instrumental rationality
Choosing the most efficient means (fastest, cheapest) to achieve a given single goal.
As defined in 164 | Herbert Gintis on Game Theory, Evolution, and Social Rationality
Other definitions
Rationality understood as the use of reason as a means to satisfy desires or achieve goals, rather than as the pursuit of truth or understanding for its own sake
Kierkegaard's Christian Existentialism
Where it comes up · 6
- 143 | Julia Galef on Openness, Bias, and Rationality2 claims
- Shadi Bartsch1 claim
- 164 | Herbert Gintis on Game Theory, Evolution, and Social Rationality1 claim
- 220 | Lara Buchak on Risk and Rationality1 claim
- Kierkegaard's Christian Existentialism1 claim
- A Quest For The Third Rome: Understanding Putin’s Apocalyptical Radicalization | Hoover Institution1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “instrumental rationality” →
- Rationality has two meanings: instrumental rationality (choosing efficient means to a single goal) and formal rationality (having transitive preferences—if you prefer A to B and B to C you prefer A to C); because people have multiple competing goals, instrumental rationality is often irrelevant, and formal rationality with transitive preferences is what lets us model behavior with mathematical decision theory.164 | Herbert Gintis on Game Theory, Evolution, and Social Rationality
- The added risk parameter is not mere curve-fitting because the goal is to capture what it is to reason instrumentally; taking the means to your ends does not require taking an average, and it is genuinely open to you how much weight to put on worst cases versus better cases, so this is a legitimate degree of freedom in rational choice rather than an arbitrary extra parameter.220 | Lara Buchak on Risk and Rationality
- Some Chinese intellectuals wage a rhetorical war against rationality as distinctively Western, focusing on Plato and Aristotle's claim that reason makes humans superior, and contrasting it with the Confucian value of ren (humaneness); they argue Western rationality has become too instrumental—science and technology pursued for their own sake without asking whether they are good for us or the planet—whereas they champion 'value rationality' that uses rational means to reach ethical ends, implying the West lacks a moral compass.Shadi Bartsch
- Rationality in Kierkegaard's framework is understood in Hume's sense—as instrumental rationality used as a means to satisfy desires—not rationality in the continental sense of comprehending ultimate reality.Kierkegaard's Christian Existentialism
- Religious scholars and others have noted that there are different types of rationalities—instrumental rationality (doing something to achieve a goal), epistemic rationality (doing something because it feels true), and rational irrationality (following a logical ideological argument that appears absurd to outsiders)A Quest For The Third Rome: Understanding Putin’s Apocalyptical Radicalization | Hoover Institution
- There are two senses of rationality: epistemic rationality, reasoning to make your beliefs as accurate as possible, and instrumental rationality, making decisions that effectively achieve your goals; many argue these conflict, claiming self-deception (soldier mindset) is sometimes instrumentally optimal for happiness or success.143 | Julia Galef on Openness, Bias, and Rationality
- In every specific case where people claim you must self-deceive to be happy, motivated, or successful, there is an alternative strategy that achieves the same goal without deception; people give up too soon and neglect this third option, when in fact you can make peace with reality rather than choosing between comforting falsehoods and misery.143 | Julia Galef on Openness, Bias, and Rationality