factual

Chinese Critique of Western Instrumental Rationality

Some Chinese intellectuals wage a rhetorical war against rationality as distinctively Western, focusing on Plato and Aristotle's claim that reason makes humans superior, and contrasting it with the Confucian value of ren (humaneness); they argue Western rationality has become too instrumental—science and technology pursued for their own sake without asking whether they are good for us or the planet—whereas they champion 'value rationality' that uses rational means to reach ethical ends, implying the West lacks a moral compass.

factualpending

Speaker

Shadi Bartsch

Evidence Quote

“they claim that ... Western rationality has become far too instrumental, by which they mean science for science’s own sake”

Source

Shadi Bartsch— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:29:07 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...