factual
Informed consent for lobotomy was more thoughtful than assumed
The assumption that lobotomy patients had no informed consent is wrong—patients and families often thought deeply and thoughtfully about the decision, weighing genuinely terrible alternatives such as a violently disabled child spending life in a straitjacket; though convenience for caregivers was also sometimes a factor.
factualpending
Speaker
Megan McArdleEvidence Quote
“these patients were often thinking deeply and thoughtfully about it, and not just about: 'Is it going to be more convenient to have my disabled child sitting quietly on the couch'”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:20:13 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...