informed consent
The standard under experimental space-tourism licenses whereby companies are not liable for a participant's death because the participant accepted the known risks.
As defined in 213 | Timiebi Aganaba on Law and Governance in Space
Where it comes up · 5
- Megan McArdle on the Oedipus Trap3 claims
- 166 - The Plague Years2 claims
- Ezekiel Emanuel1 claim
- Sally Satel on Organ Donation1 claim
- 213 | Timiebi Aganaba on Law and Governance in Space1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “informed consent” →
- Caregivers and treaters have their own incentives—it is easier to manage a quiet, apathetic, sedated patient than an anxious or noisy one—and it is dangerously easy to convince yourself that what is good for you as the caregiver is also good for the patient, a problem evident in the historical use of lobotomy and persisting today in the sedation of dementia patients and difficult schoolchildren.Megan McArdle on the Oedipus Trap
- There is a fine ethical line between obtaining consent and obtaining informed consent: a patient with limited education may agree to an experimental trial without truly understanding it, putting the physician in a powerful position to either exploit or appropriately educate the patient.166 - The Plague Years
- Our evolved conception of informed consent exists precisely because we recognize that decisions cannot rest solely on what the family or caregiver wants—unlike children who cannot picture the future or grasp trade-offs and so need surrogate decision-makers, adults' treatment cannot be decided merely because a caregiver is tired of the patient being noisy.Megan McArdle on the Oedipus Trap
- American society wildly overemphasizes informed consent as a protection because giving people information and letting them decide ignores information overload, inertia, and the impossibility of evaluating everything; in low-trust societies or those lacking good institutions, relying on individuals is no substitute for institutions—we must trust expert and regulatory bodies the way we trust that airplanes are inspected.Ezekiel Emanuel
- The rigorous protocols and oversight (Institutional Review Boards) governing human experimentation today emerged from historical atrocities such as the Nazi doctors and the Tuskegee experiments, where physicians who policed themselves repeatedly justified horrific abuses; getting a drug trial approved now takes nearly a year of IRB review.166 - The Plague Years
- Exploitation genuinely applies in the black market, where poor sellers are offered a pittance (e.g. ~$2,000), rarely receive what they were promised, have no contracts, and no informed consent or post-operative care; an ethically sound legal system would instead require respect for the donor's autonomy, informed consent, generous reward, expressed gratitude, and guaranteed health insurance for complications.Sally Satel on Organ Donation
- The assumption that lobotomy patients had no informed consent is wrong—patients and families often thought deeply and thoughtfully about the decision, weighing genuinely terrible alternatives such as a violently disabled child spending life in a straitjacket; though convenience for caregivers was also sometimes a factor.Megan McArdle on the Oedipus Trap
- Space tourists hold the legal status of 'space flight participants,' and the experimental licenses states give tourism companies are built on an informed-consent standard—companies are not liable if a participant dies because the participant must understand and accept the risk—with a set number of years of this protection before the situation is reassessed and insurance markets develop from accumulated data.213 | Timiebi Aganaba on Law and Governance in Space