to choose between naturalistic ontologies and metaphysical ontologies we have to choose between athens and jerusalem we have to choose between religious faith and rational certainty and the question is what criteria could we possibly offer for either decision that we were to make and to make the question even more difficult what possible grounds for this judgment could we offer that doesn't presuppose what it's trying to prove”
Kierkegaard is part of the broader Romantic reaction against Enlightenment rationality, along with Romantic artists and thinkers who prioritized feeling, sentiment, grand emotion, and passion over rational calculation and measured proportion.
“kierkegaard is writing in the first part and the middle part of the 19th century he is one of the great examples of theological romanticism and of course that's connected with the entire romantic reaction to the enlightenment and to the rationality that's central to the enlightenment romantic thinkers like or romantic thinkers it's almost a contradiction in terms romantic intellectuals like feeling over reason they like grand and beautiful emotions they emphasize sentiment”
Kierkegaard's philosophy is fundamentally a reaction against Hegelian synthesis, which claimed that philosophy had reached its end point through Hegel's comprehensive systematic philosophy that explained the ultimate purpose and goal of human life.
“kierkegaard's philosophy is a reaction to the hegelian synthesis the idea that philosophy pretty much closed up shop once hegel had put together the ultimate or comprehended the ultimate purpose or goal of human life”
In the age of romanticism and the age of anxiety (the 20th century), humans face simple subjective choices with no decision procedure, set adrift in a realm of whim, opinion, feeling, taste, and sentiment—which Kant described as a 'wretched anthropology'.
“when we move into the age of romanticism and also into the age of the 20th century the age of anxiety if you want to call it that we are faced with simple subjective choices which have no decision procedure we are forced to make either-or decisions perhaps not of the fundamental uh significance of the choice of the aesthetic or the ethical life but we are faced with choices many choices which we are informed have no rational grounding and that means we are set adrift in a realm of whim in an area of opinion of feeling of taste of sentiment which is what kant described as a wretched anthropology”
The ethical life, as Kierkegaard defines it, is the pursuit of moral righteousness independent of pleasure—following moral rules for their own sake rather than for satisfaction or rational justification, similar to Kantian ethics but grounded in passion rather than reason.
“what he means by the ethical life is the person who pursues moral righteousness independent of pleasure what he means by moral righteousness is the person that follows ultimately god's divine law whether they recognize it immediately or not”
Kierkegaard is one of the earliest and most important precursors to 20th-century existentialism, and his work continues to have direct acknowledged influence on contemporary philosophical writing.
“kierkegaard then one of the great romantic theologians one of the great reactions to hegel one of the few early 19th century writers whose work still has a considerable direct acknowledged influence on the philosophical writing that is characteristic of living philosophers today”
Rationality in Kierkegaard's framework is understood in Hume's sense—as instrumental rationality used as a means to satisfy desires—not rationality in the continental sense of comprehending ultimate reality.
“the life of rationality not rationality necessarily in the continent sense more likely rationality in the sense that hume uses it instrumental rationality rationality used as a means to satisfy our desires our desires may be the physical satisfaction of our pleasure neurons or it may be intellectual satisfactions”
Kant's famous footnote on Abraham argues that if God appeared to humans, they should not obey unless they could verify that the command is consistent with the categorical imperative—in other words, Kant would submit God himself to rational ethical scrutiny, treating reason as the ultimate authority over faith.
“if it were the case that god should appear to us by some miracle literally speaking we couldn't just fall down on our knees and do what god told us we'd have to stop and ask ourselves is this really god i mean that's a that's the kind of thing a rationalist does when god appears to me asks who are you right”
The aesthetic life encompasses both physical/sensual pleasures (sex, alcohol, physical satisfaction) and intellectual pleasures (reading philosophy, aesthetic appreciation), united by the orientation toward pleasure whether physical or mental.
“under the aesthetic life what he means is both physical sensual pleasures uh sex and alcohol and uh i don't know any physical sensual pleasure in addition to that as as a component of the aesthetic life there's also the intellectual pleasures in other words he does not leave out the intellectual hedonists”
Abraham is great not despite but precisely because his willingness to sacrifice Isaac makes no moral sense—it violates every ethical principle—yet he does it out of pure faith; in Kierkegaard's view, if the action made sense rationally, it would not demonstrate genuine religious faith.
“abraham was one of the great men of faith one of the great religious figures in the world precisely because what he is doing makes no sense if it made sense it wouldn't be nearly so good”
The core problem Kierkegaard addresses through the concept of boredom is that the aesthetic life—constant pursuit of pleasure and novelty—is fundamentally hollow; this hollowness is masked by distraction, but awareness of it would lead to despair or even suicide.
“the real evil or the real misery in the life of the aesthetic man is boredom kierkegaard says and i think it's one of the greatest lines in the history of philosophy it's beautiful and it's horrifyingly true he says that boredom is the root of all evil”
In the first volume of 'Either/Or' (the aesthetic life), Kierkegaard presents arresting images and writes from the perspective of an aesthetic person, explaining what it is like to be us (and argues that we do not fully comprehend the wretched state of the purely natural aesthetic person).
“in the volume one in the ether he presents some very arresting images he writes from the perspective in the first volume of the ether he writes from the perspective of the aesthetic man and explains to us what it's like to be us as if we didn't know and in fact kierkegaard thinks that we don't know”
A person's fundamental orientation toward the world—whether toward the aesthetic life (pursuit of pleasure), the ethical life (moral righteousness), or the religious life (faith)—determines their behavior, activities, and the level of human existence they achieve.
“kierkegaard believes that the orientation that a person takes to the world determines their behavior determines their activities determines the level of human existence that they may rise to”
Kierkegaard uses the image of a clown in a burning theater announcing the danger seriously while the audience laughs, treating the warning as a joke, as a self-description of his own philosophical project—he is a serious religious thinker whose warnings about human spiritual peril are dismissed as morbid cynicism by an unreflective public.
“at a theater one evening a fire broke out backstage and one of the clowns came out onto the stage and announced to the audience that the theater was on fire they thought it was a joke and he told him no really the theater is on fire you are in terrible peril and the more he told them that the funnier they thought it was and the more they laughed this is kierkegaard self-conception he is a joker who is deadly serious”
Kierkegaard's claim that people must 'earn your stripes as an intellectual by not only thinking problems through but feeling them through' means that genuine philosophical understanding requires not just rational comprehension but existential commitment and suffering.
“he feels that people that haven't suffered for what they believe almost have no right to it that you earn your desserts that you earn your stripes as an intellectual by not only thinking problems through but feeling them through”
Many of the important decisions in human life do not offer a rational decision procedure; human wisdom is not derived from any algorithm but from experience, hunches, and muddling through an obscure, unclear world not perfectly delineated by reason.
“it may well be and i have a hunch that it's the case that not all the important decisions in life offer us a rational decision procedure many of the important elements in human wisdom are not derived from any algorithm they are derived from experience from acting on your hunches maybe from doing the best you can muddling through a world that is obscure unclear and not perfectly delineated delineated by the light of reason”
There is a strain of philosophical melancholy, forlornness, and anguish in Kierkegaard that seems modern and almost anticipatory of 20th-century existentialism, though the religious formulations are not typical of later centuries.
“there's a strain of philosophical melancholy in kierkegaard a forlorn-ness a kind of anguish which is very much modern which seems almost a part of the 20th century the strange religious formulations are not in keeping with this century i'll grant that but the idea that truth is subjectivity one of kierkegaard's favorite terms instead of the drive for objectivity and certainty and rational proof characteristic of the thinkers of the enlightenment kierkegaard says no like any good romantic truth is subjectivity”
The price for escaping aesthetic life (with its boredom and aimlessness) is absolute fidelity to God, which may require committing terrible acts and accepting gruesome suffering.
“for kierkegaard we live in a grim and rather macabre world there is a terrific amount of misery and pain and irony connected with the best of human lives the price for escaping the aesthetic life from for escaping boredom is a life of absolute fidelity to god and that means that you may well be called upon to do things that are exceedingly unpleasant even unto the murder of your own child”
Biblical faith according to Kierkegaard is exclusive and jealous—'The Lord thy God is a jealous God, thou shalt not have strange gods before me'—meaning the idol of reason is a strange god and must be abandoned by those who commit to faith.
“biblical belief comes first and it is exclusive of all other beliefs the lord thy god is a jealous god thou shalt not have strange gods before me the idol of reason is a strange god”
We live in a frightening and horrific world where we are faced with miserable, soul-wrenching choices that ultimately amount to what Kierkegaard calls a 'flip of the philosophical coin'—the most important decisions have no rational grounding.
“we live in a frightening horrific world where we are faced with miserable soul-wrenching choices that ultimately amount to a flip of the philosophical coin the emphasis on subjectivity the loss of certainty the loss of orientation the the argument that essentially there is no ultimate rule no ultimate rational algorithm which will allow us to discern good from evil”
Kierkegaard's decision to write his doctoral dissertation on Socratic irony, and his entire approach to philosophical writing, reflects his belief that irony is essential for communicating the paradoxes and absurdities of genuine faith—something that cannot be explained directly but must be experienced through ironic contrast.
“he wrote his doctoral dissertation on irony on socratic irony the whole book is an ironic treatment of irony his supervising professors found it enormously unpleasant they said you're an awfully impressive guy but i never want to read anything like this again irony is one of the things that cure god relishes so much because having put himself through this harrowing theological experience he feels that it is very difficult for him to explain to people what the significance of the ultimate moral theological choice is”
Kant and Kierkegaard are perfect paradigms of the thinking they represent—respectively, Enlightenment rationalism and Romanticism—and both made comments about the same biblical story (Abraham's trial) that highlights the advantages and disadvantages of each position regarding faith and reason.
“in order to get across to you the difference between the either and the or and in order to get across to you the difference between say the enlightenment and romanticism in order to get across to you the difference between kant and kierkegaard i think we should choose to examine the theology of these two gentlemen kant and kierkegaard because they are perfect paradigms of the kind of thinking that they represent and fortunately for us kant and kierkegaard were considered enough to both make comments about the same biblical story at least one of them maybe more than one but there's at least one biblical story that both of them talk about and it connects the problems of faith and reason”
There is no up or down in the modern world; you take your best shot and live the life you choose, which is the grim perspective Kierkegaard offers—justified by the fact that it increases consciousness and makes us think deeply.
“there is no up there is no down you take your best shot and you live the life you choose this is what kierkegaard offers to us a rather grim perspective on the world justified perhaps by the fact that it makes us think that it increases our own consciousness”
Kierkegaard's essay 'The Rotation of Crops' traces the origin of boredom and culture back to God's own boredom—God created humanity because God was bored, and human culture itself (the Tower of Babel, civilization) is ultimately a product of humanity's desperate attempt to fill the void of meaninglessness with trivial distractions.
“god created man because he was bored adam was alone he was bored he asked for eve adam and eve were born together they had some children then they were bored on familia and then people multiplied and reproduced and they were then they were bored on moss and everywhere boredom took over the world eventually people created the tower of babel which is an idea that is as boring as the tower is high and the reason they did that is sheer boredom that's the only reason people put together culture at all”
The Either/Or is a remarkable literary work not only for its philosophical content but for its literary technique—Kierkegaard's ability to imaginatively inhabit the consciousness of aesthetic and ethical persons and describe their experiential states is unmatched among philosophers.
“there are very few authors who can project their mind into the consciousness of a hypothetical other person better than kierkegaard when he writes about what it's like to be an aesthetic individual a fascinating piece of work”
Kant's conception of God reveals what he considers virtue: God likes moral rules for their own sake, obeys them perfectly, and reflects Kant's own personality with its vices removed—Kant's God is essentially a 'super Kant' with Prussian orderliness.
“kant'wood wins to hear that kind of a belief is that any god worth believing in is where is going to be rational i mean that's part of what makes him virtuous think about the content conception of morality and then you think about the content conception of god and you're going to find out that kant's god is oppression because god likes moral rules just for the sake of having them he likes rules and he obeys them perfectly which is what a prussian god would do in other words kant's god looks remarkably like kant with all his vices taken away in other words he's the super kant he always obeys the ci”
Humans are naturally born into the aesthetic life with a predisposition toward pursuing pleasure, which Kierkegaard interprets as analogous to the concept of original sin—the natural depravity of the human condition.
“god believes that that is natural to human beings that we are born into the world of the flesh the world of space and time and that the natural rational orientation of human beings will be the pursuit of pleasure either physical or intellectual and as a matter of practical fact if you look back in history it's not hard to find people that like pleasure it's not even hard to find them now it is a natural state of human affairs this unfortunate tendency this fact that we are born into the aesthetic life or that it is it is the most natural and in this sense of natural reason the most reasonable choice that human beings particularly untutored human beings can make nietzsche think or god thinks that that's the analog of original sin”
Kierkegaard recommends reading 'Either/Or' with a diary called 'The Diary of the Seducer,' which is particularly in keeping with depicting the aesthetic man's consciousness.
“i particularly recommend a piece called the diary of the seducer which is very much in keeping with the aesthetic man kierkegaard then one of the great romantic theologians”