definition

Great Books Speak Down Through Irony

Every great book, and especially every Platonic dialogue, deliberately contains inferior arguments because Socrates speaks down to interlocutors who don't understand well; the reader's task is to take the deliberately inferior argument and raise it to the level the author actually intended—this downward shift and required elevation is irony, and analytic philosophy fails precisely because it lacks irony and refutes the deliberately inferior argument.

definitionpending

Speaker

Harvey Mansfield

Evidence Quote

“all great books have the character of speaking down to someone and presenting truth in an inferior but still attractive way. The reader has to take that shift in view and raise it to the level that the author had. What I’m describing is irony.”

Source

Conversations with Tyler - Harvey Mansfield— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:31:57 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...